Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Potty learning for reluctant 4yo
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Potty learning for reluctant 4yo

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I need advice and encouragement! My dd is 4.5 and is still not interested in potty learning. We have tried introducing it since she was about 2--bought a potty, took her out shopping to pick out her own undies, brought home potty-themed books, let her pick out some stickers that she could use to keep track of her progress. We've tried several times, to no avail.

She's been at home until this year; I'd hoped at preschool (very small school, 3 mornings/week) she'd see other kids doing it. No effect.

I *really* want her to be experienced with the potty by the time she starts Kindergarten!

We've been very careful not to push it, not to make it a big deal. But the effect of that is that she just doesn't care or have any interest and so nothing has happened. (No older or younger sibs, very few neighborhood friends. Those friends she does have, as well as older cousins, don't want an audience when they're peeing.)

Does anyone have any advice? Today we began the process again, doing things very incrementally (she was out of her pull-up today twice for brief periods of time. Didn't use the potty, though). We made a chart, but she didn't seem all that excited about filling it in and getting rewards.

I keep being tempted to just say, okay, it's time. Here are your undies, no dipes during the day. But she's already resisting even the slightest hint of that, and I don't want it to become a battle of wills or a traumatic thing. We've tried talking about it as a grown-up accomplishment she can be proud of, and are hoping to go that route. But I'm just not sure what the heck we're doing. Any advice?
post #2 of 4
My ds had some pretty major potty issues. Still needs only dad to help with no. 2, and he's almost 6. It just takes some kids longer. I tried everything. Bribing, cajoling, tough talk. It did not help. Ds does not like to be pushed into anything.

Can you just leave it alone for a while? You have lots of time before K. And once your dd is ready, she'll be able to do it. If she's not ready next fall, you can worry about it then. HSing is great.

We were also concerned that ds was resisting reading and writing. So I stopped all efforts at actively teaching reading and writing around September. Low and behold, he picked up a pencil and just started writing a few weeks ago. Big, beautiful, evenly spaced and sized letters. He can also read pretty much anything he chooses. But he has to choose to do it. And he had to be ready.

Good luck. It is very trying I know.
post #3 of 4
My DS was very resistant as well...I tried bribing, books, you name it...nothing worked. It just so happened that about 2-3 months before his 4th birthday, he got SUPER excited about his upcoming b-day (one of his good friends had a party before him and that got him talking) and how he was going to be a BIG boy, etc.
I told him that his birthday WAS coming, but that being a big boy meant that he used the potty...b/c babies use diapers, not big boys. For whatever reason, THAT made it click...at that moment...I had tried that terminology several months before and it never bothered him...he said he was fine being a baby...the potty scared him
So, I would maybe walk away from it for a week or two, and then revisit it again.
I know my grandmother always tells the story of how *I* got potty trained...I saw some cute frilly panties (with ruffles on the back) and wanted them SO badly. She told me that I couldn't have them b/c I was still using diapers, and that was ALL it took for me to use the potty...the incentive of my frilly underwear So you never know what might work!
I can tell you, it has been an EASY road once my DS decided he was ready...we went from diapers, straight to underwear day and night, and he's had no accidents! So, even though I HATED that he was almost 4 years old by the time he was trained...I didn't go through all the drama and tears of forcing him to train before he was truly ready!
Good Luck!! I know it's frustrating!
post #4 of 4
Thread Starter 
Wow, no accidents! Thanks both of you for these encouraging replies. We've made it into undies over the last two days, but with accidents instead of using the potty. . . . We'll see what tomorrow holds. I hesitate to back off at this point since I don't want her to think I don't know she can do it. But I'll follow her lead and see. We did have a panty party with all of her stuffed animals and that seemed to help get things started.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Potty learning for reluctant 4yo