Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › The Great Christmas Tree Dilemma...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Great Christmas Tree Dilemma...

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
The Great Christmas Tree Debate...

Ok, so we just got a fresh tree this year. For the first 7 years we used my Grandmothers old fake tree...but it shed more than any real tree could ever and I had no idea if it was full of lead or what! So we freecycled it (still had all the pieces to it! nice shape).

For the past three years we've gotten fresh trees. The first two years from a family farm - the organic tree wasn't as nice as the non-organic, but it was organic! and local! like winning the jackpot...

This year we ran out of time and went to a tree lot...in the dark...bought a tree...didn't realize the tree was spray painted until a few days later when I noticed the tree trunk was green as well...

So we can't very well compost that tree in the backyard...and it was expensive...hence the debate.

DH says buying a fake tree makes more $$$ sense. I say buying a real tree from a family farm is good $$$ for the local family, especially if they are raising the trees in an eco-friendly manner...

What is your take? What do you do? And how do you justify it as a good GREEN choice?

I'd love to get a plant-a-tree tree that I could plant after we use it to decorate it, but we don't have any land on which to plant it. I know there are other options...but which ones are the greenest?

Aside from having no tree at all, what do you do?
post #2 of 7
Yeah most people don't realize that on bad years when the needles aren't pretty enough they paint the trees. People just won't buy a tree that isn't green enough.

We buy a tree from a farmer that lives around where my mom lives. Helping her neighbors helps my mom after all. Most of our local stores carry her neighbor's trees. They are spray painted but I've never composted our tree for food purposes. Ours goes in the back yard, and is either used for fire wood in the summer or it just breaks down out there.
post #3 of 7
We had this debate the other night has we shelled out big money for something that will decorate our home for 10 days or so. At least our town takes all the treats and uses them for a fish habitat. But it just seems like a lot of money to waste on something that is so shortlived. I would almost rather not have a tree than to spend all this money. I don't know what we will do next year. Maybe we will go out after the first of the year and buy an artificial tree that is on sale.

Kathi
post #4 of 7
it's like any other "farm" crop - buy local.

I admit to not doing that, but I feel better putting my old tree, whatever it was sprayed with outside until all the needles fall off - or sending it to city tree "recycling" programs.
post #5 of 7
I am horrified that they spray paint trees!!! Really? That's awful!

We went to a local farm and cut our own tree down this year. They had a whole bunch of information saying that this is the greenest way to do it (assuming you can't buy a live tree and plant it later). I realize that reading this info at the tree farm meant it was biased. But I'm willing to believe it.

Their stance was that even though you are cutting a tree down, that tree did serve the earth for several years, cleaning the air etc etc. And by buying trees that are responsibly grown you are supporting an industry that HELPS the environment because they are growing plants.

They also had a lot to say about the non-eco friendly issues with fake trees - production, distribution, chemicals that might be in the tree, etc.

I too would like to find a way to do a live tree and plant it later. And we DO need trees in our yard. However nowhere around here does that. So I'm going to have to find someone with some land, some trees and willingness to let me take a shovel to them!
post #6 of 7
Thread Starter 
My kids are so upset that the tree was painted. They are greenies to the core and they (6yo and 3yo) want to start a tree farm so everyone has a good tree to choose from for free....they are so funny

we'll go to the organic family tree farm from now on...

although I did see a artificial tree made from 100% recycled plastic the other day...pretty pricey, but hey, it's nice to have the option
post #7 of 7
If you can compost or chip the tree for mulch, that's great. Buy local, of course!

We don't really have a choice. Real trees make it hard for me to breathe. So we have a gloriously fake tree.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Mindful Home
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › The Great Christmas Tree Dilemma...