Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Family Safety › What to do about helmet in bike trailer
New Posts  All Forums:
 

What to do about helmet in bike trailer

post #1 of 30
6/17/10 at 11:23pm
Thread Starter 
DD is 1, she is fine with her helmet when she is on her tricycle, but we just got a bike trailer and she freaks out about wearing her helmet in it. We actually thought she was unconscious the first time we put her in it with the helmet on, she slumped to one side and was not responding to us. Apparently it all has to do with the use of the helmet.

So I am wondering what to do about this. I am a mom who ALWAYS makes my kids wear their helmets. I was thinking about putting a pillow behind her back so her head wasn't pushed forward with the helmet on. I need ideas on how to keep her safe and comfortable.

We only ride on the sidewalks in our neighborhood for short rides. How can i make this work?
Sponsored Links
post #2 of 30
6/18/10 at 12:12am


No advice, just looking forward to the responses. Our DD is also 1 and is not wild about the trailer/helmet setup. In our situation, I think it is more the trailer that makes her nervous and the helmet is just an added oddity.
post #3 of 30
6/18/10 at 12:47pm
How flat is the back of the helmet? The flatter the better because it does push their head forward uncomfortably. My DD got a different helmet and it made a big difference.
post #4 of 30
6/18/10 at 6:55pm
Thread Starter 
The helmet is actually really flat in the back. We have two different brands and have the same problem with both.

She loves the trailer, just need to figure out the helmet thing.
post #5 of 30
6/19/10 at 1:22am
Maybe try one of those u-shaped neck pillows, liek the kind you use on the airplane.

I would for sure require the helmet even in the trailor!
post #6 of 30
6/19/10 at 3:26am
Doe's your trailer have a seat which allows room ro a helmet? Ours is supposed to (and does slope back at the top of the seat) but DS at 3.5 is only just tall enough that his head reaches into it. If yours is similar maybe a cushion to sit on would move her head to a more comfortable position.

I have also been know to pack DS in with cusions on either side since he often falls asleep in the trailer. It looks really uncomfortable when he slumps off to one side.
post #7 of 30
6/19/10 at 12:37pm
Do you let her use the helmet outside of the trailer? My son liked to wear his around the house when playing and so was much more receptive to wearing it in the trailer.

ETA: I see that she wears it on her tricycle. Please disregard.
post #8 of 30
6/20/10 at 12:35am
My dd is 3.5 and is a good helmet wearer but i jus wanted to say that you shouldnt be riding your bike on the sidewalk it is illegal in some places and isnt a good practice
post #9 of 30
8/5/10 at 4:54pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by LaughingHyena View Post
Doe's your trailer have a seat which allows room ro a helmet? Ours is supposed to (and does slope back at the top of the seat) but DS at 3.5 is only just tall enough that his head reaches into it. If yours is similar maybe a cushion to sit on would move her head to a more comfortable position.
I had this exact problem when trying out the bike trailer for the first time. DS isn't crazy about the helmet to begin with, and then when he's in the trailer, he can't keep his head upright because of the helmet pushing against the back of the seat. Laughing Hyena, which trailer do you have, that has a space for the back of the helmet?
post #10 of 30
8/6/10 at 4:58am
Quote:
Laughing Hyena, which trailer do you have, that has a space for the back of the helmet?
It's a burley, I think the d lite. It's an older model, I don't think I could justify buying a new one even though I use it most days for the school run.
post #11 of 30
8/6/10 at 8:22am
I appreciate that you are trying to instill good practice of Bike Riding = Helmet Wearing. But consider for just one moment that a bike helmet is designed to protect the skull from a fall off a bicycle. Your DD, while strapped in the bike trailer, is neither on a bicycle nor in danger of falling off of one. A bicycle helmet is not a crash helmet. It probably will not protect the skull if you are plowed into by a car, no matter where the rider is situated. Some people have argued that if a small child is wearing a helmet in a trailer, the weight of the helmet and the positioning of the child actually puts your child more at risk for neck injuries if a mishap occurs.

