Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Ikea - yay or nay?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Ikea - yay or nay? - Page 3

post #41 of 60
I love Ikea for rooms that get a lot of living..it serves a purpose really well, providing attractive reasonably priced things that are good quality. It is great for kids rooms.

We just got new bookshelves from there for my study, which look awesome. We also bought a CD storage unit, and also a shelf for the laundry about 12 years ago from Ikea...the CD unit is still going strong, but the laundry shelf is coming apart at the seams...however it has had a lot of use!
post #42 of 60
I have Ikea stuff from the '80s!

I also have items from the 90s and 2000s.

The key things to keep in mind have already been said, but I think they are worth repeating. My personal criteria when shopping at Ikea:

~ Location: Where will the item be used?
~ Purpose: What will it be used for and by whom?
~ Materials: Know what you are buying. Does it fit the intended location and purpose?
~ and no drawers (unless high-end).

One of the things I really love about Ikea is how fun it is to shop there and how I can test each item I am considering myself and see what life in the store has done to it already. I do keep in mind that store life is harder than my house, but the items don't stay out in the store as long as I want to use them so it evens out in certain respects and is valuable information for me. I try to go to Ikea by myself because my family doesn't enjoy the experience as much as I do. I only bring them along once I have things narrowed down or the item is for one of them. Our Ikea is five miles from our house and is in the same shopping center as Costco, Lowes, and one of our public library branches (and a long row of small stores/restaurants). It is easy for us all to go together in one car and then split up and come back together.

Before this location existed, I would stop at one of the Ikea stores on any drive to/through the LA area -- timing it during open hours, of course. Before those existed, I would visit Ikea when I visited my family in Northern VA. I don't recall a time before that Ikea existed!

Another thing I love about Ikea is how DH & I were able to purchase every piece of furniture in our family office over a period of ten years from Ikea and it all looks like it came from one store at one time. Instead, it came from various lines at various times, but the finish is the same on each piece. While I love the desks we chose, I do not love the drawers on them. They are annoyingly short (front to back) and get caught if you don't open them just right. Mid-priced line. OTOH, we paid for the high-end lateral filing cabinet and configured it to have a storage cabinet on top with doors. That drawer is top-notch and still works like a dream after 8+ years. Seeing as I have purchased items for ten years specifically for this room all in the same finish, I can tell you without a doubt that the quality of materials has declined in that time -- especially in the finish in the last 3-4 years. The last two pieces we've purchased are slightly different than the rest. I can tell, but visitors cannot because those pieces are in the darker corners of the room and it isn't noticeable at all.

Every room in our house has at least one item from Ikea in it, except maybe our master bathroom.... Although, the shower curtain rings may be from Ikea.
post #43 of 60

Another IKEA Shopping Family

We shop at IKEA too. As others have said, it's not heirloom quality, but it's good enough. IKEA tends to be kind of funky and trendy anyway. I don't imagine we'd want a lot of our IKEA furniture to last twenty years.

IKEA stuff usually has a good resale value too. It's easy to find a home new for your IKEA purchases when you're done with them.

One thing about IKEA though, is that it's easy to go and start out looking at the cheap stuff only to get sucked in by the more expensive stuff. And by the time you're looking at their more expensive stuff, you could afford to be shopping somewhere nicer.

We love their expedit line. DH took three expedit 2x4 units and built a "custom" built-it entertainment unit for the media room in the basement of our old house. We got great feedback from everybody who came through when we sold.

We actually have the IKEA catalog pretty much committed to memory. DH and I love to play "spot that item from IKEA" when we watch tv and movies.

Our kids don't even know that IKEA sells furniture. They think it's a play place that sells ice cream.
post #44 of 60
It's ok, although not the greatest. You really have to check for particle board, which most of it is. But not all of it.
post #45 of 60
I agree with pp's that it depends on what you are buying & your goals.

Personally I wouldn't buy another one of there beds ever. Ours was junk from day one - the slats kept crashing through & I had to modify it myself to keep from falling to the floor in the middle of the night, every night. Then the leg snapped in half while moving it & to replace it we would have had to buy a whole new bed.

But, we purchased all of our kitchen cabinets & countertops from IKEA & LOVE them. They are good quality & solid - comparable to others we looked at from a variety of places.

Their accessories are generally pretty reliable but I wouldn't trust the furniture to be too rugged - especially if you want to move it frequently.
post #46 of 60
Thread Starter 
We went. We saw. We bought....

Thanks everyone for the input. And I absolutely see what you mean re: some things are high quality, and some are... not quite so.

Stayed away from the particle board/fiber stuff, bought some hardwood items.

Speaking of - OMG! The toy storage!! Ack! I bought toy organizers for my toddlers room.. I wish to god I'd seen their stuff when I was pregnant - soooo cute!! Ack!

We're going back to Toronto next month (off topic - to see Tegan & Sara/City & Color in concert!!!) and I'm going to buy more decorative stuff - rugs, lamps, end tables, etc.

