Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › lost in translation ROCKS! my review
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

lost in translation ROCKS! my review  

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
i just watched a movie for the first time in a long time last night, and it was excellent. i give it 5 smilies.



lost in translation. it's the best performance by bill murray i've ever seen (even before i read the falling-over-themselves-to-fawn-over-him reviews). the female part is played by a very realistic beauty; a smart, lonely scarlet johannsen who looks like an awkward 10th grader one minute and a siren the next...very intriguing.

the movie is all about our efforts (and failures for the most part) in communicating to others our own needs, and with others about their own, in a particularly post-modern setting for these two characters--seemingly the only americans drowning in a Japan drawn so pop-art and jangly that even when you can understand what someone is saying it still doesn't make sense. Neon skyscapers screaming in light a foreign language that seems somehow more foreign than any other...reminding me of the definition of "absurd"...unable to be heard due to the sheer magnitude of unrecognizable transmission.

the sketches of murray's and johannsen's characters by comparison are spare and quiet and dark, all of which sofia coppola, the director, seems to have known would give the essentially isolated characters room to exude their difficulties rather than inundating us with words, words, words in what could have been a melodramatic film about the angst of (insert post-modern condition here...loneliness, meaninglessness, existential angst, ad nauseum). a bit more of a challenge for the viewer but much more rewarding as a piece of art.

and *lost in translation* doesn't stoop to make you love it either. coppola could have crafted an ending that left you feeling happy but hollow...like eating a whole pan of brownies...full of crap you know won't edify you in any conceivable way and therefore means you've wasted your time at the least and damaged you in some way at worst. but instead you get a feeling that ordinary human valor of some sort has occurred in front of you, if i can sound that corny. the end of the film wraps up--as neatly and poignantly as a poet would have dreamed of doing--the entire thematic premise of the film in a few lines that are inaudible to the viewer but which, like ivan illych's final thoughts, signify--and indeed, manifest--a profound transformative moment that can't help but leave you as altered, at least temporarily, as the characters themselves are.
post #2 of 13
I know almost everybody loved this movie, but me, my dh and 18 yo dd really disliked, almost hated, it!!!

We found it boring and icky. It went nowhere. It also was not a comedy and it ticked me off it won a GG for best comedy!?!

But then we found Matrix 3 compelling and beautiful...
post #3 of 13
I liked it a lot. Especially because it wasn't a typical Hollywood movie. I am so tired of the usual movie. Plus we have some japanese friends from Tokyo, so it was cool to see Tokyo. (can't imagine living there!) and they did a good job with the culture.

joyberryjoy - you ought to write movie reviews. Your post was beautiful.
post #4 of 13
Hi joyberryjoy,

I LOVED this movie too. Lost in Translation had an altering affect on me as well, I thought it was absolutely brilliant and fabulous, so poetic and thought-provoking. So great that it was not a Hollywood cookie cutter movie. I often find that I enjoy the first half of movies because the plot is original, and then the second half is so predictable. Not with LIT, though. What did you think of the soundtrack? I own it, and think it mirrors the different moods of the movie perfectly.
What an amazing review you wrote! Very eloquent.

There was another thread about it a month or so ago, with lots of mixed reviews. You might enjoy finding that and reading what people thought- some really different perceptions and interpretations.
post #5 of 13
I rented the dvd, my dd told me how much she loved it and how it was "artsey fartsey" and slow moving.

The kiss of death so I asked dh to pick up another dvd and he got matchstick men and we watched that last night (talk about dark and twisted)

So LIT is sitting on the mantle unwatched.

I'll give it a chance, I guess

db
post #6 of 13
Quote:
Originally posted by DaryLLL
I know almost everybody loved this movie, but me, my dh and 18 yo dd really disliked, almost hated, it!!!

We found it boring and icky. It went nowhere. It also was not a comedy and it ticked me off it won a GG for best comedy!?!

But then we found Matrix 3 compelling and beautiful...





I agree! My mom, Dh, and I watched only half of the movie. It just seemed way too boring!
post #7 of 13
I liked it a lot too. But I also think that it talks about loneliness and looking for your place in the world. I moved to the States almost 11 years ago and It made me remember the feelings and emotions I went through then (and sometimes now too).
post #8 of 13
story a bit thin.
But I enjoyed it tremendously.

on friday joel siegle said he thought bill murray will get the oscar.
fwiw.
post #9 of 13
I loved, loved, LOVED this movie.

I found the fact that these two Americans were not only lost in the culture/language barrier of Japan, but also in their lives. I love how they didn't "get together" to make it some smarmy love story.

Instead, I think through each other they found love for themselves and an increased desire to better their own lives.

I found it brilliant and amazing.

AMAZING.

Bill Murray's character was so endearing and loveable. The tenderness of the movie slayed me.


Yeah, for those picking it up assuming to see a Stripes or Caddyshack movie, you'll be disappointed.

I loved it. It's one of my favorites.
post #10 of 13
thanks for the recommendation....we just borrowed the dvd from a friends and are planning to watch it this afternoon!!!
post #11 of 13
I love Bill Murray and I loved the scenery but I have to say I was not that impressed. It was "OK" but not as big of a deal as everyone was making it out to be. IMO

I think Sofia Coppola has the demeanor and personality of a bag of rocks...did you see her at the Oscars? Stand up straight, girl! You're on TV!

I did like it visually but it seemed like I was being manipulated into thinking it was an art film...and it wasnt...Ya know?
post #12 of 13
We usually love these offbeat character driven movies, but I found this one really dull. It has since been nicknamed the "bad karoke movie" for it's excessive use of karoke...the movie would be half the length if they would have cut the karoke to a reasonable length. It just seems like most of the movie was written to fill space...like she had a great 10 minute short movie idea and worked to stretch it into a full length movie. Mind numbing.
post #13 of 13
It got to the point where I just wanted the movie to be over or to be put out of my misery.

The only good thing was some steryotypical observations about Japanese culture.

I really disliked that movie and am glad I got it back to the blockbuster on time because I would be loathe to pay for it twice.

db
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › lost in translation ROCKS! my review