Your trailer, equipped with a 5 point harness? Designed with a roll bar type structure? Child is enclosed entirely by cloth/screening to keep arms/legs in and sand/dirt out? Hitch is designed so if even bike goes down the trailer stays upright on its own wheels? Trailer sits low relative to axle? If these things are true, than your child is relatively safe. No activity is inherently 100% safe, but this is all about risk assessment.

As prefaced, I am completely supportive of parents who practice safe bicycle riding. You, of course, are wearing your helmet to demonstrate this, which is the best way to reinforce this rule with your child. If it were me, however, and my child was that uncomfortable in the trailer with the helmet on that s/he is going catatonic on me, I would give up the helmet on the LO while explaining Every Single Time that Mommy wears her helmet because she is on a bike and needs to be safe and that Baby is safe because she is in the trailer.
post #12 of 30
8/6/10 at 8:39am
Quote:
Originally Posted by mumofboyz View Post
Your trailer, equipped with a 5 point harness? Designed with a roll bar type structure? Child is enclosed entirely by cloth/screening to keep arms/legs in and sand/dirt out? Hitch is designed so if even bike goes down the trailer stays upright on its own wheels? Trailer sits low relative to axle? If these things are true, than your child is relatively safe. No activity is inherently 100% safe, but this is all about risk assessment.
I agree. Now, if you were putting her in a trailer that did not have a 5pt harness and the roll bar, among other things, then I would probably feel differently. But with trailers that are designed not to flip when the bike does and have saftey features if it actually does, I don't think you have as much to worry about.
post #13 of 30
8/6/10 at 1:14pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by mumofboyz View Post
I appreciate that you are trying to instill good practice of Bike Riding = Helmet Wearing. But consider for just one moment that a bike helmet is designed to protect the skull from a fall off a bicycle. Your DD, while strapped in the bike trailer, is neither on a bicycle nor in danger of falling off of one. A bicycle helmet is not a crash helmet. It probably will not protect the skull if you are plowed into by a car, no matter where the rider is situated. Some people have argued that if a small child is wearing a helmet in a trailer, the weight of the helmet and the positioning of the child actually puts your child more at risk for neck injuries if a mishap occurs.

Your trailer, equipped with a 5 point harness? Designed with a roll bar type structure? Child is enclosed entirely by cloth/screening to keep arms/legs in and sand/dirt out? Hitch is designed so if even bike goes down the trailer stays upright on its own wheels? Trailer sits low relative to axle? If these things are true, than your child is relatively safe. No activity is inherently 100% safe, but this is all about risk assessment.

As prefaced, I am completely supportive of parents who practice safe bicycle riding. You, of course, are wearing your helmet to demonstrate this, which is the best way to reinforce this rule with your child. If it were me, however, and my child was that uncomfortable in the trailer with the helmet on that s/he is going catatonic on me, I would give up the helmet on the LO while explaining Every Single Time that Mommy wears her helmet because she is on a bike and needs to be safe and that Baby is safe because she is in the trailer.
This is our approach. I think some it it also comes down to where/how you ride. I know some people don't like the riding on sidewalks approach, but- particularly when riding with a sibling- it may be the safest place. Here, we don't have sidewalks, but we do have loads of car-free roads.

Neither of my boys tolerate a helmet in the trailer, and I am comfortable with the safety features of the trailer. If they were in a carrier mounted ON the bike where there was a risk of falling they would wear a helmet. In the trailer, they do not.
post #14 of 30
8/7/10 at 5:19pm
i'm in the no helmet in trailer group.

