Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Is this CLW
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is this CLW

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
Let me start by saying, it is okay either way - whether this can be considered CLW or not, I am just wondering.

I did not know the term CLW when I started this journey - and never expected to be nursing DD this long.

History:
Nursed DS on demand and sometimes around the clock until he was around 20 months old. At that time, I was in third trimester with DD and wanted to night-wean. I tried using Jay Gordon's method - and it was obvious he was not ready. Waited a while - tried again, he accepted night weaning easily. Of course later, I still night-nursed him on the occasion if he asked.

Then I became a tandem nurser. Often nursing them both at the same time. Sometime much later, I suggested that DS could nap without nursing. Again, this transition happened easisly - although I was the one setting the limits. Sometime later, I suggested he could go to sleep at night without nursing. The two children were just becoming too big to nurse at the same time. (22 months apart)

So, DS has been down to nursing first thing in the morning only for quite a while. If he does ask at other times, I will let him - or talk about it first. We have had a very busy summer with lots of morning activities. Also, dd often wakes first and drinks all the "milk-milk", so even if DS asks, there often isn't much there.

DS has gone long stretches this summer without his morning milk. When he does ask, I am happy and disappointed at the same time. (hope that makes sense) One time when he asked, I pointed out that it had been a long time - and asked if he was sure he wanted milk. There may have been one time I did say no - we were really busy or late or something.

So, with the limits that have been set along the way, not sure if this is really clw? While he has seemed ok with the limits, there were times when his sister was nursing that I sensed he might wish to as well.

Also, my H, has been very against his nursing for quite a while. There has been lots of pressure there. He has even talked to DS without me, and told him "no more". This is a difficult situation, but nursing has continued. Even yesterday - DS's birthday-he was 5! - I heard H first thing in the morning asking him, "now that you are 5, how do you feel about not having milk-milk anymore?"

Not sure if he will ask to nurse again. I might be tempted to suggest it - but again, would that be clw? Or even appropriate?
post #2 of 6
I'm new here so I'm not sure exactly about the definition of child led weaning. But it sounds like your DS has weaned in a gradual and gentle way. IMO it would be rare to nurse till age 5 in our culture and not set some limits. I think you've done a great job meeting his needs.
post #3 of 6
Except for your husband's contribution, it sounds like "don't offer, don't refuse." It's a mother-led weaning technique I found effective with my DS.
post #4 of 6
No, not child-led, but congrats on getting to the 5 year mark!
post #5 of 6
Definately CLW!

You have to set limits along the way. Everyone does it, perhaps not everyone realizes it.

I tell my kids no all the time, but that doesn't mean they have weaned, or that we will wean anytime soon. As infants, my main limits were no nursing while I was in the bathroom. Now, I refuse to nurse while I'm eating. My oldest has even more limitations (we don't nurse in public anymore). All of these are limitations...

Great job getting to 5! We're right behind ya!
post #6 of 6
Thread Starter 
I'm still a bit confused about whether this is truly clw or not...

BUT, thank you SO MUCH for your words of commendation!

We were just on a beach vacation - 5 yr old came down with ear infection - nursing was a godsend! (btw, he has been sick much more than normal this summer - coincidence? or does it have to do with such reduced nursing? hmmm)

During sickness, dh gave son the green-light on nursing (by phone as dh was not with us). DS was relieved I think. Now, he wants morning milk again! Not sure how I feel about. He actually made a comment about me not telling his father that he was all better as he doesn't want dh to tell him no milk.

I am concerned about how confusing this all must be to him. Is it better to have him continue weaning at his own pace? Or better for him to have parents on "same page" as regards? (even though i wouldn't be inside)

On a funny note, we had a weaning discussion this morning. My 3 yr old dd said, "i don't know that word, mommy. what does it mean?" My 5 yr old ds said, "i'll wean when I am 100!"
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Child-Led Weaning
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Is this CLW