Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › 12 month old only wants to eat fruit and sweet things...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

12 month old only wants to eat fruit and sweet things... - Page 2

post #21 of 33
BLB, I think our babies could be almost food preference twins (I have a 17 month old little guy)

I also have a 7 year old, who did not do that same thing of holding out for raisins/grapes/strawberries/what have you. And both were offered from day one a healthy range of nutrient-dense foods--the difference is that the now 7 year old actually ate them (in teeny tiny quantities), rather than making faces and refusing to eat, becoming hungry and cranky and gesticulating wildly for the sweeter options that the toddler knows exist somewhere! My little guy is aware of sweets even though he's never had them (really, never seen them--when we were at a friend's house he was clamoring for a brownie when he had never seen one before, or anything brownie-like baked in a 9 x 13 pan). Our daughter never did that, and happily handed over chocolates from an advent calendar at age 2.75, completely oblivious.

Both my kids have the same body type at this toddler age (50-60 percentile for height, less than 5th percentile for weight). Both rejected fat-rich things like avocadoes, egg yolks, nut butters... Both love to nurse. To me it's so clear that otherwise it's a taste preference/personality thing that's different between them, and I wish there was a magic bullet for the toddler to choose to eat the healthy and tasty meal choices!

My new breakthrough food with the little guy is hummus. He also likes guacamole (though not plain avocadoes). And chicken sometimes. It's all so hit or miss, and varies by the day. I think offering her what you eat, and then later offering a banana, peanut butter and milk if she's still hungry is a fine way to go. I would try not to fret too much and think that she'll always eat that way--there's a lot of growth and learning in this department in her future, and though sweet things may not be your preference to feed her, making them as nutrient-rich as possible will keep her healthy.

Good luck!



Quote:
Originally Posted by BLB View Post
Wow, so many different opinions. A few things to clear up:

5) Again, we offer a wide variety of healthy foods, including everything that has been listed (eggs, beans, cheese, avocado, yogurt, etc.). I don't just offer her fruit all day long, and never have--I thought that was clear. Even if she's so hungry she's in tears, she will not eat food she doesn't like or that she thinks she doesn't like. If, say, I put beans and cheese in front of her (that's all I mean when I say "trying to get her to eat"--making some food and putting it in front of her), she'll poke at it and maybe place a piece on her tongue, spit it out, and cry because that's not what she wants to eat. She won't cheer up or sleep until I give her either some milk, or some fruit. I do try to do things like put nut butter on the bananas or toss sliced strawberries with raw coconut oil for fats. And she mostly eats low-sugar fruits anyway.

ssh, ammiga, Leah, Faith--thanks, I'm going to try your suggestions.

Gotta go grab a shower, Granny is on the way over
post #22 of 33
Thread Starter 
Thanks so much for the thoughts, everyone! simcon, our kids do sound like food twins I've been chilling out on this in general and I think we'll all survive For the last 2 days I made her a grilled cheese on thin slices of whole grain bread, with a tiny bit of chutney spread on it, and she ate some of that. Last night she rejected white rice but ate a few green beans IN RED THAI CURRY SAUCE. She has no trouble with strong flavours!

crunchy_mommy--I've seen that Weston Price chart before! I actually considered making our own formula using their recipe initally, but it wasn't feasible for a number of reasons.

I'd always understood that cow's milk and breast milk are not at all the same--I'm pretty sure it's only really recommended so strongly for toddlers 1) because of dairy industry lobbying and 2) as a source of calcium (which cheese, yogurt, greens, etc. are just as good at providing), not as a breast milk substitute. Formula is much more nutrient-dense than plain cow's milk because it's uber-fortified, and it's also partially pre-digested, hence why some kids can tolerate dairy formula but not cow's milk.

That said, I don't really agree with direct parallels between breast milk and formula (ie that since it's great to breastfeed to at least 2 years, it's also good to stay on formula that long). Formula is an extremely processed "food" with all kinds of gross stuff in it (hydrogenated oils, chemicals, and in particular, hormones and antibiotics in the source milk, since as far as I can tell all formula sold here in Canada is made from American milk, not Canadian, which by law can't have hormones in it and I think it can't have antibiotics either but I could be wrong there). Plenty of babies do do fine without breastmilk or formula after 1 year, and I guess since breast milk isn't available, I feel like it's healthier for her to be off the incredibly processed cocktail of formula and onto healthy whole foods instead, since formula isn't necessary anymore. Does that make sense? It does in my head but I haven't finished my morning coffee yet, so...

