Why not buy one cute basket to reuse every year? That's how I grew up. Just like we had a box of Christmas decorations, there was one box of Easter stuff that got pulled out once a year with a basket for each kid, plus the little decorations we liked to put out. I loved that basket and seeing it every year. It was a great tradition. Now I've passed it on to DS.
DS doesn't like any candy or chocolate, which is fine by me. He'll be getting a board book and some truck stickers. I also have a handmade felt barn set w/ animals that I got in a trade that I've set aside for Easter. The year before he also got some little wood cars which he loved. I wanted to get a small amount of candy (for me and DH LOL) from the Natural Candy Store online, I found jelly beans with no HFCS, and fair trade dark chocolate bunnies and choc. eggs. Unfortunately for just a few oz. of candy the shipping was nearly $9 so I had to scrap the idea.
If DS was just a little bit older I would get him some natural art supplies