I think I'm officially hooked.
post #47 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ceinwen View Post
Speaking of - OMG! The toy storage!! Ack! I bought toy organizers for my toddlers room.. I wish to god I'd seen their stuff when I was pregnant - soooo cute!! Ack!



I think I'm officially hooked.
their storage, in general, is soooooo awesome!

we bought a huge shelving unit with a bunch of basket and such for our old house and it transformed our kitchen.

love their storage solutions.....
post #48 of 60
What about cribs?

Are they sturdy? We have a 1.5 story house with small bedrooms and I want the crib to fit with one end against the short wall but most cribs I've seen are flimsy cheap (walmart) or heavy and expensive (everywhere else).

ETA: I meant the smaller/shorter ones are cheap/flimsy where the solidly built cribs are all HUGE and expensive. I want solid and small, and yes, baby would sleep in it at some point.
post #49 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by HeatherAtHome View Post
What about cribs?

Are they sturdy? We have a 1.5 story house with small bedrooms and I want the crib to fit with one end against the short wall but most cribs I've seen are flimsy cheap (walmart) or heavy and expensive (everywhere else).
Are you planning to use the crib as a place where your small baby will sleep regularly, or do you just need it for show and occasionally so you can put the baby somewhere safe?

I wouldn't use an Ikea crib as a regular sleeping place, they just don't strike me as sturdy enough. However, if I was going to cosleep but needed a crib just so I could say I had one, then I would be fine with an Ikea one.
post #50 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by HeatherAtHome View Post
What about cribs?

Are they sturdy? We have a 1.5 story house with small bedrooms and I want the crib to fit with one end against the short wall but most cribs I've seen are flimsy cheap (walmart) or heavy and expensive (everywhere else).

ETA: I meant the smaller/shorter ones are cheap/flimsy where the solidly built cribs are all HUGE and expensive. I want solid and small, and yes, baby would sleep in it at some point.
We have an IKEA crib. I can't remember the name of the model (starts with an H, I think), but we have really liked it. It seems sturdy enough. I guess we didn't use it that much when DD was little since we co-slept most of the time. But she is currently using as a toddler bed, and it has been just fine.
post #51 of 60
I have a love/hate relationship with IKEA. I love the style and price, but hate that they use so many synthetics. We have learned a lot of lessons. Bought our kitchen cabinetry there, the bases are particle board and they are falling apart, and for a long time off-gassed formaldehyde. Bought some "all wood" dressers, assuming that "all wood" meant "all wood." The drawer bottoms were particle board and made me so sick we had to replace them, and that was a major pain. They're also not the sturdiest things. But, I can't complain too much because there is no way I could get that style anywhere else for a price we could even remotely afford.

We have a halogen lighting fixture in which we've only had to replace two of the bulbs in five years. Amazing. I bought some large metal storage bins -- I despise plastic. I mean, where else can you find metal storage bins? So while I wish they would find a way not to use so much plastic and chemicals that make people sick, I do appreciate that they at least make an effort with some of their products.
post #52 of 60
We've only been once and were not too impressed - much looked junky and much was MIC (at least the kitchenware). The items for children's rooms and playrooms, like colorful rugs and storage, looked cute and were inexpensive - wished I hadn't already furnished those areas and might revisit IKEA when we redecorate the children’s rooms. (e.g. For our playroom, they had inexpensive large colorful shaggy rugs; prior to our IKEA trip I had a piece of red shaggy carpet bound from the carpet store that looked similar and cost much more.)

Maybe based upon all the positive reviews, I need to take another trip to IKEA.


Regarding furniture, although we purchase much new I love buying used from Craigslist. We just purchased a solid wood and mahogany veneered kidney shaped desk for $75 and a mahogany buffet for $300. Both need a little work and are older styles (around 1930/40's) but they are solid, well made and no new trees were cut and the old furniture isn't thrown away. It is difficult to find more modern clean-lined used furniture; but I've noticed many beautiful contemporary styled Heywood Wakefield pieces on Craigslist lately.
post #53 of 60
My issue with Ikea is that you can't replace pieces.

For example, right out of college we bought a small dining room table and 4 chairs. I love, love, love the chairs. In the 18 years since then we have obviously had our needs change. BUT, I couldn't simply buy 4 or 6 more chairs to match our new table. They no longer sell them. The items are often only sold for 4, or 6, or 24 months and then they move on.

(So, if you come for dinner, you'll see the 4 tripp trapp chairs for the kids, the remaining two chairs I love, and a bunch of mismatch chairs. How can I buy new chairs that I don't love? )

Also the same with glass ware. I'll buy 24 or so cheap glasses (.17 a pop!) that I know will get broken over time. But I can't just buy another 12 to add to the remaining few, I'll have to start all over with whatever the current style is, kwim? Currently I have one remaining glass mug with handle, 2 10oz juice glasses, and 4 of the ceramic sort of stacking glasses left for the kids. All of them were purchased in sets of 24. Maybe I should just switch to plastic.
post #54 of 60
We had an Ikea crib and our DD slept in it every night from 4 mo to 22 mo. She wanted nothing to do with my co-sleeping plans after 3 weeks. Between 3w and 4m, she slept in a borrowed bassinet. She started crawling and rocking the bassinet at 4 mos, so we moved her. At 21-22 mos, we slowly moved her to a mattress on the floor because we were going on a long vacation to visit various family and those were going to be the sleeping arrangements. She did great, so we gave the crib away to a friend expecting twins. She then used the crib as a "downstairs" crib for her three youngest kids (ages 14m and twin newborns). When she was finished with it a year or two later, she donated it to a battered women's shelter. It still had plenty of life left in it and they happily accepted it.

