New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Advice Please!

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
I hope this is a good place to post this. It does have to do with decluttering, although it also involves lots of fun, psychological issues. Whoopie!!

Over ten years ago, when I first married DH, MIL “surprised” me with an unwelcome wedding gift—a large, six-seater colonial/country-style dining room table. She had obviously spent a lot of money on it, just as she spent a lot of money trying to decorate our place to her standards (e.g. fake flowers, wall hangings that she liked, you get the picture).

Being the young, blushing bride, I did not speak up and tell her the truth—namely, that the table was totally not my style! (I tend toward a much more contemporary look). Sure, she should have consulted with me and taken my own tastes under consideration. And sure, I should have been tactful and honest with her. But we’re well past the “would’ve-could’ve-should’ve phase.” My question is . . . what do I do now???

Over the years, I have gradually decluttered some of the smaller things, such as the wall hangings. (“Oh that? Hmmmm. I’m not sure. I think we lost it in the move ) But it’s kind of hard to come up with a white lie about this particular monstrosity.

MIL lives out of town but visits frequently. Except for the table, everything else is (finally!!) to my tastes . But she will comment on the table’s absense, and people-pleasing me (I know, I know ) feels a twinge of guilt when I ponder how much she must have spent on it. And DH is adamant about avoiding a “confrontation” about it.

The way I see it, I have these options:

1. Another white lie. Although it’s kind of hard to come up with one for this monstrosity. (“Oops! Did I lose that in the move too? ) It's not like she's stupid. I'm sure she's caught on to her stuff "disappearing" over the years...
2. Something “tragic” happens to ruin the table—although the Monstrosity is quite durable; I can’t think of anything that a professional restoration service couldn’t take care of.
3. The obvious solution: Get rid of it, replace it, and tell the truth. But since I’m short on eloquence, do you have any idea on how I should phrase it?

I’d welcome other ideas, too. What do you think? WWYD???

It doesn’t help that was at World Market today drooling over their dining room tables!
post #2 of 10
offer it back to her, along with the long-in-coming explanation that it's just not your style "anymore." say something like, i know you must have spent a lot of money on it, and we appreciate that, but we are going to make a change, and wanted to let you know in advance in case you or someone else you know would like to have it next.

think of this as your opportunity to grow out of the people pleaser and into the person who values herself.
post #3 of 10
i agree with ellies momma.

i would offer it back to her, recognizing that it was a lovely gift, that it must have been expensive, and that it is not longer to your taste. in the alternative, you could assert that you need a larger/smaller/different shaped table for that space.
post #4 of 10
I agree with the others. That is what I would do as well.
post #5 of 10
Thread Starter 
Thank you!!
post #6 of 10
Totally agree with the others. Or you could tell her you decided to redo the whole room so she doesn't think you are "picking" on her or anything. I could see my Dad flipping if we got rid of a piece of furniture that he got us (he never would get us anything but anything he did would probably be not something I would keep) but totally understanding some flight of fancy of mine to redo a room since it didn't "suit me anymore".
post #7 of 10
Chiming in late here, but I completely agree with previous posters. I know I would find it hard to say, but you must! It is YOUR home and you should have it the way you want finally!!

Good luck! Let us know how it goes.
post #8 of 10
So have you told her?
I agree with the advice- and there's no time like the present, better to just get it over and done with, now that you've decided to go with your own style!

We're rooting for you!!!
post #9 of 10
I may be too late, but: Does your DH agree that the table should go? Or is he at least willing to cooperate?

Because it's _his_ mother, and I think that everybody's better off if he falls on the sword, not you. He could tell his mother that he's decided that you need X in the dining room, and that X doesn't work with the table. Or, frankly, that _he_ has never liked the table.

Unless you need to make a principle of demonstrating your authority, it's much, much better if this comes from her son.

Crayfish
post #10 of 10
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunshineafterrain View Post
So have you told her?
Not yet! LOL! We still need to wait a couple of paychecks for the one that I want...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crayfish View Post
Because it's _his_ mother, and I think that everybody's better off if he falls on the sword, not you. He could tell his mother that he's decided that you need X in the dining room, and that X doesn't work with the table. Or, frankly, that _he_ has never liked the table.

Unless you need to make a principle of demonstrating your authority, it's much, much better if this comes from her son.

Crayfish
DH really doesn’t care how I decorate. That said, I think you make an excellent point. I’ll talk to DH….
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home