i have my dc wear helmets in almost all situations ( bike, razor type scooter, even tricycles) but not in a trailer due to the position it puts the dc's head forward
post #15 of 30
8/7/10 at 6:01pm
I always made the kids wear helmets in the burley- but we live in a very bike-friendly city and are always biking on roads with cars.
post #16 of 30
8/8/10 at 12:12am
Quote:
Originally Posted by mumofboyz View Post
I appreciate that you are trying to instill good practice of Bike Riding = Helmet Wearing. But consider for just one moment that a bike helmet is designed to protect the skull from a fall off a bicycle. Your DD, while strapped in the bike trailer, is neither on a bicycle nor in danger of falling off of one. A bicycle helmet is not a crash helmet. It probably will not protect the skull if you are plowed into by a car, no matter where the rider is situated. Some people have argued that if a small child is wearing a helmet in a trailer, the weight of the helmet and the positioning of the child actually puts your child more at risk for neck injuries if a mishap occurs.
Yep, this is our point of view as well. We didn't use a helmet with our daughter in the bike trailer as there was NO chance of her falling out and her head hitting the pavement.
post #17 of 30
8/9/10 at 9:51am
Quote:
Originally Posted by snomnky View Post
DD is 1, she is fine with her helmet when she is on her tricycle, but we just got a bike trailer and she freaks out about wearing her helmet in it. We actually thought she was unconscious the first time we put her in it with the helmet on, she slumped to one side and was not responding to us. Apparently it all has to do with the use of the helmet.

So I am wondering what to do about this. I am a mom who ALWAYS makes my kids wear their helmets. I was thinking about putting a pillow behind her back so her head wasn't pushed forward with the helmet on. I need ideas on how to keep her safe and comfortable.

We only ride on the sidewalks in our neighborhood for short rides. How can i make this work?
What we did was put DS in an infant bucket car seat! He had pretty much outgrown it for car use (not technically outgrown, but looked all squished) so we moved him into a rear facing diplomat in the car) and installed it in the trailer. He loved it and usually fell asleep while we went on bike trips. We only rode it on the bike path and only were on the road on teh way to the bike path. We occasionally took it down the street to the local coop grocery store, but that was only when he was older and did okay with the helmet instead.
post #18 of 30
8/9/10 at 9:58am
Quote:
Originally Posted by hollytheteacher View Post
What we did was put DS in an infant bucket car seat! He had pretty much outgrown it for car use (not technically outgrown, but looked all squished) so we moved him into a rear facing diplomat in the car) and installed it in the trailer. He loved it and usually fell asleep while we went on bike trips. We only rode it on the bike path and only were on the road on teh way to the bike path. We occasionally took it down the street to the local coop grocery store, but that was only when he was older and did okay with the helmet instead.
I don't know about your bike trailer, but mine says specifically not to do this on the warning/saftey label and I've seen numerous websites say that is not safe. (though maybe you have a trailer in which this is acceptable, holly?)
post #19 of 30
8/9/10 at 1:22pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrsfrenchy View Post
I don't know about your bike trailer, but mine says specifically not to do this on the warning/saftey label and I've seen numerous websites say that is not safe. (though maybe you have a trailer in which this is acceptable, holly?)
I'm not really sure as it was second hand and we did not get the instruction manual. I felt okay doing it because we were not using the bike in traffic, only on a bike path. So in my mind, worse case senario is DH or I fall off our bike and maybe at the worst the bike trailer falls over (although i think they are pretty much designed not to) and since he was strapped into his infant seat, it seemed like a "pretty safe" combination....

We did this when DS was 10 months old ish i believe...he has a late summer bday and we wanted to take hiim on the bike path for long bike rides so that is the best we could do. They don't reallly make helmets for kids that young and it's probably not best for their neck to be holding them up that young either...
I'm sure someone will come on and say it wasn't safe, but we did what worked for us and it felt pretty safe.
post #20 of 30
8/9/10 at 1:50pm
I also don't make my child wear a helmet in the Burley. It just looks way too uncomfortable, and as others have said, with the 5-pt harness and roll bar, I'm comfortable with the risks. We also always use helmets when on a bike or scooter.
New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Family Safety
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Family Safety › What to do about helmet in bike trailer