Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Tantrums, separation anxiety, new behavior...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Tantrums, separation anxiety, new behavior...

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 
DD is almost 3 and we are suddently having major behavioral issues. She is suddenly not cooperating with me at all...i didn't know how to word this because i know words like "obey" can be triggers on this site. The way we have approached discipline so far has really been based on everything i've read from this site. We are not harsh disciplinarians...our major technique is distraction, but as DD has gotten older and able to communicate we often give her options. If we want her to do something and she's not ready, we give her a few extra minutes...and compromise, allow her to do things in the order that she wants. We're firm when it comes to safety or when things just have to get done...like we have to be at church on time. We've never had problems before but she is suddenly unwilling to compromise. For instance, yesterday she wanted to wear her fancy christmas dress. I am usually extremely flexible with what she wears, but I was willing to let her wear ANYTHING else. She went straight into a tantrum - kicking, screaming, refused to put anything on at all. We tried bribing her, talking to her about what she wanted. This is one example of what's been going on, but she's basically not doing anything i ask of her. I can't get anything done and we can't go anywhere.

The other thing is that she is tantruming when daddy leaves - every single day this week he had to leave her in hysterics. The other day i basically had to lock myself in another room with the baby because i literally couldn't take it. I was afraid i would hurt her because i just couldn't handle her screaming at me.

I have read the articles on this site about tantrums...and i just cannot figure them out in relation to our daughter. She does not seem better after a tantrum, she seems exhausted. We try to give her space, but she's so violent and confused...she wants us to hold her, but then she fights and kicks us. It goes back and forth. We try to leave the room...she follows.

Her tantrums are not related to tiredness or lack of food. I've seen that in the past and it's predictable. That's not what's going on here.

We're really at a loss and need help.
post #2 of 3
Why couldnt she wear the fancy xmas dress? Could you break it down exactly word for word what happened? How did she ask, what exactly did you reply, etc?

Have you read How to Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will Talk? That is helping me, but a lot of stuff that works on this board, does not help me either, so I feel your pain.
post #3 of 3
Thread Starter 
I've heard of that book but never looked into it. I'll check it out.

Hmmm...so the dress. I can't remember word for word now but she basically pointed out the dress she wanted. I didn't want her wearing it for a number of reasons, we were going to be running a number of errands, including some shopping where I need to try clothes on her. And it was really cold...so wearing the sleeveless dress would have meant putting on a turtleneck under it and tights. It would have been a pain to try on clothes with all of the layers - i just wanted her to have on a simple outfit. Plus, taking her to the potty in public places is already difficult when I'm trying to handle my baby, so i just didn't need any extra difficulties. Most of her wardrobe is comfy leggings and tops or dresses. The thing about the tantrum is once is starts even if I let her wear the dress, it's too late. The tantrum is no longer about getting what she wants...if you ask her what she wants, she can't even tell you, she's just screaming. I can't never tell her "no" and i have no idea when she'll be okay with it and when it will turn into a tantrum.

Yesterday she threw a tantrum during breakfast. She had put her own cream cheese on her bagel...and we gave her warning that she could put a little bit more on and then she had to stop. Well, after a minute we told her it was time to put it away and she flipped out. No chance for discussion, she just started screaming right away. There was no way we could have avoided this.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Tantrums, separation anxiety, new behavior...