Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › How I Naturally Weaned My Babies...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How I Naturally Weaned My Babies...

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
The nursing relationship is just that - an intimate interaction, connection, between a mother and her child. It helps us bond, communicate needs, and transforms us into one beautiful little unit.

From the beginning, though, many people - friends, doctors, family - all like to interject their opinions on what you are doing. How many times have we heard, "you feed him too much" or "I don't think he's getting enough". What about, "don't you think it's about time to stop that now?"

Enter weaning.

Weaning doesn't have to be a tragic ending...Ending your nursing relationship on a positive note can bring just as warm memories as the beginning did.


Although many people, whether informed or misinformed, mean well, the ending your nursing relationship is not up to them. It's up to you and your baby. And every nursing relationship is different! No two babies nurse the same, no two mom-child teams wean the same.

Weaning is a part of breastfeeding, but it doesn't have to be an abrupt, sad experience. Gradual, gentle weaning that respects the feelings and needs of both the mother and child can be a wonderful way to transition into the next phase of your ever growing relationship.

Here are my two weaning stories...

My Baby #1

When my son was born, he started nursing within minutes. He 'army crawled' his way up to my chest, lifted his head, and latched himself on without any help! He knew what he wanted and how to get it We nursed beautifully for the next two years without a hitch (minus two nursing strikes, but we worked through them! More on that later.)

When I became pregnant with my daughter, I was still nursing my son, who had just turned two. Although he was only nursing occasionally during the day and to sleep, he was in NO WAY near ready to wean. And I didn't want to push him to either. So I let him nurse whenever he liked during his busy days, which was sometimes only once or twice a day by that point, and to sleep. He was an active toddler

Except, as it is for some women, nursing while pregnant can sometimes become really painful and irritating. The moment he latched on, instead of a rush of bliss and relaxation that I had always felt before, I was instantly climbing walls!

I was all for tandem nursing - nursing a toddler and an infant at the same time. I had read all the books and was excited to try it!...But nursing had become so uncomfortable for the both of us (you can't be a very nice mommy when you're flinching and grimacing), I sadly knew it was time to wean. My poor son would have loved to continue, and so would I! I fought it with everything I had, and was determined to keep going. But then he'd latch on and I'd hit the roof!

After two months of that, I decided to wean. But, instead of stopping instantly, which would have been great for my nipples, but stressful and cruel for my son, I wanted to naturally wean him. I slowly introduced the concept of "the baby is coming, and she needs the milkies now"... Least to say, my son was not amused!

He was not about to share his 'milkies'!

To help me naturally weaning, I used La Leche League's motto: do not offer, do not refuse. I also used mild distraction during the day (like outings, playdates, walks) and introduced daddy bed time (where daddy laid down with him and they went to sleep together, so no milkies from mommy) every other night, then increased it to two nights in a row, then three. This was all done very slowly, week by week, month by month, inch by inch. If I felt I was moving too fast, I'd pause the momentum until he was ok with moving on.

Over the course of the next four months, I gradually and gently removed night nursings first, followed by daytime nursings. This was fall. By the time Christmas rolled around, my son was down to nursing once or twice a week - and we all know the holidays can disrupt a nursing relationship with all that running around! By the new year we had weaned.

He wanted to do gymnastics and I had said that once he was ready to wean - be a big boy - he could do big boy gymnastics class. Of course it was a mommy-n-me class, but he still enjoyed it!

What really helped with his anxiety about the changes in our relationship was that I made sure to still snuggle him to sleep - with me falling asleep with him most times And a lot of reassurance and cuddles during the day. I wanted him to know that mommy was going to be there no matter what. Yes, the milkies were gone, but that didn't mean that what we had created together - our bond - was over.

Once he understood and felt confident that we were still a team, he seemed to latch onto the idea of weaning better and weaned himself over the last month, slowly, gradually, on his time. I know it wasn't totally 'on his time' as I started the process, but I was happy and willing to let him take his time and finish it on his own terms. For me, that was natural weaning at it's best.

