Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Did anybody have a husband that didn't really care?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Did anybody have a husband that didn't really care?

post #1 of 34
Thread Starter 
I hear so much about "I did it because my husband wanted it done" or "I don't know how to convince my husband not to do it" or "I brought it up, it turned into a huge fight" and even "my marriage might be over now!"

But did anyone have a husband that really didn't care one way or another?

When we found our our first was a boy, I said "well, now we have to talk about circumcision." His first response was "What do you mean talk about it, isn't it just...done?" I told him that no, it's actually our decision, and I had just started reading about it, and I was surprised at what I found. I started to tell him about how it's purely a cultural or religious thing, not medical at all, then I started to describe HOW it was done. He interrupted me and said "Okay, whatever you want honey, you're the researcher!"

And that was that! We didn't talk about it again until Ian was born. I shared a post partum room with a mom of a baby boy, and the dr came in and said to the other mom "I understand you want him circumcized, do you have any questions?" and my husband said "that poor baby, he has no clue what's about to happen to him!" and he hugged our perfect baby boy tighter to his chest.

So for me, it was very easy. My husband is not an intactivist at all, he thinks that circumcision is a stupid thing to do, but doesn't see it as a major rights violation either. So I guess he's in the camp of "not my kid, but do whatever you want to yours" whereas I'm in the camp of "outlaw this horrific procedure!!" So we're not exactly eye-to-eye, but there was never any tension about the topic.

Anyone else have a husband or partner that was surprisingly easy to convince?
post #2 of 34
My DH and I are EXACTLY the same as you guys! lol DH listens to me talk about how it's a violation and all that, and he says he wishes the decision had been left up to him, but doesn't get all that excited about it. So yes, it was no problem at all. Thank goodness!
post #3 of 34
My DH isn't a hardcore intactivist, and he isn't attached to the idea that he should be mourning his foreskin that is long gone... But when I brought up the whole " So if we have a boy, I'm not down with circing him" thing, he was like "why would we do that?". It didn't take any research or anything, which was a wonderful relief.
post #4 of 34
I believe that both my ex and dh would have circ'd without even thinking about it. However, they both knew this was very much a hill I'd die on, and it just wasn't that big an issue to either of them. I have to admit that I think if dh were married to a woman (say we'd split up or I died or something) that wanted to circ, he'd probably do it. He just doesn't care either way.
post #5 of 34
My DH is intact and doesn't understand why I too think "outlaw this horrific procedure!!". He still sees it as parental choice. But I haven't really brought it up too much with him because he thinks I'm a little strange in my intactivism as circumcision doesn't affect me in my life with our boys or my husband. He just doesn't care to think about it. He thinks it's a stupid choice if parents choose to circ but isn't really quite an intactivist.
post #6 of 34
Quote:
Originally Posted by MyBoysBlue View Post
My DH is intact and doesn't understand why I too think "outlaw this horrific procedure!!". He still sees it as parental choice. But I haven't really brought it up too much with him because he thinks I'm a little strange in my intactivism as circumcision doesn't affect me in my life with our boys or my husband. He just doesn't care to think about it. He thinks it's a stupid choice if parents choose to circ but isn't really quite an intactivist.
This sounds a lot like my DH. He is intact, and wouldn't have tried to convince me to circ our 3 boys, or anything, but he doesn't give it much more thought than that.
post #7 of 34
My DP wants to circ if we ever have any boys (my intact DS is from a previous relationship), but not enough to fight me on it. I told him long long ago that it was a hill to die on for me. He thinks I'm being ridiculous when I get so passionate about it but he's willing to humor me, I guess.
post #8 of 34
My (circ'ed) husband took no convincing at all. We talked about it a few years before DS was born (I was against it, but not as hard core about it as I am now), and I just said something along the lines of, "If we have a boy, I don't want to circumcise him. That means, at some point, you might have to explain to him why your penis looks different than his. Are you okay with that?" He looked at me like I was nuts, said, "Yeah. Why wouldn't I be?" and that was the end of the discussion. Over the years, we've had more talks about circ, but there was never a time where I had to 'convince' him of anything.
post #9 of 34
My dh was clearly in the no circ camp when I asked him about it while we were dating. His exact response was "Hell no would I do that to a child and frankly, I'd like mine back".

