Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › Nursing 3 yr Old Challenges
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nursing 3 yr Old Challenges

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
My DD just turned 3. She is still nursing, which, in theory, I am fine with.

Actually, I am fine with the fact that she is nursing.

What I am not fine with is how demanding she is. She will often - usually - nurse longer than DD2, who is 7 months old. Even that I can handle.

My problem is, I need to have some sort of control over her nursing. I mean, clearly it is my body. But if I tell her it is time to put nummies away, or if she wants to nurse at a given time and I tell her no, it's a nightmare She screams and cries and throws a huge fit.

I realize some may view this as more of a behavior problem rather than a nursing problem. But, in any case, it's still a problem. And it is different than normal discipline issues, because it is about her nummies, which she still needs so desperately.

Right now, my main tactic is that I tell her I will count to five, then put nummies away. At five, she says one more, so I tell her I will count to three. At three, we put the nummies away.

Most of the time this works. Sometimes, it doesn't.

Also, when she wants to nurse and I won't let her, due to being unable to, she will sometimes throw a fit that she carries on for over an hour. If I make her wait until I finish what I'm doing, she'll tantrum until I'm done, at which point I giver her the nummies, which is why she stops.

Other times, if I can't just finish up and give them to her (like I'm leaving for work or something), she will sometimes tantrum for over an hour.

When I do tell her she can't have her nummies right now for whatever reason, I do try distraction - I suggest we sing a song together, I offer to rub her back, I offer to read her a book, whatever. Occassionally this works, usually it doesn't.

Help! I feel horrible that she is so hurt by not getting her nummies - like, I don't want this do damage our relationship - but, I also know that she is old enough to have limits and I need to stand my ground on setting limits.

I am looking for helpful suggestions and stories from experience, along with perhaps some support of those who have BTDT and know what nursing a three-year-old can be like (which I have done before with DS, but he was much less demanding and more easy-going about things).

Please no criticism of how I have handled things to date. Just helpful ways to try to change as we move forward and do things a bit better.
post #2 of 4
bumping, as i have the same issues with my 2.5 yr old.
post #3 of 4
She sounds very persistent! Really, that's a good trait, that will seem more positive as she gets older & it's not about YOUR body.

Does she have the same tantrums over other limits? Or is it only with nursing? It might help to think about other situations when she has trouble letting go of an idea & what works at those times.

With my persistent son, it's helped to talk about it when we're both calm (so not right after a tantrum). Saying something like, "Sometimes Mommy can't nurse you right away when you ask. When that happens, you get really upset. That makes me sad, and it also makes be a little mad, because I need to do other things as well. Do you have any ideas about making it easier when you have to wait?" She might surprise you. . . If she doesn't have ideas, then giving her some (reading a book, watching a video if that's an option in your house, drawing a picture, having a cup of water or juice, eating a banana. . .). The two of you could choose two or three that are okay with both of you, then you could remind her of that the next time she asks. "I can nurse you in 30 minutes, after I get dinner started. Would you like to color or eat a banana while you wait?" It's also helped us to role-play the situation when we're both calm, so he can practice when he's not emotional.

I'd be careful to voice that you're not "giving in" but simply reaching the point when you can nurse. Repeating a few times while you finish whatever you're involved in, "I know you're really sad about waiting to nurse. I'll be done in XXX minutes and then you can get milk. . . Whew, I'm finally done! Now we can sit down and cuddle. I know it was so hard for you to wait for me to finish." Not acting like you're rushing to be done to appease her, but just acknowledging her unhappiness & the reality that she has to wait.

I also wonder if it may be a way of getting Mommy's attention. It sounds like it happens a lot when you're busy doing something else. Is it possible that nursing is the only time she feels like she has you all to herself? Maybe concentrate on giving her "mommy" time in other ways? Or setting a time each day when she knows she'll have your undivided attention?

I've found the book "Raising your Spirited Child" to be helpful with these types of tantrums, as well.

FWIW, my son is now close to 9 and we STILL have persistence-related tantrums. Not over nursing but they still happen. It's good practice for the future!
post #4 of 4
DS is 3 and we nurse on a schedule, not on demand. It took AWHILE to get to this point, but it works well- DS knows when EXACTLY he can expect to nurse, and I typically don't limit how long he can nurse for. At this age, part of the problem can be contributed to the guessing game- kids don't know if we are going to say yes or no, so tensions automatically run high. If you start a schedule, the expectations are clear.

For us, DS is allowed to nurse when he wakes up in the morning, at naptime, and again at bedtime. He is not allowed to nurse any other time. Was he okay with this overnight? Nope! It took awhile for him to accept the schedule, but now that he does, we have a lot less whining about nursing.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › Nursing 3 yr Old Challenges