We use all free & clear (liquid) for all of family laundry, so that's convenient. We were a Tide family because it's what I grew up with and we all have very sensitive skin, but the switch to All has been great. It's cheaper than Tide, available pretty much anywhere (so you can buy bulk with coupons and save even more), and works well, though we find it doesn't protect colors the way Tide did (though for white prefolds and covers, that's fine by me)! We used it for a solid 2.5 years on our dipes with zero problems whatsoever. The only time we had to strip was following rotavirus (and anyone who's smelled that knows that we can't put all the blame on the detergent there)!