I think we pay around that much.
Cat #1 was a craiglist kitty . She ended up having a litter of kittens (she escaped before her spay appointment, oops). This is where cat #2 came from. The spay for cat #1 cost about $300, and #2's neuter cost about $90.
Food costs us about $60/month, but we'll never feed Friskies/IAMS or any supermarket brand. They get canned Merrick wet food ($36.00/24 cans)- 1/2 can each per day, and Orijen kibble on top ($24/bag, lasts about a month and a bit). It's more up front to feed a 6-star food, but it saves us tonnes in the long run- we don't have urinary crystal issues or UTIs and we aren't shutting down their kidneys by feeding a biologically inappropriate feed- saving us thousands in vet bills long-term
(I can confidently say that poor quality food kills kitties slowly. We used to feed IAMS, and the difference in our cats health is night and day since the switch)
Litter runs us 30 odd dollars a month (We keep 3 boxes)
I buy the odd toy here and there, but they really aren't too interested. Their favourite things are free- a sheet of crumpled newspaper, a ribbon tied to a stick, twist ties, our daughter's toys- lol. The scratching post/cat tree we got for 50 dollars plus redeeming rewards points.
We have a soft sided carrier for both of them (they both fit inside with room to spare, cat #1 is only 5 lb, cat #2 is about 12 lb), it looks like a gym bag but is mesh on the sides- it was no more than 30 dollars.
We don't have pet insurance. with 2 dogs and 2 cats, it's not worth it. For the amount we'd pay, we can just put the money aside to use in case of emergency, and many pet insurance companies don't cover illness at all- just accidents and injuries.
That said we've had our share- DH used the dog's flea meds on the cats. BIG NONO. It poisoned their nervous systems. It cost us 800 at the emergency vet for them to give them a bath, some robaxacet (seriously) and watch them
And our dogs are walking accidents. (But that's neither here nor there

)