Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Natural Body Care › chlorine-free pools
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

chlorine-free pools  

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 
Hi! Does anyone here use chlorine-free products for their pools??I finally realized that if I won't clean with clorine bleach in my house, I certainly don't want my kids soaking in it all summer! I searched the internet and found all kinds of products, but I couldn't find any safety data for the chemicals they use. I don't want to trade one bad chemical for another. If anyone knows anything about this, I would really appreciate any information.
TIA
post #2 of 19
The have a product called soft swim it is suppose to be better and safer but its Pricey. I have a pool as well and was thinking hte same thing the other day about hte upcoming year. I use the bare minumum of chlorine in it and had a big problem with algea I started using Baking soda and it helped termendously. If you find any good info let me know also please.

Amy
post #3 of 19
Growing up, my parents did peroxide in their pool instead of chlorine. I know that we didn't get the side effects of the stinky chlorine
post #4 of 19
I remember in high school I was on the swim team and there was one area school that didn't use chlorine... I think they used some sort of salt mix...

Maybe not much help, but could be a direction to start looking?
post #5 of 19
We have a salt water pool. No chlorine at all. It is wonderful!!! It's just regular water softener type salt, and it is great for swimming in, no sore eyes, no ruined suits.
post #6 of 19
Irishmommy could you tell me more please I have a 24 ft round and would love to learn something else beisdes chlorine.

Thank you

Amy
post #7 of 19
I know it can be added after the fact, but we got ours when they put the pool in.

Basically you dump bags and bags of salt into the water, then all you have to do is check the salt levels every so often and add more as necessary. I think we only add once last year.

The pool water goes through something in the filter equipment that breaks the salt down into sodium and chlorine, cleans the water and then puts the salt together again before it goes back to the pool. (How's that for a scientific explanation :

There is no buying/transporting/storing of chemicals, and no shocking of the water. We never had a problem with algae either.

It is more expensive than a regular chlorine filter, but it pays for itself in not having to do the chemical stuff, and not having ruined bathing suits, sore eyes, etc.

I highly recommend it.
post #8 of 19
hmm and where would i find such a filter.

thanks
amy
post #9 of 19
we had an oxygenator on our pool in Texas. There are ozonators and ionizers too, but this was different. I make that point because everyone would correct me and say "oh, you mean an ozonator." Anyway, it works similarly to how Irishmommy decsribed the salt. It had a carbon element that divided the water into oxygen and hydrogen so that the oxygen could sanitize the water. Then it put them back together again. We loved it. It was about $2000 (a little less) to install and cost $90 a year to replace the carbon element. You still have to keep a residual of chlorine (75% less) in the pool. We saved a ton on chlorine. We still did have to shock and still had some expenses for infrequent additives. It was less than chlorine, but maybe not as inexpensive as keeping the salt water system that Irishmommy told you about. I did not look to see where she was from, so I am not sure how hot her pool got. Ours was 90 degrees easily in the summer. We loved it and it was much more comfortable for swimming than chlorine. We bought it from a local distributor in Ft. Worth Texas, so not sure about availablity. Anyway, search oxygenator and see what you come up with.
post #10 of 19
I'm in Canada. The pool does get hot. I don't go in unless it's at least 85. I love my heater!!

Look in the yellow pages for pool companies. They should know.
post #11 of 19
IRISHMOMMY,
thanks for the info. on chlorine-free swimming pool water!! It seems that the salt water might actually be beneficial to the person. Anybody else have a system like this?
I really wanted a pool when we built our house, but I didn't want to marinate dd. Looks like it's highly possible to get a chlorine-free swimming pool! Yeah!

What about hot tubs?
Any of you have one without chemicals?
post #12 of 19
My best friend has a no-chlorine pool..I will ask her what she uses. She said it doens't turn hair green like chlorine does to blondes and it doesn't erode the carpet if a wet and dripping kids runs through the house.
post #13 of 19
Just thought you might like to know that my partner did a lot of swimming as a child and teen, and gave up because the chlorine was causing him respiratory problems, so I think it might even be worse than sore eyes etc. Hope you find some good alternatives!
post #14 of 19
Just wanted to mention that my gym uses "bromine" (sp???) instead of clorine, and claims that that is better-- but I have yet to look into it.

Anyone know about this stuff? While we are "on topic"? : )
post #15 of 19
Just wanted to bump this. Very good idea on using salt instead of chlorine. I was wondering about chlorine alternatives just yesterday. And 'tis the season...
post #16 of 19
Wow.....super interesting... :
post #17 of 19

notes...

* Salt may seem like a good idea, but... it probably won't disinfect the water. You would have to use an implausible amount. I really don't think it will work.

* Ozone systems are good.

* You have to filter out the chlorine first if you are on public water. If you are on a well, then you are better off because you don't have to filter out the water first.

* Your best bet is a hydrogen peroxide system. However, you would have to buy an expensive system to do it. It can't be dumped in because the exact level of hydrogen peroxide is important... otherwise, it can destroy the pool lining, I think.

* Your best bet, all around, is ozonation with hydrogen peroxide use. It is easier to manage, but ozonation doesn't destroy algae, just bacteria. Using hydrogen peroxide can help.

* Bromine is an alternative to chlorine... but it is also a toxin. Sensitive individuals who cannot tolerate chlorine often also have problems with bromine. Bromine is a preferred choice for Olympic pools (and I don't know why).

* Health departments have mandates requiring you to use chlorine. Inspectors judge the sanitation of your pool based on chlorine levels as stipulated by local law. It can be very difficult to get waivers without having lawmakers change the law. If you don't have the right level of chlorine, the inspector has to fail the pool, even if the inspector knows that you have taken care of pool sanitation through other means. However, the inspector doesn't have to report the "failing" mark on your pool. You can appeal to the inspector not to report it; thus, no action will take place to shut down the pool, even though it may be out of compliance with the chlorine standard for sanitation.

-- Caitlin :yawning:
post #18 of 19
cwaddick, read my posts. I explained how the salt works, and it does disinfect the water. We are in our fourth year and have had no problems. Dh added a 10kg bag of salt last week, and that will probably be it for the season. And that's only because of having to lower the water level when closing.

Apparently something like 90% of new Australian pools are salt.
post #19 of 19
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Natural Body Care
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Natural Body Care › chlorine-free pools