Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Questions about cutting down sugar
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Questions about cutting down sugar

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
I've been trying lately to restrict the amount of sugar (and high-fructose corn syrup) that my children eat -- and it has been a BATTLE.

One of my friends pointed out the more you restrict the sugar, the more appealing it becomes and she is right -- when my children actually have access to sugar at a friend's house or at a birthday party they go hog-wild.

I still think their overall sugar consumption is less, even with these crazy binges. But I'm not sure I'm going about this the right way.

Have you ever tried to limit (or eliminate) your children's consumption of sugar?

Did it work?

Were you raised with a limit on the amount of sugar you were allowed to eat? Do you think it helped you as a child? Do you still eat a limited amount of sugar as an adult?

Do you have any tips or tricks for introducing this dietary change to a family?

What do you do about your children bingeing at other people's houses?

How do you stop the constant begging for sweets?
post #2 of 12
Well, the constant cravings are fed by sugar. If you're going to break the cycle, you have to clean it from their systems, and that would include at friends houses. It usually takes 2-3 weeks. When they have those cravings, you can quelch them by feeding them protein and fat - a piece of cheese, some meat, handful of nuts, something along those lines. Because sugar cravings are not psychological, they're physiological. And HFCS is worse about stimulating those cravings than plain sugar.

My tip would be to plan for it by offering other "sweet" treats - fruit with fresh cream (whipped of otherwise) is a popular one. Whatever it is needs to be naturally sweet and contain a fair amount of fat. Get the rest of the stuff out of the house and keep it out.
post #3 of 12
I agree the cravings can be helped physiologically. Kombucha helps me. Once you get all that out of your system sugar won't seem as appealing.

If you're going to do it you just have to buckle down and tell them sweets aren't an option. Don't take them to birthday parties for a while. I believe an occasional treat or binge is ok. Like halloween.

My dh didn't have much sugar as a kid. He thinks that's why he lives on Mt Dew now and has some other sugary foods. I think it's because he wasn't really taught the importance of good nutrition or what good nutrition was. At least he's incredibly healthy. My parents didn't limit my sugar. I started developing diabetes at 25.
post #4 of 12
I am absolutely in favor of limiting sugar. I really don't buy in to the whole "if your kids don't get regular sugar they will binge on it forever" philosophy. I think that if someone harmfully controls a child's diet it can cause food issues, but I also think that too many people swing in the opposite direction and are afraid of imposing ANY limits or boundaries. For me it comes down to this: sugar is a very unhealthy but tasty substance, and it is my job to teach my child how to see it as an occasional treat and not as a food that one requires daily to be healthy and happy.

My parents taught us about healthy, balanced nutrition and really limited sugary food. While I do have a lusty sweet tooth I do not run out and stuff my face at any opportunity. My parents taught me to think with my head, not with my taste buds.
On the other hand, a good friend of mine was allowed to self regulate his sugar intake as a child, and his parents kept treats in the house all the time. He had free access. He would only drink milk with chocolate in it, and had Coke every day. He is in his 30s now and has horrible eating habits. He is completely addicted to sugar, and was never taught how to choose healthy foods.

We strongly limit the amount of sugar treats in our house. We will often have ice cream, enjoy a piece of good chocolate, bake cookies, or go out for hot cocoa as a treat. My child is no stranger to birthday cake. But we do not keep the stuff in the house, and having a sugary food is not an every day occurrence.

We talk to our daughter about food choices, and how foods effect our bodies, minds, and teeth. We acknowledge that sugar is yummy and that it is really easy to want it all the time, but that because we love and respect our body it is important to feed it first with the healthy foods that will make us grow strong and keep our moods balanced.

I was so proud of my 6 year old daughter today. A friend came over today and brought a small treat for desert. My daughter thought long and hard about eating it: she'd had an upset tummy the night before and decided that eating sugar right now might make it worse. So she put her treat away for later in the evening. She told her friend, "We have some sweet, juicy carrots. Those will be my lunch time dessert! They are so sweet and crunchy and good..."
post #5 of 12
I agree with cristeen.
I've watched this very thing in my own body. I have a wicked sweet tooth and never had sugar limits as a child. We always had soda, cookies, candy... around. I was taught healthier eating choices by my stepmom and was never super hyper or overweight like some kids w/free access to sugar, though.

In the past few years I've made some major changes to my diet including cutting out high fructose corn syrup and then dairy, wheat and most recently regular sugar and I feel SO MUCH BETTER!!! I know how addicted I am to sugar and if I have even one bite it becomes a major struggle to not eat more and takes me about a month to get it out of my system and then I'm good to go and I can say no w/o feeling like I'm gonna have a sugar convulsion or something, ya know?

If you want to change how you relate to sugar you've got to get it out of all your guys' systems and become an avid label reader. After a time you'll come to know which brands/products contain HFCS and you just don't buy it. period. There is ALWAYS an alternate product available. There are plenty of other sweeteners available too-honey, agave, xylitol, etc that don't have the same addiction problems that sugar do.

And it's true that when your body is craving sugar the best thing for it is protein.

It's not easy, but there's plenty of us here to cheer you all on! It's a conscious choice everyday just like any other addiction.
Sorry for the novel... guess I feel passionate about healthier eating
post #6 of 12
DS 3 get very little sugar and dont get me wrong he loves "junk" but he was given a piece of cake with gobs of frosting on it at a party and spent 2 days sicker than a dog after (oh and he didnt eat it all). So now he tells me to much sugar will make him sick and understands pretty well that processed sugars like all processed foods are treats not part of our regular diet.

