We've only just completed one year homeschooling, but here's what we've loved for the Pre-K/K/1 year.
TOTALLY RAVE ABOUT EVERY CHANCE I GET- RightStart Math (after trying 3 other math programs)
- All-About-Spelling (so glad we started early!)
- Story of the World and Activity Guide
EXTREMELY PLEASED WITH- Ordinary Parent's Guide to Teaching Reading - this does the job very efficiently, we're now almost done
- Handwriting Without Tears - we are on the second grade printing book, will start HWT cursive later this summer
- Wordly Wise 3000 2nd edition - the Kindergarten/Grade 1 is so fun and colorful, this is something we end up doing multiple lessons in one session, as my daughter begs for it. She loves incorporating new words in her vocabulary. I'd put it up in the Rave section, but it's not a subject I put high priority upon.
QUITE HAPPY WITH AS IT DOES THE JOB- First Language Lessons (although it does go slow, I think we're going to do 2-3 lessons at a time.)
- Writing With Ease (love the literature selections and the intro to dictation/narration, but I think we're going to add an actual writing program, only because my daughter writes every chance she can get, and I want to teach her how to actually write)
There are other things we're very happy with, but since I failed to use them faithfully this spring, I don't feel justified putting them on this list, hehe. They would be: Building Foundations of Scientific Understanding and Artistic Pursuits.
As for the WTM forums, I would bet that a majority of the people there just enjoy the popular and busy forums, and aren't necessarily 100% classical. A big percentage admit in polls that they aren't classical in fact. I know I'm going to be giving up labeling myself as we just use what works for us.