Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › MTV show coming - homeschool bashing?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

MTV show coming - homeschool bashing?

post #1 of 15
Thread Starter 
I found this announcement in my local newspaper today - this is all it said. This description may just be written up poorly - I hope so - but it certainly sounds like it's going to be dwelling heavily on negative stereotyping and assumptions. Yuk.

Monday, Feb. 1st - True Life (an MTV show) - In "I'm Home Schooled," we learn how home-schooled kids deal with the social isolation, the stigma, the rigid parental supervision and the disappointment when the Rapture never actually happens. MTV. 7pm.

Lillian
post #2 of 15
I'm guessing its the same show as this:

http://www.mothering.com/discussions...ight=true+life
post #3 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lillian J View Post


Monday, Feb. 1st - True Life (an MTV show) - In "I'm Home Schooled," we learn how home-schooled kids deal with the social isolation, the stigma, the rigid parental supervision and the disappointment when the Rapture never actually happens. MTV. 7pm.

Lillian
There are so many things wrong with that description it makes me

So they rip on conservative but it's perfectly acceptable to promote a show about teen pregnancy?

And apparently MTV is so dense that it doesn't realize the entire homeschool population is NOT comprised solely of conservative fundamentalists
post #4 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lillian J View Post
I found this announcement in my local newspaper today - this is all it said. This description may just be written up poorly - I hope so - but it certainly sounds like it's going to be dwelling heavily on negative stereotyping and assumptions. Yuk.

Monday, Feb. 1st - True Life (an MTV show) - In "I'm Home Schooled," we learn how home-schooled kids deal with the social isolation, the stigma, the rigid parental supervision and the disappointment when the Rapture never actually happens. MTV. 7pm.

Lillian
i have never seen it -- and won't -- we do not watch MTV being some of the conservative fundamentalists they love to bash

buttttttttttt maybe they are speaking of ONE family specifically for whom that discription is true??? the family on that night??
post #5 of 15
Disappointment that the rapture never happens....

post #6 of 15
I'm sick just reading that!
post #7 of 15
The bonus clips on the show's blog didn't come across as very negative to me. I watched both of them. http://remotecontrol.mtv.com/2010/01...their-stories/
post #8 of 15
It doesn't surprise me that the ad for the show would be shocking. That's probably just their way of drawing watchers in.
post #9 of 15

I turned it down

I had an opportunity to be on this show last year and I turned it down. It wasn't about homescooling though. It was titled True Life I'm Losing My Hair.
Or something like that. It followed to guys with male pattern baldness and one girl with alopecia. Which is a rare condition that causes your body to fight off your hair like an illness. I have alopecia and was happy to see it revealed in the public view. Most people have never heard of it. I felt that alopecia was not depicted well or in good taste but at least they put it out there. I have since had people approach me saying.... I saw this show on MTV and was wondering if you have that thing that the girl had????? It's better than the usual chemo questions! The girl on the show had tons of hair though, I on the other hand have about 97% loss. At least they are giving oblivious unconcious people a little thought about something out of the norm. With hs and with alopecia.
post #10 of 15
I haven't seen the homeschooling episode, but I will say this: In general, True Life is an excellent show. It's won several awards, and they're all well deserved. I've been a fan for a long, long time and it's one of the shows that I still miss (we haven't had cable or satellite service for ages). I asked my mom to record it for me, and if she hasn't already she will when they rerun it. It really is a great show, though; Give it a chance before you dismiss it out of hand based on the description of this particular episode.
post #11 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by mykdsmomy View Post
There are so many things wrong with that description it makes me

So they rip on conservative but it's perfectly acceptable to promote a show about teen pregnancy?

And apparently MTV is so dense that it doesn't realize the entire homeschool population is NOT comprised solely of conservative fundamentalists
So true. It took me forever to realize what the heck the Rapture is.LOL We have forced ourselves to allot two days where we stay home because we're too busy if we don't. My kids socialize for hours at a time, several times a week. Pulleeze. Confronting the stereotype? More like promoting an old stereotype that doesn't even exist anymore.
post #12 of 15
I recorded half the show last night after being reminded on another board halfway through. The little bit I saw looked just fine and normal.

Haven't seen it yet? Has anyone viewed the episode? Positive/negative? I think it plays February 11 again.
post #13 of 15
I DVRed it yesterday and am watching it right now.
post #14 of 15
Didn't watch it b/c we don't have cable but was very curious how it would depict HS'ers . . . .
post #15 of 15
The show followed three teenagers: a girl and two boys (all in different states). I like how it showed that homeschoolers have obstacles just like public schoolers do... they're just different.

It didn't really have much to do with socialization, because all of the kids had friends that they socialized with!

The girl (in Florida) had been homeschooling for one year, after she decided she didn't like going to a public school. During the show, it followed her troubles with studying for and taking the SATs, and then deciding on a college. She studied for the SATs and then took them and scored pretty low. She stated that everything that she knew for the test, she learned in public school... nothing she had learned while homeschooling helped her on the test. She wanted to go back to public school, but was tired of arguing with her parents about it so she stuck with homeschooling. (IMHO, she was just lazy.) She really wanted to go to a community college, but she was at odds with her mother because the mother had her heart set on her daughter attending a four year college.

One of the teenage boys has homeschooled for about three years. His sister was "jumped" after school one day and the mother felt like the public school system had failed to protect her so she pulled both children from school. The boy was doing well with homeschooling, but was getting lonely during the day since his sister was older and out of the house and his mom worked full time. After proving his case to his mom, the mom "ruled" that he could go to school part time and homeschool part time. I say "ruled" because they did a mock trial so the boy could state his case to his mom. And the mom said he had to continue with part time homeschool because she already paid for his curriculum. So... he ended up taking four classes at the public school -- 2 classes per day on Tues. and Thurs. (I think). On the first day, he hated it. It was boring and he found out that he was doing more advanced work at home. He went home saying that he never wanted to go back. Mom made him go the second day. He had drama that day and loved his teacher so he decided to stick it out the rest of the semester. He ends up not continuing after that semester because of a personality difference with a teacher.

The other boy (in Louisiana, I believe) has been homeschooling his whole life for religious reasons. He also love football and was on a homeschool football team that his dad coached. His dad played football in college and the boy wanted to do the same. However, his homeschool football team did not have a good track record, so he was afraid he wouldn't be picked up by any recruiters for college football. By the end of the show, he still hadn't convinced his parents to let him attend public school just for football... they were still thinking about it. But they were also trying to raise money for the homeschool football team to try to bring more awareness to the team and perhaps get better players.

I thought it was a good show. The description that Lillian found was way off, IMHO. It didn't depict the teenagers as unsocialized freaks that were sitting around waiting for the Rapture!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › MTV show coming - homeschool bashing?