Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 4 yo DS scratching/hitting his 4 mo sister
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

4 yo DS scratching/hitting his 4 mo sister

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 
(XP to the childhood years)

The title pretty much says it all. We are SO upset that this is happening. Whenever DD begins to cry, he takes a quick swipe at her little bald head and often draws blood. DD has been quite high maintenance and clingy since birth and shrieks whenever we put her down in the swing/bouncer/floor, etc. We don't let her CIO, however. The crying is seemingly distressing for DS and he immediately lashes out at her. We have to watch him like a hawk to protect her....he is so fast. We don't spank, and he has NEVER shown any aggression toward anyone (in fact, quite the opposite!) so we have no idea where this is coming from.

He knows what he is doing is wrong, but he continues to do it...and it's unbelievably frustrating. He knows exactly what to say to appease us (e.g., "If I hit/scratch Molly, I have to go into time-out. It makes Mommy & Daddy sad when I hurt Molly. Hands are not for hitting, only for hugging.") Right now, the only recourse we have is to send him to time-out, but obviously, that isn't working. He really doesn't have any attachments to toys/TV/books or anything that we could take away as a punishment.

We have tried spending extra alone time with him, doing special things with him, etc. to no avail. We've tried role-playing what to do when he gets angry.

Can anyone offer any additional tips/tricks to curb this aggression/impulsive behavior? Please tell me it will get better. I'm at the end of my rope and so upset that my kids can't get along.

Thanks for reading.
post #2 of 3
I am so sorry. It will get better. I would encourage you to do more of the connecting if you can, spending time with him, making sure he knows you're there, baby him if he wants to do that, whatever. Anything to make sure he knows his needs will be met and you are there for him. And of course whatever you have to do to keep the baby safe so he can't get to her. Also, I would try to remove expectations right now. I firmly believe that more connection will help in the long run, but I wouldn't expect to see much right away, so don't give up on it if you aren't seeing results quickly. It's a long term process to meet a child's needs. You can't punish away his need for you and he will do whatever he has to do to get your attention *for his survival* - because that is what it boils down to. He needs to know that he will be ok even though there is a new baby now for you to take care of.

His reaction is purely unconscious and not intended to hurt her, I'm sure. I know the worry you feel and the sadness, because I was there too. The mama bear came out of me many times and it was really hard. My kids are 3.5 years apart and my sweet little boy would hit and hurt his baby sister and it just broke my heart. It was completely out of nowhere after he seemed to be in love with her from birth.

We got through it and you will too - just keep connecting and realize that it's an unconscious reaction and that he needs reassurance and calm parents. You're doing the right things, I think - just keep it up and increase as much as you can, and know that it will pass.
post #3 of 3
It's so hard, isn't? Our almost 4yo ds has recently started standing on our 8 month old dd. Really. He'll just kind of stand on top of her leg until she starts screaming. Makes me mad just thinking about it!

We've had a little success with giving him his own "baby" when the new one came. We let him treat that baby in any way he chooses. Some days he nurses his baby, others he throws him around the room. It seems to get some of his feelings out.

We also talk about things that his birthmom did for him when he was a baby. "When you were a baby, your birthmom carried you around a lot too." "you used to cry, too, when you were a baby. Your big sister and mommy would hold you and love you. Now you can help hold the new baby" etc. I think it helps him somewhat understand that all this love and care that goes out to the new baby was there for him as well, and now that he's bigger, he can do lots of things on his own and we're still here to help him.

All the best, it will get better!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 4 yo DS scratching/hitting his 4 mo sister