Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Well meaning, but annoying- How would you handle this?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Well meaning, but annoying- How would you handle this?

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
How do you handle close family members who talk to your child in ways that drive you crazy? I have a very small family who live nearby so we see them frequently- several times a week usually. They mean well, but are annoying- here are some examples: My uncle particularly is always asking my 2 1/2 yo ds quiz type questions, yk, always testing- what color is this? What sound does x animal make, what shape is that, how many x are there? I don't like it and don't think my child prefers it. I don't want him feeling constantly tested and afraid to get it wrong.

My mother seems hung up on enunciation. She will repeat a word that he is saying very slowly and distinctly several times so he can hear the right way to say it. Drives me nuts and dh really can't stand it. Seems to me she could either repeat correctly once, lightly or just let it go. She also is generally unnatural with children and she seems to make a point to always be trying to "educate" by using unnecessarily long, technical terms, such as a sanitation vehicle instead of garbage truck or transport vehicle instead of truck. Instead of just supporting whatever a 2 1/2 yo wants to call something, she seems to insist on him hearing the "correct" term. She also goes into inordinately long, adult type explanations for no good reason.

We're still nursing and my grandmother will say to him when he asks me to nurse, oh you shouldn't be doing that, you don't need to do that, you're too big for that. She also will tell him that he shouldn't ask me to carry him, that it's not good for me to pick him up, he's to big. He started crying the other day while I was in the restroom at her house and I could hear her telling him, don't cry, no, stop crying. No attempt to comfort him. Luckily, my dh was in the other room and came to ds's rescue.

But, you get the idea. In writing this that seemed unrelated, I realize it's a constant atmosphere of correction. I really disliked it for myself as a child and don't want my ds to have to feel like he's always doing something wrong. He's a wonderfully sweet, even-tempered and fairly sensitive person and I want to protect him from the way I know that feels.

So what can I say? How can I say it that won't offend, but will be effective? I do like these people, shortcomings and all! Any "pass the bean dip" type suggestions?
post #2 of 13
That stuff may bug me sometimes but it doesn't offend me they're just acting how they think is best. I, honestly, would mock them a bit....maybe not the best thing. I would probably hand my kid a dollar and say "thanks for playing" here's your winnings if the uncle was quizing too much. If my mom was that socially stunted I would start "helping" her out with any terms or concepts that weren't in her area of expertise (perfect opportunities to educate on AP ) and if grandma told my child they shouldn't nurse I might say (in front of everyone since she brought it up) grandma just doesn't understand our modern ways. Sometimes addressing issues with a mocking air while smiling good naturedly will get the point across without making people feel defensive.
post #3 of 13
I'd just let it go. You really can't micromanage every interaction your child has with other people. Be thankful that your family love and are involved with your child and leave it at that.
post #4 of 13
I don't really have any suggestions, but I wanted to say I have a similar situation and I don't think it's as easy as letting it go. When you live very close to relatives and see them a lot, their influence on your kids is HUGE.

My family doesn't do those same things, in my case, my parents love to label. "R is the smart one. J is the lovable goof. M is the beauty." Right in front of them, all the time. I can see how it isn't a big deal now and then, but when you're close to your family and see them a couple times a week...it really adds up. And I know how it affected me as a kid...not well. There are other things they say that I think can be damaging, but this is your post, not mine

I just started limiting contact, to be honest. Not drastically, but to once every 2 weeks or so. Basically, trying to dilute their affect. I've told my parents not to say those things in front of the kids...it didn't seem to help.

So, again, no great advice, but wanted to let you know I've BTDT.
post #5 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by PoppyMama View Post
That stuff may bug me sometimes but it doesn't offend me they're just acting how they think is best. I, honestly, would mock them a bit....maybe not the best thing. I would probably hand my kid a dollar and say "thanks for playing" here's your winnings if the uncle was quizing too much. If my mom was that socially stunted I would start "helping" her out with any terms or concepts that weren't in her area of expertise (perfect opportunities to educate on AP ) and if grandma told my child they shouldn't nurse I might say (in front of everyone since she brought it up) grandma just doesn't understand our modern ways. Sometimes addressing issues with a mocking air while smiling good naturedly will get the point across without making people feel defensive.
post #6 of 13
My in-laws live very close and we are their only family in the area, so I know where you're coming from!

As far as the quizzing uncle, there's nothing wrong with saying, "He doesn't really like to be quizzed like that, would you like to read a book to him?" When my kids were that young, I also might have just picked them up and walked away or even put words in their mouths:"Tell uncle, "I'm tired of quizzes, let's read a story!"" That said, one of my kids LIKES to be quizzed, so I don't interrupt that if he's OK with it.

With correcting pronunciation and and overly long explanations, I think some people are just like that. So mostly I let it go. It sounds like it's really bothering you though. Do you think your mom would be open to a conversation about her role as grandma being to play and have fun, she doesn't have to work so hard to educate? I dunno, I could see a conversation like that going good or bad depending on the person and their mood.

Now, with comments about nursing and carrying, there I would correct the adult IN FRONT OF the child. "Of course you're not too old to nurse. Come to Mama." "I don't mind carrying him." and pick him up. Frankly, these comments would bother me the most because they're undermining your consciously chosen parenting practices. If gma didn't get the hint, I'd probably limit contact somewhat.

I agree wtih PP that relatives close enough to see several times a week can be a huge influence on the child. I generally think this is a good thing. But it does require some serious, thoughtful and diplomatic boundary setting. (Which has been a, uh, stretch goal for me )

hth

Lara
post #7 of 13
Well, it's primarily my MIL and my mom that do this, so we correct them! It totally drives me and DH crazy. For reference, DS sees both sets of gparents 2 times/week.

