This is nice to read, especially after getting emotionally aggravated after a brief encounter in public with a woman I barely know, but who had a daughter 6 months before I had my homebirthed son... the woman is from Germany and speaks with a heavy accent, yet is totally Americanized, and is weirded out that I still nurse my son at 2 1/2, because she weaned her daughter to formula at 3 months, with her doctor's blessing and assurances that breastmilk past 3 months of age is not nutritionally necessary.
I usually don't try to change people when it comes to this topic because I can't keep my own emotions out of it, but was in a bad mood that day, and left with the comment, "Then it's a good thing you weren't talking to a European doctor, because they know that breastmilk for the first year is vital to normal health and brain development."
She said something to my back, but I was too mad to even turn around. And that's odd because I usually accept with some philosophical understanding of boundaries, that there are a lot of people who don't nurse, and even go out of their way to avoid nurturing, their infants, and I can't change that. I was mad because there are still doctors in the USA spouting such garbage to unsuspecting mothers who then believe them.
Yes, babies usually -but not always- survive on formula. But their health is always going to be less than it would have been if they had been breastfed, all other things being equal. And in most ways, mothers would stop at nothing to see to it that their babies have every chance to not just barely make it, but to thrive... except in the bottle culture, where they make a mental skip past breastfeeding.
I just bit my tongue and did not continue with some diatribe like "Well I am sorry your doctor is full of S__t. But they often are when it comes to pregnancy, birth, and mother/child care!" But I sure thought it, and chewed on it the rest of the day.