Mothering › Forums › Parenting › The Family Bed and Nighttime Parenting › Talking to a friend...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Talking to a friend...

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I have a friend who has made VERY different parenting choices than I, but on the most part she's just "mainstream" while I'm "crunchy". Nothing to freak out about.

However, yesterday her Facebook status was, "ferberizing truitt for naps. he doens't cry much, but it tugs the heart strings".

Truitt is her ONE MONTH OLD SON.

Now, I do not advocate CIO, but I also know that it works for some when nothing else does, when a child who desperately needs sleep cannot settle themselves. I've also done enough research to know that ANY expert who does talk about using the Ferber method advocates only after 4-6 months, once attachment is in place.

I've read interviews with Ferber who talks about how he knows his technique is taken out of context to the detriment of children.

My heart is BREAKING for this baby who literally thinks that his mom has left him and will never come back every time she lets him cry in that crib. I am almost in tears now thinking that he is possibly being set up for attachment disorders.

Am I out of line?

Should I send her a pro-CIO link that states the 4-6 month starting time? Say nothing? Even my husband, who is a "your child, your choices" sort of guy, was a little unnerved by it.
post #2 of 4
I'd send her to a neutral site if you think she'll brush off any "crunchy" advice. One month old is just too disturbing for me to not want to say something. I in no way advocate CIO, but I totally understand wanting to send her information to traumatize the kid less.

I'd also tell her how she seems to instinctually know what's best because CIO is "tugging at the heartstrings". Help build her trust in her own mama instincts. Try to focus on the positive.
post #3 of 4
Thread Starter 
After a lot of thinking, I'm going to send her a link to a BabyCenter.com page about the Ferber method, where the 4-6 month thing is mentioned.

I hate to harm our friendship, but this puts a LO at risk of attachment disorder, failure to thrive, etc, etc.
post #4 of 4
She may be feeling desperate. The first few weeks you just deal with the lack of sleep, but then by a month it might start to feel really difficult. If it were me, I'd get her a copy of Happiest Baby on the Block--that's a "crunchy" book that seems to appeal to mainstream folks too. My newborn went from sleeping 60-90 minute stretches to sleeping 5 hour stretches every night because of that book!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › The Family Bed and Nighttime Parenting › Talking to a friend...