Quote:
Originally Posted by simcon View Post
BLB, I think our babies could be almost food preference twins (I have a 17 month old little guy)

I also have a 7 year old, who did not do that same thing of holding out for raisins/grapes/strawberries/what have you. And both were offered from day one a healthy range of nutrient-dense foods--the difference is that the now 7 year old actually ate them (in teeny tiny quantities), rather than making faces and refusing to eat, becoming hungry and cranky and gesticulating wildly for the sweeter options that the toddler knows exist somewhere! My little guy is aware of sweets even though he's never had them (really, never seen them--when we were at a friend's house he was clamoring for a brownie when he had never seen one before, or anything brownie-like baked in a 9 x 13 pan). Our daughter never did that, and happily handed over chocolates from an advent calendar at age 2.75, completely oblivious.

Both my kids have the same body type at this toddler age (50-60 percentile for height, less than 5th percentile for weight). Both rejected fat-rich things like avocadoes, egg yolks, nut butters... Both love to nurse. To me it's so clear that otherwise it's a taste preference/personality thing that's different between them, and I wish there was a magic bullet for the toddler to choose to eat the healthy and tasty meal choices!

My new breakthrough food with the little guy is hummus. He also likes guacamole (though not plain avocadoes). And chicken sometimes. It's all so hit or miss, and varies by the day. I think offering her what you eat, and then later offering a banana, peanut butter and milk if she's still hungry is a fine way to go. I would try not to fret too much and think that she'll always eat that way--there's a lot of growth and learning in this department in her future, and though sweet things may not be your preference to feed her, making them as nutrient-rich as possible will keep her healthy.

Good luck!
post #23 of 33
Totally makes sense. If making your own formula isn't feasible & she's eating enough solids then why keep her on processed-chemical formula?? I totally get it The grilled cheese with chutney is a brilliant idea BTW! Oh and DS also lovessss spicy foods (tabasco sauce, jalapeno "cheeze" sauce, chili, curries, etc.) hehe
post #24 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by BLB View Post
Plenty of babies do do fine without breastmilk or formula after 1 year, and I guess since breast milk isn't available, I feel like it's healthier for her to be off the incredibly processed cocktail of formula and onto healthy whole foods instead, since formula isn't necessary anymore.
That makes sense to me too. But since your original issue seemed to be that your DD would only eat fruit or milk, my feeling was that the best way to get fat and protein into her diet would be to continue with the milk (of whatever type - I only suggested the toddler formula because you seemed opposed to cow's milk so I thought you meant your DD couldn't tolerate it).

It's true that animal milk doesn't have exactly the same nutritional composition as human milk and obviously doesn't offer the immunological benefits, but it is a good source of fat, protein, and calories (as well as calcium if you're worried about that).

Anyway from your update it sounds like she's doing a little better with the dietary diversity so maybe it's not a cause for concern.
post #25 of 33
I'd offer a lot of fruit but also a lot of other things. I wouldn't fret if she mostly eats fruit, though. My son's eating habits were exactly like that as a toddler (except he wouldn't eat anything at all until 20 months old or so), & he eats pretty well now at almost 3. He even loves meat now, which I thought would never happen.
post #26 of 33
She's still a baby. With all of my kids, there were days at 12 months old when all they would eat was bananas. I would have been thrilled if they had let me put peanut butter on them. None of them are picky eaters now.
post #27 of 33
At 12 months, I offered what we were eating. If she didn't eat it, I nursed her. I didn't "try" to get her to eat something. So, if we were enjoying fruit, so did my kids. If we weren't, they they didn't either. Breastmilk was still the primary source of calories for my kids at that time--I labeled the rest "food exploration" and didn't count on any of it towards their nutritional goals.

ETA: Whoops, I thought your phrase about "baby led weaning" was referring to breastmilk. Sorry. I didn't know that you had been ff and the ped told you to stop that part. I thought she was still getting bm (or formula).

Amy
post #28 of 33
Thread Starter 
I've decided to give her soy milk as a source of calories, fat, calcium, protein and so on (we get Silk, which is organic, sustainably produced, etc.)--I do feel like she needs something to help supplement her solids intake once this last can of formula runs out. She seems to really like it and to tolerate it just fine, and it's much more in line with my food and health values than cow's milk. We'll see how that goes in the long term but so far, so good...

I am seriously thinking about giving her a multivitamin of some sort, though, just to be safe. Does anyone know of a good food-source vitamin or supplement that's OK for toddlers (and hopefully not killer expensive)? I'm also wondering about AHA/DHA/Omega fats supplementation.

