Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Just wanted to share this somewhere as it's on my mind.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Just wanted to share this somewhere as it's on my mind.

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
My sister had a baby boy last week, her first. When I was visiting her in the hospital, she said something about his circumcision (which had not happened yet.) My heart sunk. I thought talking to my sister would not be very productive, because I assumed that it was my BIL who was wanting the circ and she was just going along. So I walked with BIL in the hallway and shared some things with him that I thought he might not know. I was humble about it, and assured him that I would say nothing else after this and would respect whatever decision they made. I was surprised to learn from him that it was my sister who wanted the circ, and he was more against it! (That's what he said, anyway. He also said they'd had "some back and forth about it".) I still think it was the right thing to talk to him about it instead of her -- even more so now. I hope the information I gave him was enough ammunition for him to re-open the conversation with her. I encouraged him to think about it some more and if he decided he didn't want it done, to not be afraid to stand up for his son.

They are home from the hospital now. I have no idea if my nephew was circed or not at this point. I know the medical staff were concerned about his initial lack of urination after 30 hours, which put off the procedure. I'm hoping that all the concern and fuss over the pee issue -- they even catheterized him briefly to see if there was a blockage -- gave my BIL even more incentive to argue against further messing with his poor son's penis. (He's peeing fine now and has regained his birth weight, so no worries there anymore!)

Anyway, I don't know if I made any difference or not, but I keep thinking about it. Maybe sharing it here can help me to let it go. It's either done or it isn't and either way I'm not going to say anything. If my BIL decided to stand up against the circumcision, he may not have told my sister that I had talked to him about it, so I'll handle my joy or disappointment in private in either case. Thanks for listening.
post #2 of 12
fingers crossed.
post #3 of 12
Great you started opening up. The more you talk about it, the better.

No need to be shy. What have got to lose?
post #4 of 12
Thread Starter 

Update!

Saw my little nephew today long enough to witness a diaper change. He is intact!

Apparently the peeing issue was the most influential factor, but that's totally fine with me! The doctor would not circumcise until the urination issue was cleared up, and by the time the baby was urinating regularly, the doctor had gone home. My sister said "We were on the fence about it anyway, so we just said forget it." (Some other family member asked about it, so that's how I got to hear about the factors in their decision.) Yay!
post #5 of 12
That's great to hear.
post #6 of 12
Wow a peeing issue saves the day, I guess another lucky boy.
post #7 of 12
Wonderful news. If you think it's appropriate at some point, you can reinforce their smart choice by mentioning it has the weight of a majority of families today behind it. Everyone likes to know their child is normal and popular.

I hope they've already heard the basics about retraction, though they can read it here anytime. It will help ensure a trouble-free experience.
post #8 of 12
Happy that is the way things worked out.

When I had my son they were concerned about his output too but we haven't had any issues since almost four years later.
post #9 of 12
The peeing problem, what a blessing in disguise!!! Good for you in taking that small initiative -- that might have made all the difference.
post #10 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by T-man's Mama View Post
The peeing problem, what a blessing in disguise!!! Good for you in taking that small initgiative -- that might have madne all the difference.
its a sad realization for me to actually consider wanting every boy to be born with ["can't do the surgery b/c of an anomaly"] 'a blessing disguise'.

All along I thought being born healthy is a blessing in and of itself.


So... as long as its a healthy penis, a dr. will want to "fix" it?

luv my 2 sweeties, I am so very happy for you! Congratulations on your newest member of the family.

Good for you for speaking up!
post #11 of 12
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by fruitful womb View Post
So... as long as its a healthy penis, a dr. will want to "fix" it?
Actually, I found myself wondering if this doctor was perhaps not all that keen on circumcision to begin with. Interesting that she kept putting it off (with reason, to be sure) then made herself scarce without talking to the parents about when the circ could be done later or whether some other doctor could do it before they went home. I could be way off base, but it made me go "hmmm..."

Thanks for the congratulations! He's totally cute, and my sister is such a calm and competent first time mom. She's nursing great, and just needs some reassurance that the fact that he's nursing pretty much non-stop doesn't mean he isn't getting enough to eat. (My other sister and I, who both breastfed children, offered our hearty assurances that this was normal, and our mom pointed out that he seldom cries, so he can't be painfully hungry.) I think the urination thing just has her a little spooked, even though he wet through three outfits today! She just needs to get her confidence up and I'm sure she will. She's still in contact with the lactation consultant from the hospital, who is encouraging her as well, so I'm confident.

I'm rambling way off topic now, but I have to give kudos to her hospital. The seemed to really be supportive of her breastfeeding and did everything possible to avoid supplementing as a solution to the pee thing. They gave her a breast pump to take home too, which she's been using it and it's working for her. Nice to see a hospital doing the right thing!
post #12 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by luv my 2 sweeties View Post
Actually, I found myself wondering if this doctor was perhaps not all that keen on circumcision to begin with. Interesting that she kept putting it off (with reason, to be sure) then made herself scarce without talking to the parents about when the circ could be done later or whether some other doctor could do it before they went home. I could be way off base, but it made me go "hmmm..."
Yay!

You know, this is how my DS' pedi was and I am soooo thankful for it. I was on the fence too, but after a difficult delivery, prolonged separation and recovering from a c/s, I was going to circ (against my better judgment and despite a niggling feeling that it was so wrong). Well, DS was born with some glucose issues (which apparently are super common in bigger babies), but his pedi kept putting it off in the hospital, saying "well he's been through enough. We'll talk about that later." Then, he didn't bring it up until DS was 1 month old. By that time, I was a raging intactivist and was SO thankful that we hadn't gotten to circ. Thank goodness for doctors like that (even though I wish they just wouldn't do circs at all!)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Just wanted to share this somewhere as it's on my mind.