Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Long distance move away from extended family
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Long distance move away from extended family

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
I've come here before with similar questions about making a move, so if you've read (and responded) before....please bear with me!

I am literally in knots over this. Here is the current situation: I live with my DH and three children about 10 minutes from my hometown. My parents and four siblings all live within 30 miles (along with my 13 nieces and nephews). Two of my sisters live down the street (in different houses, with their spouses). Our kids are all friends, I have a very close family. I don't get much "help" from my parents (in terms of babysitting, etc.), but we don't really need it because my DH works from home and I'm a SAHM...so we're flexible. I like this community for the most part. I've made friends, my kids have made tons of friends, and people are very supportive, helpful, neighborly here. It's more conservative than I am and I don't have any super close friends (besides my sisters) partly because I feel like there are some fundamental differences in our beliefs. On top of that, the schools are not good here. Not horrible, but pretty lacking and kind of rough (some small-time gang issues, etc.). It is also very suburban...nothing to walk to, just strip malls everywhere. We're about 2 hours from DHs family and, well, their awesome ocean-front beach house. That we get to use on our own for at least a week each summer. (Just trying to give you the full picture!)

We moved here on a "temporary" basis 3 years ago to get out of a crime-ridden neighborhood in the city. We've wanted to leave 1) because the cost of living is very high and we are barely making ends meet and 2) I never wanted to live so close to my hometown. Maybe it's stupid, but I feel like I'm seriously disappointing my college-aged self by living here. It is SOOO not what I wanted for so many years. But now...it works, it's easy.

My DH has applied for jobs all over the country for awhile now to keep our options open. Now one of those jobs is coming through. It would mean a move to a wonderful city that meets so many of our dream criteria. He'd be making A LOT more money, the hours would be decent (not as great as working from home, of course, but pretty regular 9-5 with almost no commute). And it would be an interesting, good job for him. We could afford a beautiful home in a walkable neighborhood with more liberal-leaning folks everywhere. The schools are great, the area is beautiful. But, it's about 14 hours away from where we live now. A plane flight.

Part of me wants to move because I feel like our family needs it's own space. We are SO intertwined with my family that it can be suffocating. I love them and we are very close, but I never envisioned living down the street from them. I just pictured more adventure, more change.

But as I type this I see how much we'd be giving up. And I really don't know what to do. My DH feels a lot of pressure to be sure this job is perfect and awesome in order to move the family for it. And I'm just really, really torn. And to add to it, my 5 and 3 year old will be crushed. Literally. They LOVE their cousins and aunts/uncles and g-parents...as in, they scream out with joy anytime someone comes over and ask almost daily to get together.

Does anyone have any advice? Anyone BTDT?
post #2 of 8
Just to clarify... you don't love the city/town ,you are in a bad school district and a neighborhood you don't love because you are worried your kids will miss their cousin playmates?
post #3 of 8
We moved away from our hometown 2 years ago and are very happy with our new life. It was hard to leave our family and friends - and we miss them a lot, but for us the good outweighs the bad. I never would have thought we would leave the area both DH and I grew up in, mainly b/c we didn't know anything different, but like you I always had this feeling of wanting to get away and make a new home for ourselves. I never moved growing up, so leaving the state seemed like a huge deal.

Anyhow, my kids do miss their old friends - but they adapt easily and have made many more here. They were sad to leave their grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins but they can talk to them on the phone, email, write letters and of course spend time with them all when we go back to visit, or they come out here.

We also moved for a new job of DH's - more pay and cheaper housing has made our lives much better.

You know, nothing has to be forever. If you find that you don't love your new community and miss your old life too much, you could always move back near your hometown. Honestly, I'm to the point after two years that I am settled in and happy enough that it would break my heart if we had to move back. But it's always an option, and of course here would be good that came out of it.

Kids are resilient and may do better with a move then you expect. My DD cried her last day of school before we came out here, and was super sad to leave our families - but once we were here she was excited and happy - it was a big adventure for all of us.

Best of luck making a decision.
post #4 of 8
I'd make that move in a heartbeat. We moved to a suburban, conservative area to be close to extended family, and that part has been awesome (grandparents, BIL and his family, we see them all the time, great memories for the kids), but there are just too many negatives. Our kids will be sad on the day we relocate, but they will adjust and love our next adventure! And man oh man, have we learned a lot about what's important to us in a community!
post #5 of 8
I moved from CA to FL (about as far as you can get!) and then back to Texas. All of my family is in CA. In some ways, it is very nice - I have a lot of freedom to do as I please and not a lot of eyes peering into my business. On the other hand, it can be hard - I miss my family and wish they were closer.

I think in the end, you have to make the choice that is best for your family. From an outsider looking in, it sounds like moving might be the best option. In any case, best of luck to you!
post #6 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by philomom View Post
Just to clarify... you don't love the city/town ,you are in a bad school district and a neighborhood you don't love because you are worried your kids will miss their cousin playmates?
Well, when you put it that way!

I would also miss my family. My sisters are my best friends. We haven't always lived near each other, so I know we'd stay close on the phone, etc. But it does hurt a little to think of not seeing them often.
post #7 of 8
My dh and I have been grappling with this same question for over a year now. I think we've decided to make the move when it comes up, and this is the reason why: if family weren't here, there wouldn't be any other reason for us to be here. And since we can't control them and their decision to stay or leave, we shouldn't base our decision to stay or leave on them being here. Does that make sense? Basically, it would really suck if we decided to stay here to be close to family, and then they all moved. So, we're going to put ourselves where we want to be, for us. Good luck on your decision- I know it's not easy!
post #8 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by petey44 View Post
My dh and I have been grappling with this same question for over a year now. I think we've decided to make the move when it comes up, and this is the reason why: if family weren't here, there wouldn't be any other reason for us to be here. And since we can't control them and their decision to stay or leave, we shouldn't base our decision to stay or leave on them being here. Does that make sense? Basically, it would really suck if we decided to stay here to be close to family, and then they all moved. So, we're going to put ourselves where we want to be, for us. Good luck on your decision- I know it's not easy!
We moved to the region my dh grew up in two years ago to be near his family. We are actually 45 miles from them, but I knew I wouldn't be able to handle the suburban life. Even though we have a beautiful piece of property out in the country we have decided we are going to be moving back west where we are much more comfortable. The lifestyles and attitude here are pretty stifling and I need to live somewhere that is more "me". I feel the same as berry. We can't stay here just because of family if that isn't making us happy.
Good luck with your decision. It is a hard one to make!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Long distance move away from extended family