Ain't never had a leak with the rice, and I've used it overnight--but I have really absorbent diapers and doublers, since DS has unexpected heavy wetting moments I have to be prepared for at all times. I haven't had it more than a few weeks though, and I can see what she means about the oatmeal beíng SUPER waterproof--but I think the Rice works great and you don't have a heavy wetter and go nuts for softness, so GET THE RICE! Or better yet, one of each!
Re: this game--for those of us who truly don't need another thing, I think it's important that we take a breather, let all our miscellaneous custom orders arrive, take time to evaluate all our recent and even slightly-less-recent purchases (it takes awhile to figure out how you really feel about a dipe or cover, I think!), and plan future purchases wisely, rather than just for thrill seeking. I know at this rate I'm going to have a 5,000 stash by summertime, and we can't afford that, it's insane. I love supporting WAHMs, but my new, young family needs to save up for our first home! Wish me luck in getting my habit under control, guys, truly.