Last week, I was you. Completely discouraged and wondering why I stuck with this for as long as I have, with absolutely NO signs of that light at the end of the tunnel. None. Our tunnel was BLACK. The last 12 months have been a COMPLETE waste of time.
We also ec'ed from 4.5 months, and my daughter is almost 17 months. We used disposables at night and when out of the house (for no other reason than they're less bulky than cloth), but we kept her either diaper free or used a cloth diaper at home. Lately, we've switched from cloth diapers to gerber undies (cotton waffle). We've had nothing but misses (she NEVER eliminated on cue, and she'd have to sit on her potty for up to half an hour before she would do anything), but I never stopped the "communication" part of EC.
"You're peeing!"
"You pee'd!"
"Peepee goes in the potty"
"Where does the peepee go?" (she's sign "potty" or point to the potty)
"POOP!"
"Can you say poop?" (poop sign)
"Where does poopy go?" (sign potty or show it to me)
"Peepee on the floor! Let's clean it up!" (offer a towel)
Etc.
Even when she was refusing the potty, we still kept up with the communication. And I know I'm going to jinx myself by saying this, but she woke up earlier this week and decided that now was a good time to be potty trained (or at least get to phase 1). So long as I keep her naked from the waist down, she'll take herself to the potty (most of the time - I still have to watch closely for body language and use timing to take her and offer a pottytunity). And more impressive than that, she sometimes wants to pee on the toilet (which is new) and will eliminate on cue (which has never, EVER happened before).
I expect regression, but this week has been almost entirely miss free. There IS a light at the end of that tunnel... somewhere. LOL! Don't lose hope.
Now can someone please un-jinx me???