Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Ironic "Benjamin Button" homebirth story
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Ironic "Benjamin Button" homebirth story

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
Well, I tried to watch a movie during early contractions to distract myself, and of course, I turned on The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Little did I know, the first scene involves a husband coming home to his wife who has died in childbirth and discovering a baby who is deformed (he then tries to run away and throw the baby in the river). Well, needless to say, I turned that movie off right away, but I was interested in the F. Scott Fitzgerald version of the story and googled it today. Here is the opening paragraph:

"As long ago as 1860 it was the proper thing to be born at home. At present, so I am told, the high gods of medicine have decreed that the first cries of the young shall be uttered upon the anaesthetic air of a hospital, preferably a fashionable one. So young Mr. and Mrs. Roger Button were fifty years ahead of style when they decided, one day in the summer of 1860, that their first baby should be born in a hospital. Whether this anachronism had any bearing upon the astonishing history I am about to set down will never be known."


Isn't that interesting? That the original story was of a horrifying hospital birth, but the modern directors of the movie changed it to a homebirth?? Makes you think, huh?
post #2 of 10
Interesting. I too watched that movie while pregnant and I regretted it. Not what I wanted to see as a homebirthing mama (or any mama...I didn't think about it being about the "home" part so much as just the birthing in general).
post #3 of 10
Very interesting! Thanks for sharing. Leave it to Hollywood....
post #4 of 10
I haven't seen this & will now be crossing it off my to watch list until the pregnancy hormones are more level...
post #5 of 10
huh. interesting! I watched (and loved!) that movie several months ago--can't remember if I was pg yet or not--but I totally missed the first couple minutes. I was either zoned out or dealing with kids, I imagine...but whatever, I totally missed that they'd portrayed it as a homebirth! LOL! Now I need to watch it again...
post #6 of 10
oooh that totally makes me mad!!!
post #7 of 10
That's really interesting. Now I will have to get the original version and check it out.

I loved this movie (and yes, I cried my eyes out- PP mamas should wait awhile) but it was a different birth in the movie that stuck with me: When Benjamin's wife gives birth at home after the traumatic fall down the stairs. I've been chewing on this for a while. Not sure if the drama/danger of the fall reflects poorly on homebirth or not. Or does the lack of any direct commentary on her giving birth at home show support for such an event. Or neither- maybe it was only following the book?

Just wondering what anyone else thought about that part of the movie???
post #8 of 10
Thread Starter 
I couldn't figure out if she was at their home or in a birthing room or house for that purpose. I think she said to call an ambulance after she fell and it didn't seem like it was their house, although maybe I was wrong. Interesting...
post #9 of 10
Its been awhile since I've seen in but I can only remember the birth of Benjamin's daughter. It seemed to be a positive home birth and nobody made a big deal about that the baby was born at home.
post #10 of 10
hmmmm....Very curious
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Homebirth
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Ironic "Benjamin Button" homebirth story