I really appreciate all the replies. I'm in the Land of Larry Craig, where there honestly don't seem to be many secular home schoolers. It's easy for us to feel isolated. I've tried so many avenues, including violin, swimming, skiing, theater, etc. It feels really hard to break in, here. Either that or we're somehow socially sabotaging ourselves. It's hard not to get a complex about that! Maybe I could give it more time. But I honestly feel like I've run out of heart and energy for it. And I'm certainly running out of money. Putting her into different activities to chase down opportunities to build friendships is taking its toll on our finances. I've sought out lots of free stuff, too. Heck I even swallowed hard and took her to church - and I'm an atheist-leaning agnostic. She's very much involved in the community with the volunteer work I do, and spends quality time with our adult friends, but again that's something that's not her own.
I could give this social issue more time and try to work up another round of attempts, and I may do that. Her dad is pretty reluctant to put her in school. And I am too. But she's such a social person, spending her days pretty much with me alone. So it's hard to think keeping her with me all the time is the right thing to do. I'm feeling like as she grows she should have experiences that don't involve me. Experiences of her own. And that time is neigh.
I've just arranged for our local public school to do an assessment for admission to the gifted/talented program. I'm not convinced that's the best route to take. But I suppose I want to know what options we have in terms of public school options. Her dad is kind of freaking out about this change in plans. I'm trying to reassure him that it's not a done deal.
Riding lessons are one of my last resorts. It's something she's totally interested in, and it's very separate from me. That may take some creative financing, though.
Anyhow I'd appreciate any words of encouragement or, heck, you can be brutally honest, too. I'm looking for an answer, or a new perspective, or a kick in the pants. For some reason the prospect of putting her in school feels like leaping off a cliff. I have a very unsettled feeling about it.