Wow, I have to admit I'm a bit surprised at the general one-sidedness of the responses. I do really appreciate your perspectives though, thanks!
I'm sorry to read about those of you who have had parents or spouses die. I still do think that the probability of that happening is very low. Yes my experience is anecdotal, but in my life I have only known one person (out of a great, great many over the years) who have had a parent die while they were minors. I guess I honestly don't worry about me or DH dying- in the same way that I don't worry that a meteor will fall out of the sky and land on our home or that my child would die from one of the diseases we will choose not to vaccinate for. But that's just me. I can understand that some people would gain peace of mind from life insurance- I guess that's just
not me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by SeekingJoy 
What type of life insurance product(s) is he trying to sell you? Term? Whole life? Carrying a reasonable level of term life insurance (or having adequate investments to support the surviving partner or guardian) shouldn't be that expensive, and I think it the only resposible thing to do once kids are involved.
|
Term insurance. And it's not that expensive, I just think our money might be better spent in many other ways to prepare for the future.
I think that saying it is the ONLY responsible thing is going too far- there are many other ways to be financially responsible for one's children besides life insurance! And we are looking into those ways just as we looked into life insurance.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MeepyCat 
Where on earth are you getting $30 to $40K quoted as premiums? That seems really high for a million in coverage.
|
Not premiums. I said the total investment in a term police of 25 years would be $30-40k.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunflower.mama 
I just suck it up and do it. Perhaps once your LO arrives you will realize how scary the thought of leaving him or her to be cared for by someone else is, not to mention how scary that would be if you left the child without resources to provide for said care. It's a component of your responsibility as a parent.
|
I don't just suck anything up and do it. I like to think things through and find the best alternatives for me and my family. Lots of things I could imagine are "scary", and I never said I would leave my child without resources to provide for his or her care. I find your comment offensive and I think I can judge what my responsibilities as a parent are. Thanks.
Quote:
Originally Posted by iowaorganic 
Why would you NOT provide the security of life insurance for both your partner and you dc? We have term policies with return of premium riders. So it is like a 0% interest savings account at the end of the 30 years. Not everybody thinks these are good ideas- but it works well for us.
|
Again, life insurance is not the only way to provide security for my partner and child. Sheesh. I'm glad you found what works for you, I'm going to try to find what works for US!

Quote:
Originally Posted by rainbowmoon 
Don't forget if you or your spouse dies you and your minor children will receive social security death benefits until your child graduates from HS or is 18 and 9months.
|
I'm sorry to hear about your spouse dying.

DH and I have worked outside our country (Canada) since leaving university so we have never really contributed to any governmental security/persion plan, and therefore are not eligible. We have investments and savings because of this.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mnnice 
Just because you buy 25 year level term insurance doesn't mean you need/should pay the premium the entire 25 years  .
We have term life insurance and I suspect that we will pay the premiums for a few more years, but not the entire term. We are becoming increasingly self-insured.
|
True about not having to pay the entire 25 years. That's a good point. We are solidly on our way to becoming "self-insured" as well (if I understand your meaning of that).
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunnysandiegan 
My thoughts are similar to the OPs in many ways. We don't buy into all the "insurance" our country is so incredibly fond of these days. Both cars are paid and we keep liability (higher than legal due to our COL) and uninsured (due to our location) coverage. I've been without health insurance due to the industry and DH has been without due to unemployment. (We're both covered now, though.) DD has always been covered (by the state during unemployment and by us at all other times). DD is 9.
We have a small policy on me and a larger (but relatively small compared to others in this thread) term life policy on DH. We also have a small AD&D policy on DH (same benefit amount as term policy, but half the premium cost because it doesn't cover health-related death). The 10 year term policy ends soon and we'll be deciding how we wish to proceed. We chose to cover our mortgage and cremation costs (our preference) and a few months income, which becomes more months as the mortgage shrinks. We also choose to save through a variety of investments (highest percentage is very safe) and have a year's worth of expenses in those accounts. We have additional funds, also, and excellent credit. Without a mortgage, all those funds would last several years, especially since those expenses are based on a family of three. Without me, DH & DD would have my retirement account (over a year's worth of expenses today). Without DH, DD & I would have his retirement account (about a year's worth of expenses today). Both of those retirement funds would be DD's if both of us were to pass, which is more than double my private university tuition.
If one or both of us were to pass, life would be different for the remaining family members. Regardless of life insurance payouts, life as you know it is going to change when a family member dies. In our case, the family we've asked to care for our child would not *need* any financial help (it is there anyway in a modest amount) and they have a large enough house, etc. Plus, if my dad were still living, he'd provide financially for DD indefinitely (and/or me, temporarily). DH's family would provide for him and/or our DD, if needed. No one in either family is rich, but everyone has reached financial maturity and handles finances well.
Try to remove the emotion from the situation and evaluate *your* situation independently of others. Do you have supportive family? What is the financial health of those family members? Do you own a home? What is the general fiscal policy for your immediate family (DH & you - savers/spenders, high/low-income earners, high/medium/no debt, etc)? Do you have any large debts that would need to be covered if one spouse were to pass (different laws govern this factor, too)? Age is also a consideration, as is genetic health.
I believe in basic term life for low amounts and focusing on living life to the fullest and preparing for the future with a diverse approach. (Putting all financial eggs into the life insurance policy basket makes zero sense to me, especially when families struggle to put food on the table.) This advice applies to most, but not all people...everyone has something unique about their circumstances and those need to be taken into account.
|
Thanks for this. It's nice to hear an expression of a different viewpoint. And hey from a finance grad, too!

I really appreciate your comment about removing the emotion from the situation and evaluating my situation independently.
Do you have supportive family? More or less. If anything happened to me, dh, or baby-to-come our families would do ANYTHING to help us. We don't lean on them for any support and haven't in the past, though.What is the financial health of those family members? Pretty good. Do you own a home? No, we live abroad and our employers pay for housing. We don't plan on owning a home until we retire.What is the general fiscal policy for your immediate family (DH & you - savers/spenders, high/low-income earners, high/medium/no debt, etc)? Savers. Med-high income earners. No debt.Do you have any large debts that would need to be covered if one spouse were to pass (different laws govern this factor, too)? No.Age is also a consideration, as is genetic health. We're young (29 and 30) and we are very fit and healthy. Genetic health is probably average- people in our families get pretty old and die, with very few health bumps along the way.
I think a lot of people have a hard time removing the emotion from this issue (very understandably!) and it's something that dh and I have attempted to do. I think it's really easy to have a knee-jerk reaction when it comes to things like life insurance- and people saying things like "why wouldn't you want to be sure that your LO isn't provided for? etc." But I think the above questions are things that we have considered and are the main reasons WHY we have chosen not to buy into any big life insurance plan. I started this post thinking that there would be more people who might see things along the same lines and offer some insight and support (also fully expecting to hear the other side of it too of course...not expecting to feel so attacked, though

).
I think dh and I are on our way to doing things similarly to what you and a PP have done- very minimal life insurance (we already have a free term policy through one of our banks for 100k...didn't mention it because we don't have to contribute to it), no debt, lots of savings and investments. After paying off our hefty student loans, we already have started retirement funds for both dh and I, an education fund for our future kid as well as investments, and solid enough careers should one of us have to go it alone. I think we have a good start for providing for ourselves and our kid even taking into account the unlikely possibility of a tragedy. Maybe I should have added all this as a preamble to my first post.

Follow Mothering