Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Experiences with different raw milk sources, A1/A2 connections?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Experiences with different raw milk sources, A1/A2 connections?

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I am pregnant with baby number three, and have been practically living off of whole, raw cow milk. Almost two years ago, through muscle testing at my NP, I tested allergic to cow dairy. I went in with a RAGING ear ache after having had ear aches my whole life. And he broke my heart telling me I couldn't drink the milk from my own cow. I would reluctantly go off, and start to feel better, and then try again weeks later to feel my earache coming back.

When my Jersey was done lactating, I went off raw milk for over six weeks. But I finally broke down and started getting milk from my Mom, who also has a Jersey. I thought I would have instant ear aches. I was prepared to deal with it, being stubborn and loving my raw milk. Surprisingly, I am now drinking over half a gallon of raw milk almost every day(have been for a while now), and I feel GREAT. No ear ache. No congestion. No stomach aches.

So I've read a bit about the A1 and A2 story on cow genetics. It seems very relevant to me. Having had raw milk from many different cows in my lifetime, and only being successful with a certain few, it seems that there is definite stuffing in the theory. I grew up on a Jersey/Hereford(a beef breed) cross raw milk. Ear aches. We then switched over in my late teens to a pure bred Jersey. No ear aches. Moved from my parent's home and stopped drinking raw milk, and limited consuming most milk products, but would get occasional ear aches. Moved back near my parent's after my son's birth and went back to drinking milk from the same cow they had in my teens. No ear aches. Met my hubby, went vegan for a year. No ear aches. Got a farm and our own cow(no longer vegan) and began experiencing ear aches again. Switched to milk from my Mom's cow(good old Sasha, cow from my teens) and NO ear aches. Accidentally got slipped milk from my Mom's Holstein/Jersey cross a few times and had minor flare-ups. These went away when I told my Mom I ONLY WANTED SASHA'S MILK!

So I am thinking that Sasha must be an A2 cow. I've read that Jerseys are approximately 50% A2. Sadly, I think my own Jersey falls into the A1 bracket. I have started drinking milk from Sasha's daughter, and have had no problems... She must have gotten her Mom's A2 genes. When all of my siblings and I were VERY young, my parents raised goats because none of us could tolerate cow dairy at the time. So it all makes sense to me, after having experimented my whole life.

What are your experiences with raw milk from different breeds of cows? Do you put any stock in the A1/A2 theory? From those of you who conquered former dairy sensitivities; what does your raw milk source look like? Just interested to hear other peoples experiences and to see if they coincide with A1 and A2 compatibilities/incompatibilities.
post #2 of 4
I've never dealt with sensitivites to milk raw or not and have had raw milk from two different sources (both holsteins, I think. I honestly never asked the one source or got around to seeing their farm before switching back to my original source... I just prefer her milk, and the other I kept having issues with it going sour w/in like 2 or 3 days...). I honestly have no clue if either source has a1/a2 milk.... and I don't really care. IMO its a load of crock to sell a testing kit (cause' isn't there like only one company that sells the darn things? And it costs a butload to do.... thus hardly anybody has botherd to do the testing...) and certain farms' milk over others/breeding stock from different cows.
post #3 of 4
This is probably obvious, but would your mom be willing to trade Sasha for your Jersey?

Of course I assume Sasha is a lot bigger and more productive. Hmm.

I dunno about A1/A2 but I firmly believe in doing whatever works. We humans think science has figured it all out but I think we're still a looooong ways away.
post #4 of 4
Thread Starter 
I absolutely agree that science is far from having everything figured out. And I think that no matter how much it DOES have figured out, that it will never be close to the whole story. I do think, though, that little things like this do help to shed light and provide direction for people who would have to give up otherwise.

While I understand that there may be a company(or many) trying to exploit the information for profit, I don't think that makes the discovery invalid. If we avoided every single bit of information that were being exploited for money, we'd all have to sit in sensory deprivation boxes. I don't think there is enough info or research out there yet to be able to say anything truly definitive. There may never be. That is why I came here to ask about others' experiences. In my case, it would seem that SOMETHING must be going on because I thrive on raw milk from one cow, and my health plummets drinking raw milk from another cow.

I am not particularly interested in trading cows. Sasha is getting pretty old. *haha* I am going to sell my cow. The plan is to get goats sometime.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Traditional Foods
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Experiences with different raw milk sources, A1/A2 connections?