Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › first post in forum - spiritual authority
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

first post in forum - spiritual authority

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
I'm having a hard time with some church related stuff right now.

It's hard to sum up without writing a novel. Churchwise, we are conservative evangelicals and part of a plant from another church in the area, so our church is less than a year old.

The past few years have been quite challenging for my family, so we were already in quite a vulnerable state when Oct 2008 we found I was expecting and unplanned 3rd baby. I had PPD after my 1st baby, but not my 2nd, but knowing how much more vulnerable I felt, I expected depression, just not as soon as it hit, partly I was extremely exhausted, not just the regular 1st trimester stuff, but also because of stopping meds for narcolepsy, so early symptoms got mixed up with those symptoms and I didn't get on meds soon enough, iirc it was April last year

As soon as I went on meds we went in to see our pastor, mainly to get encouragement and ideas for trying to keep faithful whilst I recovered as I'd found that when I'd had PPD before I'd pretty much shut down that part of my life, but as I recovered, it recovered too.

Turned out he was looking for demonic activity, something I'd not even considered, but with my illness, I accepted it as a possibility and agreed to go through a process of casting out demons, which seemed to reveal somethings, but also frightened me, raised my blood pressure. I've not had much time to study demonic activity, but from what little I do know, I definitely think it's possible, but that it's only a possible part of depression, not the cause or the cure.

Unfortunately my depression didn't seem to respond to the first things we tried and then one drug made me very unstable, not manic, but swinging through anger, paranoia, all sorts of things, which unsurprisingly caused a few very difficult situations, including ones where the pastor yelled at me to grow up. In the middle of October I finally figured out that these were probably caused by a drug, not needing another drug to treat and within a week I was back to normal, though normal was still a depressed normal. Then about 6wks ago I started wellbutrin and it's been a complete turn around, I finally not just bawling my eyes out most of the day, which was what had been happening until then.

Because our pastor identified relationship issues as a trigger, he sent us to a christian counsellor, who I was initially quite encouraged by, though disappointed with my husbands response and by early december I'd decided that he wasn't the right counsellor for me and I told the pastor this, his response was to ask that I signed a disclosure form so he could speak with the counsellor, I think I responded something like why, I've already decided he's not working for me, to which the pastor implied that he would make that decision for me.

There was then an incident that I posted in the lactivism forum, it's still on the first page I think "another bf in church incident". Which is the last time I've spoken to the pastor. We did see the counsellor again and my husband signed the disclosure form, but the counsellor has said he doesn't feel he can separate us out and talk to the pastor about one of us and not the other, which I respect him for.

I tried to speak to the pastor about exactly why he wanted the form signed and what he hoped to acheive from it, but my phone messages are not being returned and email messages are being intercepted and replied to by his assistant. The message seems to be you know why he wants it signed (which I don't feel I do) and he won't see you until you've signed it (which to me is coercion, whether I'm right or wrong in intially not signing it.

I'm aware that as I'm going through this, I'm less better than my superficial happy mood would indicate, as my thought are drifting to bad ones far too often.

So I feel STUCK, I don't feel it's a good idea for my long term mental health to sign, I don't feel that once the information is out of a medical office with the laws that protect privacy that it's going to remain private. But I'm not even allowed to talk to the pastor to discuss these issues.

My husband points out that this pretty much means I'll have to leave the church, or I'll be removed from it for failure to submit to spiritual authority. But that he wouldn't support me in that. He believes me not signing is purely stubborness and not wanting to submit to spiritial authority, I can give numerous reasons that I don't think it's a good idea, but ultimately thay may not be sufficiently strong to excuse me from needing to submit to spiritual authority, I'm still in prayer on that one. But what bothers me is that whilst they wait on me, I'm not allowed to speak with the pastor, because whilst I don't think one sin excused another, it can certainly give you cause for concern and I feel he's exercising his authority in an unloving manner and I know ultimately he'll answer for that.

I need wisdom, I need opportunities to speak with friends who aren't in this church, but know me and know the situation and so might be able to speak wisdom into this.

