Quote:
Originally Posted by doubledutch 
by "get" i mean "experience" as opposed to "understand". make sense? 
|
Doubledutch, that's exactly what I meant, thanks for identifying the difference. Yes, I'm more interested in the way the story resonates with people, because like many stories in the Bible, I think we have an unconscious "tape" playing in our heads about the main theme of the story. For example, I'm not convinced it's about obedience at all, but I think that if we learn the story at all, that's usually the context in which we learn it. Because don't many of us learn that story as young children? And isn't "obedience" a simple lesson to take away from this story, a lesson that most Sunday-school teachers can get behind?
So if there were a novel that questioned that assumption, would it be interesting to hear another side of the story? Just as
The Red Tent paints Jacob in a fairly unflattering light (unlike the way we usually assume we should read stories of the patriarchs), a story that asks some hard questions might be interesting, no?
I think I'm fascinated by this story because it's such an archetypal one, in a way - just like all the folk tales about entertaining angels and horns of plenty - but also makes some interesting claims about the way God works. And, as a mother, I was caught by the question, "what is her perspective?" I mean, a stranger comes out of nowhere, demanding hospitality from a mother who is literally watching her son starving to death. Would
I, as a mother, give my last food to a hungry stranger if my child was about to starve to death?? Would any of us, honestly?? So what on earth drives her to agree to do so? I just think it could be really interesting.
BTW, I also liked the first half of
The Red Tent much better than the last... but then again, the story of Dinah in the Bible is really just about her being crapped on, so I suppose it had to work its way in there
somewhere.