Really well! DD got a bunch of hand-made stuff, some by me, some by others.
She LOVED a bat knitted by a friend of mine. We did a craft exchange -- she knits, I sew. So I sent her some felt food, and she knitted a bat my DD had seen and loved. DD is sleeping with batty-batty-bat right now.

I got two handmade pet houses for her stuffed friends off etsy, and those were a big hit.
I sewed the Peter Rabbit family. She spent most of the morning asking which was which.

Peter definitely got more attention than the other siblings, but that's what I expected. They were more there as accessories. I was surprised about how rough I noticed her being with them -- so far they've held up, and I'm hoping that continues! Oh, well, at least I know how to fix them.

I'll tell you, the one mainstream, big-box store item I bought her is so totally lame. This is very much a lesson for next year....