Posted from another thread that was around a while ago, this topic is very cyclic on MDC
(edited from where I copied it, cause I got misunderstood before and did not mean too )
I really feel people think it can do a lot more than it can. And yes I believe it also can have a down side.
this is what i personal do to help with my ewcm issues:
-tons of water
-loads of epo from af till o, i personally needed to take about 3900 and for months before it started working
-green tea, i used a extract pills, since that seemed like more than i could get elsewhere
-Guaifenesin 600mg extended release , taken as per instructions for about 4 days before O and one day after to be sure
-tons of water!
the thread is here:
http://www.mothering.com/discussions....php?t=1126958
as others have talked about, i strongly think many women are under a false impression that pre seed does more then it really does, when in fact it can be more harmful than nothing depending on the personal circumstances.
best thing is to figure out what your needs are with your own body and cycle, based on what is normal and or needed for a successful cycle and look at it from there.
What folks need to remember about PreSeeed though, and this is a important thing most are not clear about, is its just a "vaginal" lube.
PreSeed is just a sperm safe lube for the vaginal area, it is a replacement for the lubricating qualities of EWCM and arousal fluid to reduce friction, if you need it.
It does not go into the cervix in any way, so it is not a replacement for the functions of ewcm in there. Without the fertile fluid in the cervix opening, sperm do not get through, most non fertile mucus acts like a plug to keep you clean.
This is why EPO and possibly some types of green tea (to increase) and Guaifenesin and water (to loosen) are used. It is kinda like 3 parts to a puzzle, neither replaces the other.
PreSeed should not be used for instance if you make plenty of arousal fluid and would not normally need lube that night. It helps only by it's lack of harm, you are still better off correcting the issue from the inside.
you are going to get a handful that said it did nothing for them, when that may or may not be the case (bottom line they sadly did not get preggo)
and you will find a group of girls that say it was just the ticket to their long awaited BFP. without having some scientific controls in the cycle, we will never know what worked for them.
I feel the use of preeseed can hurt in two ways, one much more than the other in reality.
When ladies use it because they feel dry, they often are hiding or getting around a real lack of ewcm rather than addressing it. They often think that if they are comfy then they are good to go for ttc. The pre seed website happily let's folks think this IMHO. So if aclady has "hostile cm" as it is referred to and only uses preeseed to " fix it" then she is harming her chances greatly. Since she has fixed nothing in the actual plumbing.
Now if the quality of the ewcm up at the cervix is good or being addresses via internal healthy ways and a lady finds it's quanity lacking or lacks the arousal fluid needed to comfortably start, then preeseed can be very very helpful.
Heres my situation over the years...
I used to always need lube. Long before taking and in the beginning, I used very non sperm friendly types.
After learning superficially about ewcm and the dangers of lube I switched to preseed. I figured that thankfully I had delt with the issue.
It wasn't till later when I read about the role ewcm plays in the cervix that I realized that i had only masked the problem.
I then worked hard and still do on correcting my body from the inside ( mostly with water , epos and green tea extract, the guafennision is a last resort)
What I have found in the end is that durning my fertile times I now rarely need lube. Yes at time I need it to "get me started" but that takes just a tad. The non fertile times I still often need some, but am also not worried about that.
The other way it can hurt is because it is not your own ewcm and can't be as a foreign substance be at perfectly good, so when I hear ladies who have plenty of ewcm use it "just in case" or cause "every little bit helps" or because "it's cant hurt, right?"
They need to understand that they are diluting your natural fluids with a man made pretend version of them, so yes it's "sperm safe" but it's not the same, just close. Good real is still better.
good luck and may you have a bundle of joy soon.