She woke up yesterday crying and signing desperately for banana and saying "nananananana"--I think I know what her first word's doing to be
post #29 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Astrea View Post
I've decided to give her soy milk as a source of calories, fat, calcium, protein and so on (we get Silk, which is organic, sustainably produced, etc.)--I do feel like she needs something to help supplement her solids intake once this last can of formula runs out. She seems to really like it and to tolerate it just fine, and it's much more in line with my food and health values than cow's milk. We'll see how that goes in the long term but so far, so good...

I am seriously thinking about giving her a multivitamin of some sort, though, just to be safe. Does anyone know of a good food-source vitamin or supplement that's OK for toddlers (and hopefully not killer expensive)? I'm also wondering about AHA/DHA/Omega fats supplementation.

She woke up yesterday crying and signing desperately for banana and saying "nananananana"--I think I know what her first word's doing to be
I was just reading the "Cure for Tooth Decay" and the author purports that children crave fruits b/c they really want fat/protein.

I've been wondering about this b/c DD is always wanting fruit. She will eat it like crazy. She has some normal toddler pickiness combined with a dairy allergy and food sensitivities to wheat and probably corn. We've been working through rashes and malaise and it's getting hard to figure out exactly what to feed her.

I think fruit is wonderful. But in some cases, such as mine and possibly yours, I wonder if it points to other issues.

P.S if you're wondering about a supplement and your DD can chew, check out Animal Parade. DD loves them.
post #30 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by claddaghmom View Post
I was just reading the "Cure for Tooth Decay" and the author purports that children crave fruits b/c they really want fat/protein.

I've been wondering about this b/c DD is always wanting fruit. She will eat it like crazy. She has some normal toddler pickiness combined with a dairy allergy and food sensitivities to wheat and probably corn. We've been working through rashes and malaise and it's getting hard to figure out exactly what to feed her.

I think fruit is wonderful. But in some cases, such as mine and possibly yours, I wonder if it points to other issues.

P.S if you're wondering about a supplement and your DD can chew, check out Animal Parade. DD loves them.

fruit isnt bad, but it is high in sugars, and the author of cure tooth decay advocates a lower sugar eating plan (yes, even natural sugars in fruit), with plenty of good fats and protien. often sugar cravings are a need for energy/calories, which can be a more sustained energy that lasts longer if eating protien and fat rather then mostly sugar (a banana is by weight mostly water and carbs/sugar, very little protien and fat).
post #31 of 33
I would STRONGLY re think soy milk. You sound like you are doing a great job but I really think you should do more research on soy.... it messed up my hormones big time and depleted my body of minerals. Ick ick ick.
post #32 of 33
Did not read the other posts.

In my opinion, you should offer balanced meals: vegetable, protein, grain (depending on how you eat, you might omit the grain). She can eat what she wants.

I learned that my own milk got less sweet as time went on. I don't know how sweet your milk is, but that might just be her savory.

I strongly agree with the mantra of you decide when and what, and she decides whether and how much. To me, this is a simple maxim, easy to follow, and does not allow for poor eating.

Both my kids strongly prefer fruit at first, get into dairy and cheeses later, and go through veggie phases.

But then, neither of them ate that much at 12 months. Yours eats way more than either of mine did (one is 3.5, other is 14 months).

Oh, and yoghurt- if you put it in the blender and put it in a sippy, that could be a good alternative to milk in a sippy.
post #33 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by crunchy_mommy View Post
I don't think fruit is bad at all & I'm happy for DS to eat fruits in moderation. I simply don't believe nature would create a yummy, readily available food if we weren't meant to eat it. I feel there is a reason that fruits & veggies are easier to gather & prepare than hunting for meat & fish -- the fruits & veggies are meant to be a staple in our diet, & the meat/fish less so.
Problem is, fruits as available in the stores today have much more sugar than them than even 20 years ago, much less in ancient times; also, they used to only be available seasonally, whereas now they are available all year round. Some places, meats/fish were probably easier to obtain than fruits much of the year.
I wouldn't stress about it too much -- my ds was picky at that age and he is ok now, although still pretty darned picky and missing several teeth. I think it's important to provide a wide variety of high fat, low sugar foods at this point, but you can't make them eat it.
Sweet foods are highly stimulating, and some kids eat them more for the sensory experience than true hunger.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Nutrition and Good Eating
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › 12 month old only wants to eat fruit and sweet things...