Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › goat milk vs cow milk in yogurt?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

goat milk vs cow milk in yogurt?

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
i just made my best batch of yogurt ever, thick and creamy. but why this batch? the time i use 'regular' store milk? it's not even whole milk but 2% (the best i can get with my WIC checks). the last few years i've been making yogurt with goats milk. Does cow milk just make thicker yogurt?

My method did vary a bit this time. I wasn't watching closely and the milk heated to 175 whereas I usually only heat it to 150 before cooling. Also I used a tbsp of fresh yogurt instead of one of my frozen cubes, but that has made no difference in consistency with the goat yogurt. My culturing time was 20 hours, longer than I was doing with the goats milk. I have never been happy with the goat yogurt, and so really haven't made it in awhile. But if I could get thick creamy yogurt like this every time, then I could go back to making it instead of buying it.

The reason I was using goats milk is because my kids are allergic to cow. But they handle goats milk just fine. They've occasionally had store bought yogurt from cows milk with no discernable problems. In the past few weeks I've fed it to them more (both yogurt and kefir, store bought) to test them out. And they don't seem to react. DD atleast has an immediate and consistent reaction to cows milk, so I'm feeling pretty confident they can handle the yogurt. Combine this with the fact that WIC is giving me gallons and gallons of useless cows milk each month, I've gotta find something to do with it! So I thought of yogurt. I know over in the healing the gut tribe some mention being able to handle 24hour yogurt, even if they can't handle milk in any other form.
post #2 of 6
Goat's milk just makes runny yogurt. I think the homogenization in the store-bought milk also makes it firmer. I make yogurt and then strain it through a cloth for a day or a day and a half (for 3 quarts). Once or twice, I'll scrape the thicker yogurt off the bottom. That strains about half the volume in whey out, and it leaves me with a nice, creamy yogurt. Use the whey for soaking grains, fertilizing plants, or in several NT recipes.
post #3 of 6
Yeah, goat milk just makes runny yogurt. It's really frustrating. The only way I've found to make thick goat yogurt (beside extensive straining) is to use a Chevre culture. Granted Chevre is a cheese but you make it with a culture and initially it's the consistency of a nice thick yogurt (to make the actual cheese, you strain it). Anyway, it works beautifully and you don't need a yogurt maker (it cultures at room temperature). It also works great with raw milk as you only need to "heat" the milk to like 86 degrees.
post #4 of 6
bumping an old thread, but I do goats milk yogurt all the time now without a problem. I've started adding arrowroot as a thickening agent during the initial heating process with FABULOUS results!
post #5 of 6
How much arrowroot do you add?
post #6 of 6
Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Sonja View Post
How much arrowroot do you add?
up to 4 TBLSPNS I do it after it hits 160 but before 180 (I use raw milk so I bring it up to 180 first) I don't find it affects flavor at all.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Traditional Foods
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › goat milk vs cow milk in yogurt?