Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › WWYD? Ds calling us stupid
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

WWYD? Ds calling us stupid

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
Hi there,

Ds is 3.5yrs old and has discovered that the word stupid is not a nice word and therefore loves to use it. Sometimes he just blurts out "mommy you're stupid" but most of the time he is angry and will then call me or dh stupid. I respond by ignoring him and/or explaining that that is rude and it hurts my feelings. I think it is best to not give too much attention to his name calling and using it as an opportunity to explain appropriate behaviour. When he is mad I tell him to tell me how he feels but to not call me names. Dh on the otherhand thinks that ds is getting away with being rude and that this is unacceptable. He says that he would never dream of calling his dad stupid when he was growing up. He says that he had way more respect for his parents than ds has for us. Am I going about this the wrong way?? How can I explain to dh that getting angry and the idea of spanking is not the answer??
post #2 of 11
Two suggestions:

The first is to give him appropriate words to say when he's mad. So, it's not OK to say "you're stupid!" what can he say? "I'm really mad! I don't like that!" or whatever you come up with.

The second is an idea from Playful Parenting: Tell him "I guess you can say 'stupid', but don't you dare call me 'flibbertigibbit' (or snickelfritz or whatever silly word you want)." He will, of course, say that word. Then you can overreact in mock horror. He'll do it again, you'll do it again, and you'll both think it's hysterical. That gets him attention for saying words, but it isn't negative attention, and they aren't words that you mind. This worked beautifully when my dd was calling me 'boobies'. (It was a word she'd heard, but didn't understand. We never used that word.)
post #3 of 11
I second Lynn's idea. When my son was your sons age we got together with one of his friends of the same age and a younger brother. His friend and also learned "stupid" from somewhere. And they started to call me that. I was kind of horrified but I had also just finished playful parenting and I gave it a shot. I said something like well, You can call me that, but don't ever call me quackie duckie. It was the first thing that popped into my mind. And even as I was saying it; I thought this will never work. But it did. And they immediately started calling me that. I would then play it up saying no, not that, etc. etc. Anyway, that was it. Now my son and his friend are seven and when I go there his son still greets me with quackie duckie. I highly recommend reading the book Playful Parenting if you haven't - we found it worked really well at that age and even older ages. Though, I must admit, it does take some work sometime. But it is not negative and makes things fun.

Quote:
Originally Posted by LynnS6 View Post
Two suggestions:



The second is an idea from Playful Parenting: Tell him "I guess you can say 'stupid', but don't you dare call me 'flibbertigibbit' (or snickelfritz or whatever silly word you want)." He will, of course, say that word. Then you can overreact in mock horror. He'll do it again, you'll do it again, and you'll both think it's hysterical. That gets him attention for saying words, but it isn't negative attention, and they aren't words that you mind.
post #4 of 11
hee heee hee, I love that idea! Now I`ve just got to come up with a good word to use, as dd is going through a similar phase.

as to the "respect" idea - might it help to remind your dh that he is not likely remembering himself at 3.5, but rather as an older kid with a better understanding of respect and respectful behavior than a 3 year old can manage?
post #5 of 11
I am so going to read Playful Parenting, I love that tip. My dd calls us stupid too (she just turned 3) and I have been telling her to say "silly" or something like that instead. She's replaced it a couple times, when she thinks of it but when she's mad she still says stupid. Which happens a lot, many times a day.
post #6 of 11
having BTDT, i wish that i had never made a big deal out of ds calling us stupid. once he knew we didn't like it he used it like crazy. at 3.5 they don't always have the ability to express themselves so my suggestion would be that if your ds says "stupid mommy" then i would just say something like "you're mad at me because of i did so-and-so" and then leave it at that
post #7 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cujobunny View Post
I am so going to read Playful Parenting
It's worth it! It's one of my all time favorite parenting books. I just love the emphasis on connection, and the ideas he has for defusing lots of situations.

Just last night after stories, I said "OK, time to get into bed". Ds (9, and old enough to know 'better') said "no" because he was too 'tired'. So, I began to count backward. The game is that they have to try to be in bed before I hit zero. I'm just amazed that it works every.single.time. That sort of thinking can really defuse a situation. I just wish I had the energy to remember these things all the time.
post #8 of 11
Playful was definitely the way to go for us. DH is better at thinking playfully on the fly, and he went the silly words route. Big hit. My standard response became, "No silly, I'm not stupid, I'm your mama. Remember? My name is Mama!" That was got a lot of laughs, too.
post #9 of 11
Thread Starter 
Thank you for the great replies. I tried the whole playful thing but ds kept calling me stupid so I would make up another funny word. I know dh made way too big a deal about the actual word "stupid" which has only made things worse. I have been trying to calmly but firmly say "we don't use the word stupid, but you could use x y, or z instead" Sometimes it works, sometimes he is tired and looking for a struggle and will still use it. I am way more calm about it than dh. I think ds picks up on dh intensity and therefore uses the word more. I have been reading Kids, parents, and power struggles and have got many good ideas. I guess it is a work in progress. I am sad to say the whole playful thing didn't pan out, but wish me luck that gently I can direct my son in the right direction
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by kdescalzi View Post
Thank you for the great replies. I tried the whole playful thing but ds kept calling me stupid so I would make up another funny word. I know dh made way too big a deal about the actual word "stupid" which has only made things worse. I have been trying to calmly but firmly say "we don't use the word stupid, but you could use x y, or z instead" Sometimes it works, sometimes he is tired and looking for a struggle and will still use it. I am way more calm about it than dh. I think ds picks up on dh intensity and therefore uses the word more. I have been reading Kids, parents, and power struggles and have got many good ideas. I guess it is a work in progress. I am sad to say the whole playful thing didn't pan out, but wish me luck that gently I can direct my son in the right direction
I'm also a big fan of Playful Parenting.. another thing you could try is when he calls you stupid just act REALLY REALLY STUPID, like start saying "DUUURRR" a lot and forget really easy stuff, like his name, and how to use a telephone. The whole point is to take the power out of the word. The sillier you are the better. I really highly recommend actually getting the book from the library and reading the first few chapters (that's all I had time for)- it's not just the techniques, it's also the whole idea behind the techniques.
post #11 of 11
Thread Starter 
I just picked up playful parenting from the library. I am taking all your great advice and I will be reading it...wish me luck
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › WWYD? Ds calling us stupid