Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Toddlers › "Baby Can Read" DVD's
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

"Baby Can Read" DVD's

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
Talk to me about your experience with 'Baby can Read' DVD's.

My DD is 15 months, and I know that the absolute best thing for teaching a child to read is to sit down with them and read as much as possible right from infancy. I do that pretty much every day, for a realistic 15-30 minutes. That doesn't sound like much, but I'm sure its more then the average (though probably far below the MDC average.)

My issue isn't that I'm intent on her reading at a crazy-young age. Of course I want her to do well, but if she starts reading at 5 or 6 that would be fine. My problem is that she goes to a babysitter during the day, and the sitter always has the T.V. on. This is the ONLY bad thing I can say about the babysitting arrangement, and no other daycare setting would be even close to as good as the current one. There is one other little boy who is 20 months, and he doesn't even glance at the TV, but my dd does. She has a pretty good attention span and is very mild mannored, and by her nature she pays attention. I don't need my kid paying attention to sponge bob and whatever other garbage they put on the kids channels!

It just seems like if she is going to be absorbing something from a TV screen then something like "baby can read" would be better then the repulsive "cartoons." This is if I could even convince the babysitter to change out the tv to a dvd.

Any thoughts?
post #2 of 6
Hmmm, this is a tricky situation. Have you talked with the sitter about the TV issue? You have every right to as a parent and if you bring it up in a non-confrontational way she ought to be a professional and listen to your concerns. If there's no way you can convince her to turn the TV off I think you're on the right track trying to find shows you'd at least be more comfortable with. Sure, it's a compromise, but we can't avoid them sometimes. I don't know about Our Baby Can Read DVDs, but maybe you can check out your library for some kids' DVDs and see if there are any you like (or at least don't dislike too much!). My daughter's seen a bit of classic Sesame Street and the Muppets and she enjoys it for a few minutes at least (her attention span isn't that long!). If you feel good about some you can buy them and let the sitter use them if she's really dead set on having the TV on.
post #3 of 6
I don't see any harm in bringing the subject up, like pp said. Honestly, I use the TV as a "babysitter" when I shower in the morning and sometimes when I make supper, if it's labor intensive. I set him in the play yard we have and he gets to play with special toys and watch Winnie the Pooh. It's wonderful. But if it's on as background noise all the time...I'd have a problem with that too. Maybe just ask what kinds of shows are watched and ask if the discovery channel or something can be put on. I'd think a musical show like Raffi, sesame street or the discovery channel (all those vivid plants and animals) would be more worth while than Baby Can Read DVDs, but I think the DVDs are really just a scam like Baby Einstein.
post #4 of 6
What about sign language DVDs like Signing Time? Rather than trying to teach her to read, it would teach her another language that may help her communicate more. The biggest worry I have about teaching a child so young to read is the lack of maturity to understand the things being read. There are things that I have read on walls and billboards that make ME blush...I don't want my 2 year old reading that...
post #5 of 6
Or what about just asking that the tv be set to pbs?? Thats what we watch. They have lots of good shows on and its all kids programming from like 6:00am-5 or 5:30pm. Dinosaur train, Super Why (reading program), Word World (reading), Sesame Street, Clifford, etc. All nice & gentle & many teach reading or math or something too.
post #6 of 6
I too was going to suggest Signing Time or even maybe a music DVD like ThatBabyDVD..... We try not to do too much TV in our house and was one of the main reasons we changed providers. (one of my mainissues with TV besides the attention issues it causes, is the advertising....)

We gave our DCP music CDs which she occasionally used too but not enough (but we replace TV with music in my house LOL)

Good luck mama....
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Toddlers
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Toddlers › "Baby Can Read" DVD's