Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Why isn't my bone broth gelling?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Why isn't my bone broth gelling?

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I use northern Canadian wild game and organic synthetics-free, free-range grass-fed animals only.

It seems completely random that the bone broth gels. This last time I used caribou ribs that the butcher had left in the freezer too long for his liking, so it had the meat, bones and lots of gelatinous viscera on it. It did not gel. I simmered it for 24 hrs or so.

I have had chickens from the same farm and one would gel and the other not. I usually put two or more carcasses in at a time though.

For lots of bones, like the caribou ribs, I allow the broth to reduce to 2 litres from filling a 10 litre stock pot with everything including the water, so I don't think it could be that I've used too much water. Could it?

Are there ingredients that could cause an otherwise gelatinous broth not to gel?

I use veggie clippings and peelings, egg shells, a TBSP of acv, unrefined sea salt, peppercorns, and spring water. The broths are very rich and delicious with lots of fat at the tops of my jars, and my dh likes them diluted a bit because they can be a bit too strong-tasting at 2 litres for him (not for me though ).

Does this happen for you mamas too? Does it matter and do you know why this happens so randomly? I know that if I end up with a bag of bones without joints (moose or bison, usually), then there isn't much gelatin to begin with, but the ribs had lots.
post #2 of 6
I don't really aim for gelling, but I think it is pretty hit or miss here too. I think some animals just have more gelatin in their connective tissues than others, even if they are the same age and from the same farm.
post #3 of 6
I make chicken stock weekly and have never, ever had it gel. The one and only time I've had gel was when made stock out of last Thanksgiving's deep fried turkey carcass.

I don't know why some gels and some doesn't.
post #4 of 6
One of the main thing that affects gelling is time of simmer. Long simmers, which are great at extracting minerals, end up breaking down the gelatin somewhat.

I've found that a 12-16 hour broth gels somewhat, whereas a 20-24 hour broth doesn't really at all -- with chickens from the same farmer, using necks and feet in the stock.

I want both the gelatin and the minerals, so I am starting to do a somewhat shorter simmer, around 14 hours. I get a sloppy gel, not a crisp one.

I have made really short-simmer stocks before, breaking the bones up beforehand, and gotten a really crisp gel. But a really short simmer doesn't give you the minerals...
post #5 of 6
Dont worry about it, my broth has never gelled and ive tried every recommendation possible to get there. As long as the stock is prepared correctly, it will do its nutritional job, gel or no gel.
post #6 of 6
It seems random for me too. But I agree with what Brown Lioness said.

Interesting about the shorter cooking time creating a more gelled broth. When I think about it, that has actually been the case for me too quite often... except when it hasn't
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Traditional Foods
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Why isn't my bone broth gelling?