My Baby #2

Then I had my daughter that May!...and although we had a rocky start to our nursing relationship, we found what worked for us and had a wonderful nursing experience for the next 3 1/2 years!

My daughter is now 3 1/2...I can't believe it! And she just weaned herself. I knew she was my last baby, and I wanted her to have a more gradual natural weaning when our breastfeeding relationship was coming to a close. And since I'm not having any more babies , I won't get to breastfeed again. So this choice was simple: Keep going until she was done.

I did want to quit a few times over the last year and a half, but since it was a relationship between she and I, I decided I was ok with letting her call the shots. That's what's great about a nursing relationship. It's only between the two of you. Too bad if no one else agrees. It's not up to them

Then I got sick, and still am. It's all a mystery. That initiated doctors, family members, and friends telling me that I HAD to stop nursing. "It's got to be a drain on your system" is what they were all saying. Doctors would prescribe me things to 'try' that weren't OK for nursing, which meant I had to stop. And I almost did, but I decided to continue nursing, not 'try' meds that I knew weren't going to work anyway, and I'm glad I did. My 'illness' had nothing to do with nursing.

I was very fatigued for weeks at a time and I had to night wean her. Thankfully she loves her thumb as much as her 'mees' (her word for milkies) so I thought it was going to be easy. Boy, was I wrong! She was very stubborn, and I caved every night. One little please was all it ever took

Although I was tired as he-double-hockey-sticks, I was glad that I did continue. I loved nursing her. She's a snuggle bug, just warms my heart. Plus, I'd always get the urge to completely wean her right around the winter time, which is stupid. All those germs, colds, flu...so I'd keep going and was glad for it.

Two winters ago, when she was about to turn two, I was toying with the idea of weaning her soon. Gradually start the process. But then my little peanut got sick and couldn't eat nor drink for 4 days. She couldn't even keep water down!

At that point she was only nursing once every three days or so. Well, during that stomach virus, she nursed every two hours for 4 days and was able to keep all the breastmilk down! Kept her hydrated, fed, and out of the hospital. On the night of the 4th day she demanded pizza, we ordered it, and she was better from then on! What would have happened, though, had I already weaned her? She couldn't even keep water down. She'd of been hospitalized for sure.

Now, for the past six months or so, she was nursing maybe once or twice a week. Sometimes once every other week. I couldn't believe the milk was still there even when she'd go two weeks without nursing! But it was still there, and whenever she wanted it, I did not refuse. LLL motto!

About a month ago I told her that once she was ready to stop nursing, she could have a prize. She choose big girl ballet/tap lessons She just started and loves it!

As for me...well, I got a prize too!!! A new bra! Breastfeeding for the past 5 or so years, almost nonstop, I didn't have anything else other than nursing bras. My new bra? It's a black lacy number, and if you want to see it, just ask. I love it! I do I feel like such a big girl myself! ha ha LOL...

Remember: Weaning doesn't have to be a tragic ending. Ending your nursing relationship on a positive note can bring just as warm memories as the beginning.

Have you weaned? Thinking about it? How did you do?

enjoy the snow (if you've got it) ladies!

post #2 of 16
I weaned my daughter at just before 2. I also hit the antsy, uncomfortable, grimacing phase. For me, I wanted to breastfeed as long as it worked for both of us. When it wasn't, I knew it was time to start to stop.

She was already night weaned. I used gentle distraction to get her down to nursing just at bedtime and waking. One morning, she just didn't want to nurse when she woke up. So we were down to only bedtime.

I started counting how long we nursed. I started the first night at 2 minutes per side. Each night, I reduced the time by 10 seconds (she never protested being moved to the other side or being told it was time for sleep -- she obviously wasn't too attatched to the whole thing). After less than a week, I laid her in my arms to nurse... and she sat back up and asked to go to bed.

And that was it. She never brought it up again, didn't even seem to notice.