My MIL will baby-talk to DS - we don't baby talk to him and he doesn't baby talk. When we hear her doing it, DH will normally say to DS "Why don't you show grandma how a big person is supposed to talk?" That normally stops it. Of course, she will make the excuse that she did this with SIL's kids, but we always tell her that we're not SIL and our DS is NOT her kids.

My mom is a bit different. She is bound and determined to do things her way. For example, she started calling poop "shoo-shoo" - this drives me crazy! So, everytime I hear her say it, I correct HER. Same with calling juice "ju-ju" - DS can say juice just fine. One day, she yanked a pen out of his hand and I went off - asking her how she would feel if someone just walked up and took something from her and what taking something from DS is teaching him in how to act with others. She asked what she should have done and I told her that we tell him he has to sit at the table with paper if he wants to hold a pen.

I feel for you... it wouldn't bother me so much if we didn't see everyone so often, but we really can't limit time with the gparents right now.
post #8 of 13
I don't think limiting contact is the answer... personally, I want to teach my kids to learn to deal with relatives, not just give up and walk away. Lest they decide to walk away from me one day! Of course, this pertains to little annoyances, not "big issues"!
However, based upon my own experiences, I also think the kids will form their own opinions on these issues and learn that "crazy uncle always quizzes... gma always gives her opinion too much... etc. My MIL talks baby talk to ds. We don't do this and the baby talk she uses isn't even the typical... it's way beyond that and really, really grating and annoying. DS, at 3, has already picked up on it. He says, "I don't like ____, she talks funny." YOU are the greatest influence on your kids. If your relatives are kind and love your kids, I definitely agree with the pps. Try to overlook it.
post #9 of 13
I would go insane!
I am really upfront a nd therefore would tell them, preferably more kindly than not, but to get my point acxross.
Limit? yeah that's an option, too
post #10 of 13
That sounds so annoying. My parents did some of those sorts of things that annoyed me. The somewhat mocking response can be helpful. I have also flat out asked that they not say certain things, for ex, my dad always makes remarks about how much DD is eating or her big belly and although she is 3 and it is not a big deal now, I said, please stop talking like that to her because she is not likely to be a skinny mini (has her dad's build) and it will be soon enough that she will have the opportunity to have body image issues thrust upon her, he didn't need to contribute to it.

Some of the correction stuff is likely to stop when your DC gets a bit older, so you may just let that one go and choose your battles. I know my parents did a lot of that pronunciation correction and I finally reminded them of the story they told me about someone correcting me when I was a kid. I was pronouncing the word (to myself) the exact way they were but it just didn't come out the same way. My parents did a lot of "good jobs" that drove me nutty, but I just cringed and tried to ignore it until it stopped. My mom also constantly referred to herself in the third person to DD. AHHHH! Drove me batty. I ignored it. It stopped with DD got bigger (she's almost 3.5 now).

The grandmother I would NOT let go. I would firmly tell her that she needed to stop that sort of talk and that you'd be happy to educate her on why you do things the way you do. I'm sure she will also be the one to be telling him not to be a baby when he cries when he is a little older. I don't think that sort of thing is helpful. She will have her own ideas on childrearing, but if she disagrees with how you are doing things, she can talk to you about it or keep quiet around your son.
post #11 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by PoppyMama View Post
That stuff may bug me sometimes but it doesn't offend me they're just acting how they think is best. I, honestly, would mock them a bit....maybe not the best thing. I would probably hand my kid a dollar and say "thanks for playing" here's your winnings if the uncle was quizing too much. If my mom was that socially stunted I would start "helping" her out with any terms or concepts that weren't in her area of expertise (perfect opportunities to educate on AP ) and if grandma told my child they shouldn't nurse I might say (in front of everyone since she brought it up) grandma just doesn't understand our modern ways. Sometimes addressing issues with a mocking air while smiling good naturedly will get the point across without making people feel defensive.
This is very passive aggressive, and likely to make people feel defensive, but unable to respond.

I personally would just tell people directly that talking to my son that way bothers me. Offer an explanation if you want, but don't leave it up for negotiation.
post #12 of 13
I would realize that different people do things differently. They probably have no idea that these things bug you. The first 2 wouldn't bug me at all.

We think we're our DDs teachers. We plan to homeschool. It just seems natural to teach them.

Personally I can't stand it when kids call things the wrong thing and no one cares enough to teach them the right answer. I think your mother is doing an awesome thing in helping your son learn to pronounce things correctly and learning the proper terms for things. What's so bad about that? Why learn it wrong first instead of just learning it right from the beginning. I disagree with my sister on this, and her 6yo is still pronouncing things wrong because they refuse to correct her. It seems so counter intuitive.

I realize that I'm an unschooler at heart. But I don't think there are good and bad times to teach kids. All the time is learning time.
post #13 of 13
Hmmm...Don't have a problem with my own children about this....Dh and I go visit relatives by ourselves so there is limited contact in that area. I have had strangers do it, which I think is worse than family doing it.

However when I am around my nieces and nephews I try VERY hard to treat them like they actually have a brain in their heads. It annoys me very much to hear adults talk down to children.....I usually re-direct even if they aren't my own children. My family is VERY much un-AP so when I treat their children with AP like behavior they usually are taken back like they can't imagine how a small child could actually comprehend normal conversation. I tell them: "How would you feel if someone talked to you as if you were a baby?"

That said..I actually remember adults talking to me like a I was a baby when I was 5 or even 7 years old. I hated them for it and I would try very hard not to talk to them after the fact. I remember that very distinct uncomfortable feeling and I don't want a child having to feel the way that I did.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Well meaning, but annoying- How would you handle this?