Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Toddlers › Is gaining a 2 1/2 YO's compliance without cat-herding possible?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is gaining a 2 1/2 YO's compliance without cat-herding possible?

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Oh lordy, the cat-herding we go through...every. single. day. Does anybody have any tricks for getting a kid to move with a purpose and do what we ask without having to physically guide him in the direction we want to move and punctuating every. little. step. with "Can you do X yourself, or do you need some help with that?" Putting on jacket, shoes and socks to leave the house, brushing teeth, changing clothes, and doing final pee pee before bed - these are the worst. They are things we do daily, and they are always a struggle, dragged out much longer than they need be.

I try to break things down into small parts, so it's not "Let's get ready for X," but, "You need to come in the bathroom so we can brush our teeth." Then, "Here's your toothbrush. Squeeze the toothpaste onto it." "Okay, you need to brush your teeth a little longer than that. Keep going." "Can you finish by yourself, or do you need some help?" "Take off your pants and undies so you can do final pee pee chance." "Can you do it yourself, or do you need some help?" The only motivation I have found to keep him on task is to remind him with every deviation, "The longer you take now, the less time you have for nursing," but it's only true because the longer he takes, the less patience mama has and the less happy she is about nursing as the hour grows later and later.

Is there any way to get a kid to just do as you say without the nagging and micro-managing? He will throw the toothbrush on the floor and book it out of the bathroom if I don't keep after him with the night-time routine, he puts up a stink about going through it, but is equally put out if we try to do something like take his socks off FOR him...gah, this irrational, meandering kid...
post #2 of 8
Thread Starter 
I take it from the lack of response that the answer to this question may be NO...
post #3 of 8
I've got a 5yo who I still cat-heard....subbing for successful ideas.
post #4 of 8
I'm just wondering when my son escaped and went to live at your house?
post #5 of 8
I have to keep at both of mine to get them to do anything. The 2.5yo wants to dress himself, but takes forever and loses track in the middle, running off to play with his undies around his ankles and his shirt flapping open. The 4.5yo wants me to dress him, but loses focus between putting the first and second leg into his pants. I seriously have to say "focus, ok let's do x now" 20 times for each task.

Herding cats is the perfect euphemism for toddlers. Picture 2 of them wanting to do their own thing outside or at the store while we're trying to get things done and get out of there. Gah frustration!
post #6 of 8
The title of this thread cracked me up. I'm living it too!

Bottom line: the things that we, as parents, think are important (getting dressed, personal hygiene, etc.) are simply not important to our toddlers. They'd much rather be playing, running around, and generally having fun.
post #7 of 8


My 2.5 yr old has no interest in what I want him to do. I say "ok, time to X" and he either says "nope" very nonchalantly or he completely ignores me. completely infuriating. Then, my 4 year old requires me to ask her 154 times to put on her shirt. and then her pants. and her socks. and. and. and. It should not take us so freaking long to get out of the house! it was easier when I had a newborn and a 18 month old. *sigh*
post #8 of 8
I just wanted to say my DS does the same thing! I just try to start getting ready to go early, and don't get stressed about being late, otherwise he senses my hurry and will be twice as difficult Fortunately, we don't have too many appts to keep .
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Toddlers
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Toddlers › Is gaining a 2 1/2 YO's compliance without cat-herding possible?