Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Silly Old Article with the STUPIDEST pro-circ Reason!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Silly Old Article with the STUPIDEST pro-circ Reason!

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
This is a way old article, and was probably already posted on here back in 2005, but there was one quote I wanted to call attention to because it was SOOO unbelievable!

http://www.cirp.org/news/edmontonjournal09-12-05/

The quote was, "“In the U.S. if you’re not circumcised, it means generally that you’re an immigrant, the son of immigrants or you’re very poor.”

Schoen says it’s a tragedy that anti-circ groups have successfully lobbied legislatures in 13 states, including California, not to cover the cost of circumcision for welfare patients.

“Poor people in this country know if a boy is uncircumcised and somebody sees him in the locker room that ... he’s at a social disadvantage so they scrape together enough money to pay for circumcision even though they can’t afford it.”"


I will be honest... I heave heard of uncut boys being made fun of in the locker room. However, I have never heard of it being done because of their economic status. Plus, it isn't as if your son is going to have to whip out his penis when applying for a job to prove that he is from the good side of the tracks.

I just could not believe that any Doctor would promote a surgery on the basis of teasing in change rooms. I know he had other reasons in the article too, but the fact he even included this one shocks me. I hope in the last five years he has come to his senses.
post #2 of 7
Consider who is being quoted. Schoen is a well know ADVOCATE of RIC, who gives misleading information, specualtion, and biased information.

In this quote he is specualting on why kids are teasing their peers. My guess is he has not even asked a single kid why he teased another about their foreskin. Probably never even tried to find one. He is attributing a lot to the the kids' thought process with no data, most likely.

This is simply rumor mongering., designed to make peole feel uncomfortable if they are thinking about leaving their sons intact.

Regards
post #3 of 7
Yep and many pro-circs take him to truth on a high basis but what they don't realize is that he is not only favorable for RIC on Males but for girls as well.
post #4 of 7
Isn't there a website with a selection of quotes and poems from Dr Schoen? This one should be added to it. The man's words should speak for themselves when people think his information is credible.
He used to be on the AAP taskforce, btw.
Oh, here are his poems...
http://www.circumstitions.com/Schoens.html

Jessica
post #5 of 7
That guy's not going to come to his senses till he's in his grave. He writes poetry about circumcised penises for God's sake.

I wouldn't waste your time worrying about that one.
post #6 of 7
Thread Starter 
New Reality TV Show Idea: Him and Freud in a locked room.
post #7 of 7
Did you ever wonder how there are still men alive in Europe? It must be a miracle.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Silly Old Article with the STUPIDEST pro-circ Reason!