I'm happy with how it ended. I feel like I helped guide her, but that she was ready and made the final decision to stop.
post #3 of 16
Thread Starter 
that's awesome jenfl! I wish all babies were given a choice and such a gentle ending to a beautiful adventure
post #4 of 16
Thank you for sharing your story with us!
post #5 of 16
Great story! I am going to move this to Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy since what you're describing involves mother-led weaning and this forum is for child-led weaning only,
post #6 of 16
I have also removed several posts questioning the placement of this thread. Please remember to keep that sort of thing to PMs or to report questions to moderators. Thanks!
post #7 of 16
great stories, thanks for sharing
post #8 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by MommyHawk View Post
What would have happened, though, had I already weaned her? She couldn't even keep water down. She'd of been hospitalized for sure.
After weaning, between her 1st and 2nd birthdays my niece had to be hospitalized for dehydration twice.
post #9 of 16
Thanks for posting this. In fact, I just came here to vent about my nursing aversion. DS is 2 1/2 and I am 16 weeks pregnant. The milk is pretty much gone and I am not happy while nursing anymore. DS mostly nurses down for nap, before bed and in the early morning hours now. He still asks several times a day though, and for the most part, distraction has been working. I think the idea of having daddy put him to bed sometimes might help and I'm going to try that. Thanks again!
post #10 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrsdocmartin View Post
Thanks for posting this. In fact, I just came here to vent about my nursing aversion. DS is 2 1/2 and I am 16 weeks pregnant. The milk is pretty much gone and I am not happy while nursing anymore. DS mostly nurses down for nap, before bed and in the early morning hours now. He still asks several times a day though, and for the most part, distraction has been working. I think the idea of having daddy put him to bed sometimes might help and I'm going to try that. Thanks again!
good luck!
post #11 of 16
This was very nice to hear. Thank you for sharing. My son is 16 months and going strong.
post #12 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Harmony08 View Post
This was very nice to hear. Thank you for sharing. My son is 16 months and going strong.
awesome!
post #13 of 16
Thank you for sharing your stories. I came here looking for guidance on whether or not to wean my 20-month old now that I am pregnant. I am still as unsure as ever, but it makes me feel better to hear stories like yours and know that I'm not the first person to struggle with these issues.
My daughter and I both love nursing, and I don't think we're ready yet. Although I'm not really excited about the idea of tandem nursing, I think I'm not totally against it either. We'll see...
post #14 of 16
I would think that "Natural Weaning" would be the same as "Child Led Weaning" since that is more natural, IMO.

We are almost weaned here...and I say almost because I am doing Child Led Weaning...and then after several days of no BFing, Lo will ask for Nee Nee to go Nigh-night. I just did the Don't Offer, Don't Refuse thing during the day and offered sippy cups & did redirection...have been doing this since age 2 and that was 6 mos. ago.

I have heard of moms Night Weaning, to get their child to sleep in their own room now...but decided that was not the route that I wanna take.

Now here we are just had the 1st dental exam & was told that Lo has "Baby Bottle Decay" and that its from "too much milk" which to me sounds totally absurd!
So, I am getting a 2nd opinion next week to help me decide on what to do about the decay and when it should be done.
post #15 of 16
Thanks for sharing your stories. I don't think we're anywhere near weaning, but it's interesting to hear what it might be like.
post #16 of 16

off topic, dental worry@07mommy

07mommy, my nursing 2 year old was supposed to go and get his decaying teeth worked on tomorrow morning, but when I took him to his pre-operative doctor appointment on the 1st, she(holistic practising m.d.) said that it's unnecessary to do anything while he's so young and not showing signs of being bothered by the decay. I said that they(the dentists) were saying it needs to be done before the decay gets worse and gets infected and affect his adult teeth. She said it doesn't work like that, and to deal with them getting worse if the time ever comes and/or starts complaining about them.
I don't think I said that as clearly as I wanted....sorry if it's kinda ramble-y...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › How I Naturally Weaned My Babies...