Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › Car advice needed please
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Car advice needed please

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
Hoping some of you might be able to help me make a decision.

We have a 2003 Honda CRV with 112,000 miles and we owe $7500 on it. Our payment is $346/month.

We initially had a lease on it, but then in 2006 decided to buy out the lease for $10,000. This seemed like a great idea b/c I had a $10,000 check coming from an insurance claim (non related to this car) and we planned to pay the car off with that. Also, it was under warranty until 100,000 miles. BUT...then we moved that summer and put the money into buying our first house instead. So we've been making payments (primarily to interest) for four years. We are finally paying the principal now, but have two years of payments left, AND are no longer under warranty.

This is our only car. Our plan was to pay off the CRV and then lease a civic when we had extra $ in our monthly budget. It seemed like such a great plan at the time b/c we'd have a dependable vehicle that we owned and could decide whether or not we really needed the second car.

I'd love to stick with that plan, but at this point, we have a car that is no longer under warranty and that freaks me out. It seems that the CRV is worth at least as much as we owe on it, and we're considering trading it in on a newer CRV or a lease, but that just makes me feel like we've wasted sooo much money. We're really having trouble deciding what to do. My research shows that CRVs frequently last for around 200,000 miles, but there's obviously no guarantee for that, and I think eventually we may be upside down on the loan, right?

I've always had a new car and worry about even taking this one on long trips b/c it's not new. That may be unnecessary worry, but that's why I'm looking for some advice. I should note that DH drives about 25 miles to work each way each day (9 mos/yr). And we live within walking distance of all things necessary for me and DS during the day, so having a second car is not a necessity.

Thanks!
post #2 of 4
JMHO you sound paranoid! I have never owned a new car, I have never owned a car newer than 10 years old actually, and have no problems driving places, taking trips etc. If you leased it and then purchased it then you are the only owners...you know the history, I assume you maintain it...i don't see the problem or why you need something "new" just for the "new title. Maybe I am confused.

Also I dont think there is any way you would be able to sell it for what you owe...I haven't looked at the KBB but off the top of my head if I was looking on CL i would expect an 03 CRV to go for about 4500-5500.

I think leases are a waste, personally. I would prob trade it on a newer CRV if you are really that freaked about a warranty (ive never had one) but expect that your payment is going to go up significantly. I dont ever want a car payment...so IDK i am probably not the best judge here.

I buy a car that I can pay 2k or less for and drive at least 5 years...

HTH!
post #3 of 4
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the response. No, I'm not at all concerned with the "new title." I've simply never had a car that was not under warranty that I owed money on, so I'm having trouble coming to terms with the fact that something major could go wrontg, and we could ultimately not afford to repair our only car, yet we would still owe money on it.

I did check the KBB and it looks like we could sell or trade for what we owe without too much problem.

I don't want a car payment either, but I have one either way at this point, so just trying to determine whether it's best to pay off this car or to start with a newer one and have a warranty while paying on it.

Thanks!
post #4 of 4
have you looked on craigslist to see what similar models are selling for though? Just because KBB says it is "worth" 8k, doesn't mean that is what the market will bear.

What would you expect to go wrong that you couldn't afford to repair? What did your warranty cover? Is there any way to purchase an extended warranty? At 113k miles, I wouldn't really be expecting motor or tranny work...but you should google to see if it is a common occurance.

If you are dead set on trading I would see about a certified used model that is a couple yrs old that comes with a warranty. Then maybe your pmts would be about the same.

I just can't see putting that much money into a car...but to some people it is worth it. If you really are that freaked out about not having a warranty and cannot extend your expired warranty then I would def look into selling/trading
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Frugality & Finances
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › Car advice needed please