Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › New here and giving a midwife a 2nd try? (long sorry)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New here and giving a midwife a 2nd try? (long sorry)

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I am new here. I am Laura and I have one DS who is nine months old and he was a HB. We just got a + sign again and my brain has started whirling thinking about my 2nd birth. My first labor was 33 hours and was awful but I have come to terms with my labor and I can look back and only see the good, I can remember all of it but take only the high parts to heart. So I don't feel like it's the trauma of a harsh labor that is making me doubt my midwife.
She was very invasive, hands on and BOSSY. But I feel like I made the right choice for me my first pregnancy and birth because I really needed the guidance (e.g. Bossiness) even though I didn't get the birth experience I wanted. So now I am wondering if I should find a new midwife or give this very lovely lady a 2nd chance. On a personal level she was a perfect fit she and my mom are like one person. I would love to use her again but with a whole new set of ground rules. I feel like for another birth I need a whole new cast of characters to get the birth experience I want/need to heal from my first labor. My mom, sister, midwife1, midwife2 and DH were at my DS's birth. I could not have made it through without my mom, DH was drowning in the birthtub by about hour 25, I had to stay in the tub to keep my bp down and so I need my mom to help me though the last 7 hours. Now I would like to have a non-invasive, low key just DH and I labor and midwife there to make sure daddy doesn't drop the baby when he catches him/her. We loved midwife2 and would gladly use her but then I worry about offending midwife1. Midwife1 has birthed 3 of my nephews 2 since DS and has used an apprentice who both of my S_I_L's loved and I just found out that she lives 5 blocks from us so I am wanting meet her and in hopes that she can be involved in our birth, DS and I make sure we walk past her house on our walks in case she is in her garden, before I knew who she was we saw her almost every walk!
Anyway after all this babbling my question is do I give midwife1 a second chance? Why I am wondering about this so soon is because I had very low progesterone levels at the beginning of DS's pregnancy so I want to get my hormone levels checked as soon as possible and I debating just making an appointment with the HB friendly OB/GYN to get lab work done, so I can wait to make a midwife decision. THANK YOU!!
post #2 of 5
Congratulations on the pregnancy! About the bossy midwife though, do you think she only got that way because you needed it and could change the way she works with you for your second? If that's just the way she is and it doesn't work for you I'd say go interview the other choices, definitely. If she only was so involved and bossy because it was your first time or you asked for help, maybe she can be different. Still if it's an emotional or mental hurdle having her there and remembering the challenges of last time, fearing repeats, do what you have to to start afresh. I've been there with a long and miserable first labor and a long but nice enough second fraught with nagging fears it was going just like last time.
post #3 of 5
Is she always naturally bossy, or did she become that way during labor? Because I'm naturally very hands off and quiet, but I'm not afraid to roll up my sleeves and do the "take charge" routine when it's needed. That's something my clients hire me for, to use my skills to help them when needed. If she's bossy all the time then you can't expect her to suddenly change for one day, but if she's great all the other days then you should just talk to her.
post #4 of 5
If you have good vibes with mw#2, go with her. There's nothing saying you need to use #1 again, for any reason.
I'm preggo with #3. #1 was a hb with a dr., who no longer does births. #2 was a hb with a mw who is actually the dr.'s RN (lots of experience with delivery babies), and while she was totally competent, her bedside manner and strong perfume were enought to deter me to find another mw for this hb. I haven't been to my dr. yet this whole pregnancy (no reason to- no sick kids, etc.) so it'll be a little wierd bringing my newborn in to see the dr. with her there being the RN, but I'll have to negotiate that when the time comes!
post #5 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by JamieCatheryn View Post
Congratulations on the pregnancy! About the bossy midwife though, do you think she only got that way because you needed it and could change the way she works with you for your second?
Exactly what I was thinking! As a matter of fact, I remember reading one review of a local HB MW here & a mama said that she was exactly what she needed - "mama bear holding my hand during my 1st birth, & very hands-off, giving me space to labor during my 2nd." So it's definitely possible. Actually I would say all good MWs are chameleons in that way & can adapt to the behavior the mama wants & needs.

that being said, if you really like MW#2, I say just go with her! BOTH of those MWs were at your birth, so I can't see why you'd worry about offending #1 if you chose #2 - wouldn't you have to worry about offending #2 if you chose #1? Besides, I should hope that #1 would be mature enough to understand that she's not a perfect fit for every woman. & if, say she were the backup, she should be mature & not hold a 'grudge' that you didn't pick her. I wouldn't really worry about that.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Homebirth
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › New here and giving a midwife a 2nd try? (long sorry)