Obviously we all need prayer!
post #2 of 11
I'm sorry mama, that sounds rough.

I'm not christian, but my first thought was that maybe there is another church of the same religion with another pastor who might be a better match for you, and have better boundaries. I don't personally beleive one person has any closer or more direct line to G-d than another, so I don't think I completely understand the concept of submitting to spiritual authority. However, to me, it sounds like a misuse of spiritual authority. It's one thing for the pastor to ask why the counselor didn't work for you, so he could help you find someone else, or to act as a counselor for you, but coercing you into signing away your privacy without explaining why he wants you to sounds wrong.

I say listen to your intuition, and talk to your husband about your concerns. I admit I don't understand the concept of spiritual authority, however, it seems to me that your concern is legitimate and you need to talk with your husbands about your concerns, and try to find a way to help him understand what your issues with it are.

(again, personally, I'd be running to find another church with a different pastor, however I realize that may not be an option in your religion.)

s
post #3 of 11
annekh23

I feel you are in a very vulnerable state. Let me say first of all this has nothing to do with spiritual authority. I am a christian. I believer your pastor is WELL out of order. Please talk to your husband about this. Remind him of the verses about how a husband is to love his wife, do this prayerfully. This is an issue between you, your husband and God. Is it possible to distance yourself from the church, whatever you do dont sign those forms. If you feel a strong conviction about this, follow that.

I level with you. It sounds like you are in the middle of a very difficult season in your life. What you need is support and understanding, mostly from your husband. What you are going thru sounds like something I went thru a few years ago, Im sure its not identical, I would agree with you here...

Quote:
I definitely think it's possible, but that it's only a possible part of depression, not the cause or the cure.
What I learned during that time was that while demonic activity played a role, I was lacking the chemicals needed to keep me from being depressed. A doctor will tell you about that. What the demonic activity is is the substance of the thoughts, what you are thinking about, the actual fears, the anxiety, feelings are physical, but the actual thoughts were demonic. I couldnt control the physical reactions until I could control the thoughts and I did need antidepressants to help. It becomes a downward spiral. The thoughts will feed the physical reactions and the physical reactions will go on to feed more fearful thoughts and so on.

Can we talk about your relationship with your husband? You can pm me if you want but I want to know how he is with you. Is he patient? Is he understanding? I dont want to slam him but I cant understand why he'd side with the pastor and not with you. Is he becoming impatient with this illness? Or am I misunderstanding something here?

It sounds like a sticky situation and a sensitive one. Lean on Christ thru this. If you have no one on your side, your dh, the pastor in your church, Lean on Christ and follow His lead!
Quote:
"...Fear not, for I have redeemed you;
I have summoned you by name; you are mine.

2 When you pass through the waters,
I will be with you;
and when you pass through the rivers,
they will not sweep over you.
When you walk through the fire,
you will not be burned;
the flames will not set you ablaze.

3 For I am the LORD, your God,
the Holy One of Israel, your Savior;
please keep us posted and feel free to pm me if you want to
post #4 of 11
Also, it makes me very annoyed that a pastor of a church doesnt know how to handle things like this. He is handling your situation ALL wrong. I dont know if you realise that he is ALL wrong, from sending you to the councellor to demanding that you sign a disclosure so he can speak with your councellor. These are major red flags imho. I pray sincerely that your dh can see this very clearly and very soon.
post #5 of 11
Your pastor does not sound like he is showing Jesus! Jesus wants you to be healed and at peace.

You answer to God first! Then your husband! THEN to your pastor? I put a question mark because a pastor would not and should not be this deeply into your "stuff".

If you say no then the answer is NO!!!!
post #6 of 11
Is there a regional authority for your church's denomination? If church authority is a big thing for y'all, they might be able to help you connect with a different pastor, without you having to leave the "authority".

In my understanding, submission is a personal and voluntary thing. We are told to submit to proper authority. However, the authority figures are *not* told to demand submission, or manipulate, punish, or threaten in order to get it. They are told to humble themselves and that they will be held to stricter account than the rest of us. There are things for which church discipline is called for, but not signing a disclosure form is not one of them. So if that would put you out of the church, then the church is dysfunctional by Biblical standards.

