Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › Convenience over your children's friendships -- should I feel guilty?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Convenience over your children's friendships -- should I feel guilty?

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I'm a single mom with 2 jobs (one very part time, one about 50 hours a week) 1 child, a dog, and grad school. Life is a little crazy around here, and recently I'm feeling like I never have enough time, the house is a mess, my kid is regularly going to bed to late etc . . .

We're planning on moving within the next six months to have a little more wiggle room in the budget, and to get DS into a good middle school program. I've basically narrowed it down to 2 choices. The schools are very similar -- big public schools, with strong academic reputations, lots of diversity and IB curriculums.

1) Is in the city I live in now. There are no school buses, and it's about a 20 minute drive from work. I'd probably need to drive 30 minutes from where I live to get him to school each day, and then 20 minutes to work because I couldn't afford anything closer to the school. He'd have to go to some kind of afterschool activity each day, because I wouldn't be able to leave work until about 5:30 which means we'd be getting home at the earliest around 6:30 with homework unstarted, the dog to walk, etc . . . We'd also end up putting the dog in daycare more which means a longer drive in another direction to pick up drop off, just because 7:30 to 6:30 is too long for him to be alone. BUT he's got 6 or 7 close friends going to this school next year. He's a very social kid, but also a little shy, so of course this is where he wants to go.

2) Next door suburb (note these 2 schools are 10 minutes apart). He rides the school bus, and then either goes to aftercare (where he can do homework) or grandma's (where he can do homework) or home (where he can do homework AND walk the dog), so when I'd get home around 6:00 (maybe even earlier because I could be at work much earlier -- he gets on the bus at 7:00, I'm at work by 7:30, as opposed to 9:00 which is when I'd probably get to work at the other school). Dog daycare is across the street from the apartment. I'd be walking in the door at 5:00 to 6:00 to homework at least started (for one of us), and a dog that's already been exercised or at the very least peed. Plus apartments cost less here. BUT he knows exactly 1 kid out of 1200 who go to this school, and she's a girl who will be in 8th grade (he'll be in 6th) which means no recess or P.E. or electives or anything together.

He of course votes for #1, and I do think socially it would be great for him, but that school bus is calling my name! Am I an irresponsible mom if I prioritize sanity of schedule over his social life.

I should note that I'm the "activity mom" on the weekend. I'm always rounding up a gang of kids to go for a hike or an ice skating outing, or a ski trip or the pool, and would continue so he'd still see his old friends on the weekends.
post #2 of 6
My life is far different from yours (we homeschool, but I work about 30 hrs/wk and am also a part-time college student) and my kids are former military brats so they're used to moving, but I would go for option #2.

Your son, though shy, will make friends at his new school. Aside from the issue of friends, it seems like option 2 has way more advantages over option 1.

However, I would focus on the cost of living and the quality of time you'll have together, and not on the bus. I know the bus factor is a big deal for you, but kids generally do not appreciate such things. Emphasize the fact that saving money on housing means you will have more to spend on fun/enriching things and activities, and that less driving around will mean nicer lives overall.
post #3 of 6
Thread Starter 
I think maybe we're looking at the bus from different angles. For me the bus is huge because it's why everything works. It's why he can come home right after school or go to Grandma's (she lives on the same bus route), and why I don't have an hour commute in the morning, so I can get to work early and thus leave early. He'd be fine on the bus. For one thing he's already got a friend to ride it with (he wouldn't see her all day because the grades are separate but they'd be on the bus together). He also loves the bus he takes to camp -- I think he loves it more than camp itself which is saying a lot.

Frankly if school #1 had a bus the decision would be super easy.
post #4 of 6
No, I totally understand the reasons why you love the bus. I'm saying that, IME, kids generally do not appreciate the things that make life easier for their parents. Kids appreciate the things that make life easier for them. So, the other positives (extra money, extra time together, etc.) will be more apparent to him and easier for him to relate to.

Of course, I don't know your particular kid. I'm just going by the other kids I know, including my own.
post #5 of 6
I would go for #2.

Kids make friends very easily and having an 8th grader as a close friend, already, is awesome for a middle schooler. Plus, that fact that she will be riding the bus with him is even nicer.

A saner schedule and less financial stress will allow you to be a more present and available mama... that is really what your child needs more than anything else, especially during those middle school years.
post #6 of 6
#2. HANDS DOWN.

Yes, he has friends at #1 - but thats his only reason for wanting that right? He may be shy, but he'll make friends. Theres 1200 kids at #2 - there will friends to find.

Don't tell him that you want him to go there b/c of the bus - tell him you want him to go there for all the reasons that 2xy said. But, you are welcome to keep the little secret that you love love love that bus! And focus on all the positive aspects of it. Trust me, by the time he's in 8th grade he's not going to want you picking him up and dropping him off at school everyday - that was so embarassing for my brothers at that age!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Single Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › Convenience over your children's friendships -- should I feel guilty?