Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Unassisted Childbirth › conflicted re: homebirth with CNM vs UC again
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

conflicted re: homebirth with CNM vs UC again

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I cross-posted this over in Homebirth, but I'd love some thoughts/opinions from UCers as well.

After what I consider a traumatic hospital birth with CNMs with my ds, we decided on a UC for my dd. It went perfectly. Now I've got ds2 coming in the Spring and I had decided to go with a home birth CNM for this one for a couple reasons, mainly because I was thinking I'd like the support of another woman this time around, and because my dh will be busy with 2 kids instead of one. Part of me feels like it's the responsible thing to do this time; however there's a small yet substantial voice that's been getting louder the further along I get that has me somewhat anxious as far as 1.) having the mw there, who I'll only have seen less than a dozen times before the birth and thus won't really "know", and 2.) having one of her assistants there, who I won't have met more than once or twice. I having a huge problem getting comfortable with having what amounts to a sort-of-stranger and a for-certain-stranger in my home, during labor and birth. It's probably just a throw back to her being a CNM and my previous hospital experience with another one, i.e., I'm apprehensive that she's going to pull a switcheroo on me during labor and become very hands-on, but she assured me she's comfortable just hanging out and knitting unless we want her more involved. Thoughts? Opinions? Sometime someone on the outside can see these things more clearly. This is the third time around and I thought I'd be as rock-solid in my decisions as I was last time, but something's definitely keeping my brain in re-think mode.
post #2 of 6
I'm a homebirther, so I guess I found the wrong thread. But I have seen lots of mamas in the HB section find midwives who are willing to be very hands-off.

If you decide you want a midwife, interview a couple of them and see if they would be comfortable staying in the next room until you asked for her.
post #3 of 6
Does it have to be a midwife? If you're just looking for support and an extra pair of hands- your mom? A friend? Hire a doula? Hire a doula JUST to look after your other kids so your husband can be the support you need?

And I hear you on the sort of a stranger thing in your home. I have a very UC friendly friend who has offered to come doula for the birth of this little dude (who really needs to COME OUT sometime soon!) but I don't know her *that* well, and I don't really want to call her unless we're really feeling the need for more hands or care for my DD. But at the same time, I know now that I'd feel the same with pretty much anyone else in my space, even my sister or best friend- they'll throw off my vibe.
post #4 of 6
Thread Starter 
Well that's just it exactly. I'm getting a little concerned about feeling invaded upon in my space as it were. I like the mw I'm working with well enough, it's just having someone else in your space at such a vulnerable time and in such an intimate environment is starting to really make me second-guess my decision. I think that what's underneath it is a combo of feeling like my UC went so well last time that I'm jinxing myself or something by having another UC, and that feeling in the back of my head that she might be like the hospital CNMs I had the first time around and pull the rug out from under me halfway through. I think that second thought is very unlikely since she comes highly recommended and has a great reputation but I can't help worrying. I suppose all the autonomy last time has spoiled my outlook.
post #5 of 6
I think a good midwife would stay out of "your space" unless needed, or she needs to check heart rates, etc(there *is* a certain amount of paperwork she needs to have filled out to cover her hiney ) And most of the ones I know are sensitive enough to stay "out of the way". Most women in the throes of heavy labor really are too busy dealing with the contractions to pay that much attention to who is where , when and what's going on...some sensitivity, yes. But the advantages of having someone there that could help and had the knowledge to know what to do in a gray area (how much bleeding is too much? Should the placenta come out within a half hour like they do in the hospital, etc) and could help you stay home, and to know WHEN to transport, might far outweigh the risks of her "being in your space"...Just a thought...
post #6 of 6
Listen to that voice! I sort of wanted to do a UC this time, but my husband didn't like the idea, so we went with our (fabulous) mw again. But throughout the pregnancy I kept having that nagging feeling that I wanted it to be "just us." But, like you, I also didn't want to "jinx myself" after 3 perfect, beautiful home births. And i worried about the burden on my husband of having to look after the 3 other kids while assuming the responsibility for my and the baby's well-being. All the things you have mentioned.

Well I've been sobbing every day for a week since my son was born, my midwives really did intrude on my space this time and ruined the experience with unnecessary questions, unnecessary advice, and stripping me naked in front of my adolescent children before I could really think to protest. I'm not an overtly emotional person, so the fact that i've been crying so much, and in front of my kids, is significant of the trauma I feel I have experienced. After three beautiful, memorable births, I now have one I hated. I feel robbed.

The physical birth went perfectly, and I think this idea that we don't deserve to continue to have good births and healthy children is part of a cultural disease. I am now a firm believer in UC - please listen to that inner voice. My biggest regret is not so much the annoying midwives but that I failed to respect the message my intuition was sending me. If you want an extra pair of hands, I think the best choice is your closest friend (or physically closest good friend). Also, though, my kids were great too and ended up needing very little from dad, so an extra person didn't need to be there, in retrospect.

btw - I really do love my midwife! But... needed to be completely alone to enjoy my birth. I think they were annoying this time because it was daytime (and there was an apprentice - whom I love - but again, too many cooks in the kitchen) and people behave differently in daylight than in darkness.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Unassisted Childbirth
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Unassisted Childbirth › conflicted re: homebirth with CNM vs UC again