Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › i have absolutely no idea what im doing re: discipline.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

i have absolutely no idea what im doing re: discipline.

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I really am feeling totally lost here and could use some support and advice. This will probably be long; sorry.

DS is 20.5 months old. As he's coming into himself more and his communication abilities are growing (almost talking in complete sentences now), things seems to be falling apart a bit around here and i feel like a total loser mom. Basically, he completely falls apart the minute he doesnt get what he wants, and Im terribly bothered by how upset he gets.

I have no idea what to do or what the appropriate, healthy GD thing to do or say would be when I find us in certain situations. I have no idea whats normal or not normal or good or bad.

Much of our day is spent with DS in complete melt-down mode. Again, when he doesnt get what he wants immediately he falls apart and screams and cries.

Very General Example: We're drawing on a large piece of paper on the floor with washable markers and he keeps drawing on the floor. After 3 or 4 times of me redirecting his hand back to the paper and saying 'We only draw on paper, we dont draw on the floor, paper is for drawing..', I will say 'The markers will go byebye if we draw on the floor; we only draw on paper.' and when he draws on the floor again, I take the markers away, explaining again with as few words as possible why Im taking them away. Total meltdown.

What do I do at this point? Ignore the tantrum, or try to comfort him and explain why? Let him continue to draw on the floor? Try to quickly get him interested in something else? I have no idea whats right, or what to look for that might tell me if what I did was right or understood by him. I know this example may sound lame/ordinary, but we have about 8 million of these kind of situations happen each day and they really stress me out. I just want to do right by him. And I struggle with being consisten about what I do in response to him because I really get thrown when he gets that upset...

He also still nurses a great deal; which I love and am happy to do. However, he is incredibly demanding about it now. If I dont drop what Im doing immediately and nurse when he asks, we have a total meltdown then as well. What have I done to create this? Is it my fault? Is it just the way he is? I dont feel its healthy for either of us to have things be this way at this point. What can I do to help him be more patient? I have no problem with the nursing, just with the demanding manner of asking and the meltdowns that ensue if he's not nursed within 6 seconds of having yelled, "NUSS!!".


In the past months I just feel he's gone from a super happy and sweet little guy to a fairly miserable one who is unhappy a great deal of the time. This change seems to have coincided with a huge language explosion --- going from single words or two-word phrases to stringing 5 or 6 words together correctly for statements and questions. I guess I thought increased ability to communicate would make things smoother! Silly mama.....

Any thoughts or advice? Again, thanks for reading this far.
post #2 of 6
Sounds like he's testing his boundries. I would continue with the "this is what we do in our house" ie take away the markers for drawing on the floor. When he throws a tantrum what feels right? for me I'd be hugging him and wait for him to calm down. Remind him why it happened and then move onto the next activity.

If ignoring him works for you, I've heard of great success. I can't do it. I have to comfort.

<quote>is this just the way he is?</quote>

Well yes, at 20 months it's pretty normal. the world revolves around him and he's learning he's seperate and can make demands.

You aren't doing anything. It's a developmental thing. Try to just roll with it and practice a lot of deep breathing. You never knew how much patience YOU had until you had kids right?

Let the tantrums come and calm him down whatever works for you. Just hold him, be there with him or whatnot. He will learn eventually. It takes time.

Remember:

THIS TOO SHALL PASS.

He won't be going to college and throwing tantrums when he doesn't get his way.
post #3 of 6
I have 2 boys and my first one was not like that at 20 months, but my second one was. My second one really craves routine and familiarity in his day- this helps- and also has a very concrete sense of himself (whereas my first is very imaginative and dreamy; easily distracted...). I have found what helps with DS2 is being silly to help him learn to be lighthearted about himself and life, and to do "power games" with him so he gets to sometimes feel like he is in charge, and also to be very brief about comfort. I validate him "Wow you are angry the markers went bye bye" a couple times so he knows I understand how he feels, then I am matter of fact "Oh that screaming is loud, I am going to go over here and do xyz" and then I come back to him after a minute (whether or not he is still screaming) and ask him if he's ready for me to scratch his back/give him a hug whatever it is, that is kind of our sign the drama is over... not sure if it will work with yours, but it works for us!
post #4 of 6
Personally I didn't let my kids use markers at that age b/c I figured it would just make a mess lol. However yes his behavior is pretty normal. Does he sleep well?
post #5 of 6
yeah, I was going to say change the situation BEFORE the meltdown happens. Markers on paper on the floor sounds like close to trouble to me I'd either mandate working at a table or stick to crayons.

IME meltdowns/tantrums happen. Once they're going I'm sympathetic to the kid's feelings without giving in. But I have some luck attempting to avoid them ahead of time. (I have a kid who will melt down and beg for a cookie any time. So when we have cookies in the house they are OUT OF SIGHT )

-Angela
post #6 of 6
NAK: This may be a bit rambly...
My dd (19 mos) acts like that when she's tired or has had sugar. A tiny bit of sugar makes her super volatile. Same with sleep. If she's even a little over tired she is a terror. You may want evaluate your ds's sleep habits.
As far as drawing on the floor...either get rid of the markers or let him draw on the floor. In general I avoid "concept rules", like not coloring on certain surfaces. The only rules I have for dd are
1 no climbing on the dining room table
2 no playing with cat litter
3 no hitting/throwing/biting
4 she must sit at the dinner table until mommy and daddy are done eating (10 mins or so)

Other than that she has complete freedom. Our place is very well baby proofed so there are no major safety concerns around here. We also don't have anything breakable/tearable within her sight.

Another thing I've noticed is that dd almost always obeys me, but I have to ask her a few times. I think it takes a while for her to understand a command, and then decide to obey. So if I say "Time for a diaper change" she immediately says "NO!". Then I wait a few seconds and say it again. After I ask a few times she walks over to the changing table. I don't think we can expect them to obey immediately, even if it seems like they should be able to.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › i have absolutely no idea what im doing re: discipline.