I consider that a good return on our $99 investment.
post #55 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunnysandiegan View Post
We had an Ikea crib and our DD slept in it every night from 4 mo to 22 mo. She wanted nothing to do with my co-sleeping plans after 3 weeks. Between 3w and 4m, she slept in a borrowed bassinet. She started crawling and rocking the bassinet at 4 mos, so we moved her. At 21-22 mos, we slowly moved her to a mattress on the floor because we were going on a long vacation to visit various family and those were going to be the sleeping arrangements. She did great, so we gave the crib away to a friend expecting twins. She then used the crib as a "downstairs" crib for her three youngest kids (ages 14m and twin newborns). When she was finished with it a year or two later, she donated it to a battered women's shelter. It still had plenty of life left in it and they happily accepted it.

I consider that a good return on our $99 investment.
Thanks! Now I just need to figure out if it's worth it with shipping... or if I can talk my parents into bringing us to the big city for a shopping trip.
post #56 of 60
Personally, I would want to see it in person before purchasing. Ikea cribs are not the same as the Babies R Us (et al) cribs, so you should know that going in and really get a feel for the differences. It is a no frills crib, at least ours was. As I stated above, it worked great for us and another mom we know and an unknown mom. Not everyone appreciates simplicity, though.
post #57 of 60
The only things I really like from iKEA are my huge metal mixing bowl and the cheap scrub brushes...I think my last apt. I installed some good wall hooks too.
So nope, not a huge fan of them.... Fell for the whole IKEA thing once and won't fall for it again.

DS had some cute pop up hampers, they lasted about 2 years... He also had circle rugs that looked cute but didnt hold up to weekly vacuuming and normal kid play- those were gone w.in a year. I may have gotten him a tinker toy type thing from there that he liked.

Lunch is always good and its close to the mall that has our only 'LEGO' store.
post #58 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ceinwen View Post
We went. We saw. We bought....

Thanks everyone for the input. And I absolutely see what you mean re: some things are high quality, and some are... not quite so.

Stayed away from the particle board/fiber stuff, bought some hardwood items.

Speaking of - OMG! The toy storage!! Ack! I bought toy organizers for my toddlers room.. I wish to god I'd seen their stuff when I was pregnant - soooo cute!! Ack!

We're going back to Toronto next month (off topic - to see Tegan & Sara/City & Color in concert!!!) and I'm going to buy more decorative stuff - rugs, lamps, end tables, etc.

I think I'm officially hooked.
I'm just adding my vote for I Love Ikea!!!

We're about 40 minutes from an Ikea, but I grew up about 10 minutes from one - so we went a lot. We've got probably 4 Billy bookcases, a Billy cd tower, a Poang armchair with footstool, a desk (table top and legs purchased separately) and a few other pieces. I have a (particleboard) computer desk that has lasted 8 years so far. My parents have an Ikea rocking chair that has lasted about 25 years so far (from back when Ikea had a nice/comfortable rocking chair).

Glad you enjoyed it! If you didn't pick up a catalog, make sure to visit their website and order a free catalog by mail.

I also LOVE to check out the As-Is section whenever I'm there. Oh, and I highly recommend the Lingonberry sauce.

(Can anyone else almost smell the hotdogs as they're reading this thread?)
post #59 of 60
I am thinking about heading to Ikea for lunch today....Swedish meatballs, potatoes, Lingonberry sauce....Mmmmmm.... And, the library is next door.... just under five miles from our house, too......
post #60 of 60
I HATE Ikea!!!! Every time we go they are out of what we went for. Every. single. time. We have two Ikeas close to us and it's the same at both. Last time we went they actually had the kids' table and chair set we wanted, but the chairs were out of reach and refused to get them down from the top shelf for us. Then they told us they couldn't be sure when they would restock them. When finally managed to get them on another trip one of the holes was drilled too deep and when we put it together we ended up drilling into our floor.

So we only go to Ikea when we can't avoid it. As much as I hate shopping there they have a wide variety of things at decent prices and a lot of their furniture works well in small spaces. If there's something we like we always look on craigslist first. We just got a leather Ektorp sofa that hadn't ever been used for half price. Most of our stuff is second hand Ikea because it's easy to move and really cheap when it's used.

I'm also really disappointed that all their Scandinavian food is Ikea brand now. My husband and I both lived in Scandinavia and really looked forward to picking up our favorite treats. Now they don't sell them anymore
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Mindful Home
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Ikea - yay or nay?