The circumcision issue was a main deciding factor in a marriage candidate for me. I wouldn't have married a pro circ man.
post #10 of 34
Well, whoever I end up marrying will know long in advance that circumcision is something I'm opposed to, so that battle is pre-determined. I don't really have the patience or the endurance to fight it, and thankfully it seems that people from my generation tend to be a little more "meh, whatever" on these things. To me, it isn't even a fight; it's a fact. My kids will be intact, and if he has any issues with that, he'll have to get over it and work through his feelings on his own, because I frankly find it really weird that we women (and sometimes men) have to fight so hard to defend not performing surgery.
post #11 of 34
Yeah, it didn't take much convincing for my dh either. We didn't know what we were having, but I thought I'd research it anyway just in case we had a boy. I told him I didn't want it done, and he was like, "ok". Now that he's more educated about it, he does get a little mad if we find out that friends of ours are going to do it/just did it. A friend of ours made some comment when she was pregnant that made him think they were going to go ahead and have their baby circ'd if it was a boy. Dh said to me later, "You have to talk to her about not circing!" Unfortunately, I did talk to her, she did have a boy, and apparently what I said didn't change her mind .
post #12 of 34
I don't think DH really cared much, before DS was born. I brought it up, and he basically said he trusted my opinion, and that if I thought it wasn't right to do it, he would stand by me. But he really didn't have strong feelings against it.

Then a few months after DS was born, he watched one of those videos I've seen people post on here occasionally, of the procedure being done. After that, he came to me and told me how glad he was that I'd known not to have it done, and how horrified he was that he might have unthinkingly subjected DS to that if it hadn't been for me doing the research.
post #13 of 34
I thought for sure that my DH would need a lot of convincing - but he was surprisingly easy, too. At first, he said, "No, he needs to be done." And then I made him watch the Penn & Teller video on it ... and he said he needed to think about it. After a few days, he said, "Okay, we won't circ." And that was that, never another word.
post #14 of 34
Mine! I basically said it wouldn't be done and that was that. I overheard him talking to someone on the phone and I heard him say something like "He won't be, Mindie doesn't believe in it."

I also didn't have to plea with him about the home birth thing either.
I am so in love and think I will keep him.
post #15 of 34
We've had only girls but had the talk before we conceived our last dd. He was pretty easy going. His only question was if our son would get teased in school about it since his one uncircumsized friend use to get harrassed. I told him the stats on how many are circ'ed and not now and he said 'ok, i trust your judgement and research'.

I recently have heard him say in response to others that women don't ask why their labias/vulva's, ect are different than their mothers, so why would a son care if his penis is different than his dad's. This was after I had him watch the video of an infant being circ'ed. So clearly he's on board, but it was never a fight.
post #16 of 34
I said "we're not circ'ing." And dh said "ok."
post #17 of 34
dh didn't take any convincing, really. penn and teller sealed it for him, and now he's quite the intactavist, despite being circ'd himself.
post #18 of 34
XH was cool about it. I said, "If we have a boy, I don't think we should have him circumcised." He shrugged and said, "OK." And that was it. He knows I research everything to death before I make a decision, so he was pretty laid-back about things like that. And that was even before I got all rabidly anti-circ. I just thought it wasn't necessary, so why do it. XMIL, on the other hand, had a panic attack. Literally. She thought it meant that XH was mad at her for having him circ'd.
post #19 of 34
I brought up circ pretty early in my relationship with DP because it's an issue I feel very strongly about that would influence my decisions about whether or not to get more serious with a person depending on their stance and how strongly they felt about that stance.

He said he had never thought about it, but that if I felt that strongly based on research that I've done that there was no way he would ever pressure me to do it and he would defer to me because I'm more informed about it than he is. He is circed, doesn't want to restore and thinks he's fine the way he is, but doesn't care about his son looking like him or anything silly like that. So we had a couple of chats about it here and there and I reiterated it when we found out we were pregnant, but it's just not a big debate around here.
post #20 of 34
DH didn't have an opinion one way or the other. I think he could have guessed that I wouldn't be cutting any future children since I already had my Anti circ bumper stickers on my car when we met.

When I became pregnant with DD, it never even came up. It was a complete non issue and no discussion was needed.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Did anybody have a husband that didn't really care?