I have known some very sweet and well-intentioned people who got caught up on this kind of dysfunction. Authority and accountability were taken much, much too far. And even though the pastor had a sincere desire to help people and had love for all the people who he was ministering too, he caused many people a whole lot of pain. Dh and I love that pastor and his family and the people in the church but dh especially recognized the wrongness of what was going on and chose to pull away gracefully before we got in deeper and ended up butting heads.
post #7 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by cappuccinosmom View Post
Is there a regional authority for your church's denomination? If church authority is a big thing for y'all, they might be able to help you connect with a different pastor, without you having to leave the "authority".
My tradition (Orthodox Christianity) actually allows for something like thing. Part of our spiritual disciplines is regular Confession with a priest (how regular is determined between you and your spiritual father - usually the one you confess to). Often the spiritual father is your parish priest, your pastor. But sometimes for a variety of reasons, it doesn't work for the parish priest to be your spiritual father/confessor. So, with his blessing (OK), you go to another priest for Confession, but you do have to let your pastor know you've gone for Confession. Sometimes parish priest might check with other priest to confirm you've gone for Confession, just to make sure, but there's no discussion of what was said in Confession - that's HUGE no-no!
post #8 of 11
Hugs to you OP.

I have seen both counselors and my pastoral staff, but I would never sign a disclosue to my pastor from a couselor or therapist. What goes on in therapy is not something you shouls ever feel pressured to disclose.

I also do not think that not disclosing the contents of your therapy sessions falls under the purview of spiritual authority. IMO, your pastor is abusing his role. Even if that is not his intention, I do not see how he could ever regain your trust. That makes him the wrong pastor for your family.

I would also suggest looking for a Licensed Therapist to go and see. You can call them ahead of time and ask them about religion if that is imporatant to you. (I have called offices for my patients and I just say, it is really important to my client that they see a counselor with similar religious views. Are you ______? If not, I ask them if they could refer me to any therapists that are.
post #9 of 11
Nevermind.
post #10 of 11
I read the discussion in the lactavist forum as well, and I think you really need to leave this church.

The pastor may be well-meaning, but he should not be in this position of authority - he doesn't seem cut out for it at all.

And I don't want to sound terrible, but I think this is a real problem with non-denominational groups with no authority over their pastors (which I seem to recall from the other thread is the case.) There is no accountability in the leadership.

This church seems to be about manipulating people, and power plays, and that is not helping anyone. Your husband is I'm sure trying to do the right thing, but he needs to realize that some authorities, aren't.
post #11 of 11
What a mess. This pastor sounds like a control freak. I think this is a huge problem with Evangelical church splits with no heirarchy. no one to oust the pastor when he starts acting like he has been possessed by the demonic influence of power, manipulation, and control. I have seen it so much and is ultimately why I left the evangelical church. you end up having one man running the show. who may or may ne have stable doctrine.

first of all I would avoid this pastor as much as possible. This church is not a safe place for you. the question is though, since you husband seems fully on board, how much are you willing to stand your ground on things if it efects your marriage? how much are you willing to play along to keep the peace in your home? would they be willing to compromise? could you see another counselor and release those records to your pastor? it may be a waste of your time but at least you can say whatever it is they want to hear.

and this is a matter of spiritual warfare. I would start praying non-stop that you and your family would get out of this church and that your husbands eyes would be open. and if they ask you how you are doing say fine and mention that your prayer life is reaching new heights.....you can even thank them for their part in this.

I have a very close relationship to my preist and there is noting I would feel uncomfortable sharing with him (ok I would be uncomfortable but that wouldn't stop me) but I would be quite taken aback if he asked me to release medical records to him. that seems like overstepping. and before I did sign things over i would go above him and talk to the bishop to make sure he had the spiritual athourity to ask for such things. But I think he would rather hear it from me anyway, and doubt he would ask for such things ever.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Spirituality
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › first post in forum - spiritual authority