Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Life With a Babe › Blow off our own DD's B-day or do the whole party thing?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Blow off our own DD's B-day or do the whole party thing?

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
When I say blow off I don't mean blow off DD though!

It will be DD's 1st birthday in about a month! We are obviously very excited but DH and I are in complete disagreement about what to do for it.
1. I think we should have a party with family and friends, nothing too big maybe 10-15 people max. Cake etc, nothing fancy just grilling and relaxing and maybe playing a game or two.
2. DH wants to go to Mystic Aquarium with DD (for those of you familiar with it). He wants to make a big day out of it for the 3 of us and make it very special.

The reason he doesn't want to do the first is because his mother has never ever gotten over her divorce with his dad. His father remarried to a lovely woman (his parents have been divorced for over 10 years mind you) who is extremely kind and has no problem with DH's mother. Unfortunately DH's mom is unstable (posted about her in another thread) and hates this woman,blames her for their divorce (DH's father didn't even know his future wife at the time) and freaks out (cries, hides in her room) at the mere mention of this woman's name.

Due to logistics there are only 2 places we can have the party (no public places are realistic) MIL's house where we are living at the moment, or FIL's house with his wife. I would like to do it here where we are living but we are afraid DH's mom won't even consider letting the "other woman" into the house. However, DH's mom will absolutely refuse to go to DH's dad's house, thus basically screwing everyone over like she always does in situations like this (my baby shower was a mild disaster because of her and the other woman" being there).

All this is why DH wants to just blow everyone off and go enjoy our little family and DD's big day. I wouldn't mind doing this but I really want to have a party for my moms because they aren't the problem and neither is DH's dad or step-mom. I think it would break my mom's heart if she couldn't see DD on her birthday (she missed my wedding and baby shower). I was thinking that we could just talk to DH's mom and tell her that basically we would be really honored if we could have the party here and if she would even bake a cake for the party (she used to be an amazing cake maker) BUT we would be inviting DH's Dad and wife because they are a part of our family and deserve to be there regardless of her issues. No negotiating that point, I want them to be there if we have it here. If she says no we were thinking of just saying "well thats too bad then because we will be having it at DH's Dad's house and you are of course invited and we really hope you come!"

OK, this is getting long, but I just don't know which is the better of our 2 options. As usual MIL is making things hard but we are running out of time to hem and haw about what to do...So any suggestions and if you read this far THANK YOU!
post #2 of 5
Your reasons are very similar to why we didn't have a first bday party for DD1. We were living with my mom at the time, and my dad and stepmom and my mom weren't on good terms at the time. We had a nice day just the three of us, and then had a really great 2nd birthday party when we had a house. I'd go with the great day...
post #3 of 5
Will it be stressful for you if both women are together, regardless of location? Is it going to ruin your memory of DD's first birthday? I'd blow off the family.

Actually, our kids are 5 and 4 and we've never had a birthday party for either one of them yet, because we just couldn't figure out the logistics of it, even without any major family feuds going on. My parents are in another state, and we usually just announce what weekend near the kids' birthdays we'll come to visit, and I bring cupcakes then. When MIL was alive, we told her which day we'd bring cupcakes over to her place for her to see the kids. We always bring cupcakes to our weekly playgroup that week, too. I guess we just have a bunch of mini-parties, instead of one centralized party.

The day of each child's birthday, we do something special just with the four of us. For DD it's almost always an amusement park, since she's a summer birthday. DS is in the winter, so we do a kids' museum or aquarium. And waffles with ice cream for breakfast. And birthday child chooses dinner. And more cupcakes, of course.

Could you plan to do the aquarium and just invite your mom to join you, or would that be a whole other issue?

I hope you find a peaceful solution and have a lovely birthday celebration!
post #4 of 5
I vote for the aquarium. Who needs the stress of all that? Enjoy the day with your family! I would suggest meeting your mom for lunch or something either the day of or one day around dd's birthday.
post #5 of 5
Thread Starter 
thanks for the advice! I spoke to my mother about it and she is actually going to be just coming back from vacation so she said she wouldn't be able to see DD until the weekend (her actual birthday being on a Tuesday I believe). So it works out pretty well if we don't have a party!

I really didn't want to have 2 big parties for DD, as a child of divorce at a young age I hated that I had to have 2 myself. So for DD's sake since her parents are together and all I told DH I really wasn't interesting in acting like we were the ones with the problem...

I am thinking aquarium it is, I wouldn't mind doing a party but my biggest concern was my mother and she won't even be around! Plus the aquarium is a lot of fun!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Life With a Babe
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › Life With a Babe › Blow off our own DD's B-day or do the whole party thing?