Mothering › Forums › Welcome to the MotheringDotCommunity › Questions and Suggestions › Some are more equal than others eh?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Some are more equal than others eh?  

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I see you are re-opening NC&E (as had been promised when it was first closed down). But it's now a pay-to post forum?

I don't quite understand the reasoning behind this. Is it that the opinions of those those who can afford to pay have more value? Is it that those who can afford to pay are "better behaved"? More deserving?
post #2 of 4
Not at all.

The simplest explanation is that we cannot have a dedicated administrator for N&CE.

We would like to implement updates and look into various other features that members would enjoy rather than spend a great amount of time in one forum, a forum that isn't a core issue to Mothering, just something that we all enjoy.

We do see how much it was enjoyed by many members. It was a difficult decision and not one that anyone wanted to make.

I moderated those areas for some time so I do think I am pretty aware of how severe the situation was getting. I hope people know me from my several years moderating Activism, War & Politics, N&CE and Politics that I wouldn't back down from a board unless I was genuinely concerned and worried. Back in the day people of all over the spectrum would happily post together, have interesting discussions and everyone would walk away still friends. But it is a lot different now, it seems people do not *want* to post with people who believe differently than they.

We did try and reduce the amount of baiting and divisive posting but nothing was working.

I am not trying to blame anyone, I think it is just an unfortunate result of the hostile tone that the political scene has taken in general. It is very difficult to moderate. There is just a geniune lack of civil discourse going on.

I do think members here might have thought we were lecturing them. I am sorry if that is the case. The nasty tone is so pervasive, I have seen it in really unexpected places like the liquor store or things on my facebook that would be UAVs here. Someone threatened a political figure on my facebook. I was really horrified.


Several other websites and forums have also made similar decisions in regard to Political posting. I have been watching it on other boards, for my information and it isn't any better anywhere else.

It is really unfortunate.

I am sorry.
post #3 of 4

Why do you have to pay to be able to post in N&CE

I do not understand this new rule, it seems extremely unfair that people who cant afford to be suporting members can't participate.
post #4 of 4
I'm really sorry that it feels unfair. I totally understand and realize that not everyone's going to be happy. The news forum is not core to Mothering's web purpose, and the forum (in our past experience) has taxed our limited resources that could be better served focusing on AP/NFL topics.

We received a great deal of feedback from members who said they never actually posted in N&CE but enjoyed reading it and wanted a place to keep up with current events. I hope that it's understood that we tried really hard to keep the forum open to general posting, but it became extremely divisive to the community. We really do try and meet the needs of our members to the best of our ability.

We've received many requests to reopen the forum and decided to make it an extra benefit for members who support MDC financially. We realize not everyone can afford a Supporting Membership subscription just as not everyone chooses or can afford to purchase a Mothering Magazine subscription. The least expensive Supporting Membership yearly fee is currently $5, and we understand that it's not in everyone's budget, especially in today's economic climate

News topics are still able to be discussed in the core forums, but we ask that discussion focus on issue related to the forum's subject and not the individual newsmakers. Please see this link for further explanation:

Quote:
We will allow members to discuss news items in appropriate parenting forums such as breastfeeding items in lactivism, birth related items in the birth forums or chickenpox outbreaks in Health & Healing. However, keep in mind that threads still need to remain on-topic for the forum and should not be about individuals but about the general topic.
Please feel free to PM me if you'd like to discuss in more detail.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Questions and Suggestions
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Welcome to the MotheringDotCommunity › Questions and Suggestions › Some are more equal than others eh?