But even before that would turn down sugared foods and eat fruits or veggies at picnics and such.
post #7 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crunchy*VT*Mom View Post
Were you raised with a limit on the amount of sugar you were allowed to eat?
There is a family story (told VERY frequently) of me being... oh 3 or 4 or something, and my mom explaining that we would now have a one sweet per day rule. Little daughter of a lawyer that I was, I knew and reminded her every day that I hadn't yet had my "sweet per day" yet that day. And of course she said every time it meant NO MORE than one sweet per day.

We didn't eat a lot of sugar as children, though I certainly knew my way around any rules my parents set down for sugar out (at parties, etc). That said, as a teenager, I had a horrible diet. My parents DID limit fat (other than butter), buying low fat milk, I wasn't allowed to finish the cream the rare times we bought it even though I craved it, etc. Other than that, I could eat what I wanted to. I started to eat a lot of processed foods, and TONS and TONS of sugar. My cholesterol SKYROCKETED (well above 200, at 16!), I put on a lot of weight(my bmi, which admitedly I don't put a lot of stock in for most people, put me at overweight), my depression got worse, my health was terrible.

A year ago this january, I first started trying to cut down on sugar (having already cut out all processed foods that contained ingredients I didn't know and could cook with at home for 6 months and having great health changes). It was so so hard. After about 2 weeks of serious withdrawl (and NO refined sugar at all), I would be fine, and not crave it. Until I had two desserts/sugar things in a row. And I had to go through withdrawl again.

In may, I moved into my own place, and the first things I bought were copious amounts of whole milk, cream, and butter. I was starving for them. It was both an emotional and physical craving. I was crazy over the cream, and ate large amounts of butter. (and other TF foods.) fairly quickly, my health returned, my weight dropped to a healthy weight and stayed there, my cholesterol came back to normal.

After about 9 months of eating TONS of healthy fats, I find myself without much of a sweet tooth. I can eat dessert, but I only really want about 2 bites, and then it is too sweet, and I didn't go through withdrawl after the holidays, when I ate TONS of sugar. It was just easy to come home and stop eating it.

This just reinforces for me, the fact that sugar cravings are a physiological craving, and often indicate either a lack of fat or a lack of sugar.

My advice for cutting out sugar is this:
-Eat protien and fat rich and naturally slightly sweet foods instead when a craving hits (when I was going through withdrawl so many times, peanut butter and coconut oil mixed with a little honey and raisins was my savior. the coconut oil makes it taste like dessert, the peanut butter, raisins and smidge of honey make it sweet so it satisfies that without any refined sugar, and the protein and fat are what your body crave. That or cream for dessert, with or without a little honey or raisins. It's naturally sweet, but has plenty of fat.)
-Eating LOTS and lots of healthy fats
-NO refined sugar in the house. at all. (we do actually have a bag of white sugar for kombucha, but because I don't bake sweets really, it doesn't "count" to me, because I'm not going to do anything with it in a craving. a cookie on the other hand....etc. at least til your caught up on fats
-Start cold turkey. It sucks, but it's the only way to do it. you wouldn't deal with an alcohol or heroin addiction by trying to cut down slowly. it doesn't work. did you ever read about that study where rats had to choose between feeding their sugar addiction or their heroin addiction, and chose the sugar? your up against one tough foe here, but you can do it.
-For me, one refined sugar thing on one day is ok as long as it doesn't happen about more than 1x a month, and is a small amount. (a peice of birthday cake, but not a sweet lunch and candy and birthday cake, etc), once I'm thouroughly out of withdrawl. One peice, two days in a row triggers the addiction, and I have to start over.
-Tough it out. It sucks, but your kids can't eat what isn't in the house (except at friends houses, and I think it's reasonable to ask other parents not to give them any sugar), and they will thank you
-Teach your kids good food. Don't just feed them good food, teach them what good food is, how to choose healthy food, and how to prepare it. Teach them how it nourishes them.
-Never stop. Don't figure that you've taught them enough by the time they are teenagers. Don't feel that you don't have time anymore, or because they are gone a lot it doesn't matter. It matters most then, that you keep involving them in healthy food, and eating healthy food with them.

Sorry it's so long. I hope my experience and advice can help.
post #8 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinuviel_k View Post
We talk to our daughter about food choices, and how foods effect our bodies, minds, and teeth. We acknowledge that sugar is yummy and that it is really easy to want it all the time, but that because we love and respect our body it is important to feed it first with the healthy foods that will make us grow strong and keep our moods balanced.
I think this is just wonderful!
post #9 of 12
[QUOTE=Magelet;15134198-Start cold turkey. It sucks, but it's the only way to do it. you wouldn't deal with an alcohol or heroin addiction by trying to cut down slowly. it doesn't work. did you ever read about that study where rats had to choose between feeding their sugar addiction or their heroin addiction, and chose the sugar? your up against one tough foe here, but you can do it.
[/QUOTE]

WOW!!!! That's incredible...and really creepy!
post #10 of 12
Thread Starter 
~Thank you~ for writing your stories.

It is definitely encouraging to know I'm not alone in this.
post #11 of 12
Thread Starter 
I saw a quote on facebook the other day that I liked:

"Cravings are like stray cats, the more you feed them, the more they come around."
post #12 of 12
I don't necessarily restrict sugar from my DD. I let her know that there is a limit and eating too much sweets is not healthy for her. I try my best to encourage her to drink a lot of water, so she is not always in the habit of drinking sweet drinks..
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Nutrition and Good Eating
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Questions about cutting down sugar