Do I do something about this- "good family with a little child abuse" - Page 2

[AndrewsMother]

Tell your clergyman. Vermont law requires members of clergy to report suspected abuse.

http://dcf.vermont.gov/fsd/reporting...abuse/mandated

[ErinYay]

Normally I err on the side of keeping one's nose firmly on her side of the fence, but I read thistoday (disturbing and upsetting- 2 young girls removed from a Georgia home) and man, if only someone had called sooner.

[Funny Face]

I would call clergy/pastor at your church and tell them.

I would also make your mother see that this woman 'may not know better' but that someone has to show her HOW to do better and if the one's witnessing the abuse won't then a third party (CPS) should be informed. Make her understand that they are a resource for education and betterment for this mother.

That's a really sad and disturbing thing to hear about. The fact that she doesn't act like this in public is telling as well.

[sapphire_chan]

If the woman acts like this because of being raised like this, then WHAT THE WILL HAPPEN WITH THE KIDS?!??!?!?

Tell your mom that the kids deserve to have their mom given a chance to learn a better way. For the sake of themselves AND their children.

Oh, and it's not "a good family with a little child abuse" it's an abusive family that puts on a good front.

[LynnS6]

Are you in a position to go with your mom to try to help this family? It sounds like this mother is completely overwhelmed. If it's true that her children are living in the conditions that you described and the mom is exhibiting the behavior that you described (2nd hand), then they need help.

If you go over there yourself, you can offer some concrete help for this woman. If things are really bad in the house, then you can make the decision about calling CPS yourself.

I would also alert the pastor. Not only are they mandated reporters, but there may be congregational resources to help this family -- counseling, physical help to clean up the house, people to volunteer to babysit.

[lilyka]

is it possible your mom exaggerated a bit? That would explain why she is upset about you pushing her. Sometimes people do that. If you did not see what happened I certainly would not call. Your mom may have stretched the truth a bit for drama and now does not want to admit to it.

[pianojazzgirl]

Originally Posted by lilyka

is it possible your mom exaggerated a bit? That would explain why she is upset about you pushing her. Sometimes people do that. If you did not see what happened I certainly would not call. Your mom may have stretched the truth a bit for drama and now does not want to admit to it.

This is exactly what I thought when I read the OP.

Because it was your mom who witnessed whatever happened ultimately it has to be her who calls or doesn't call. I'd certainly encourage her to call (since of course things could have happened exactly as she described), but I don't think you can/should do much more than that. And depending on your relationship with your mom you could question her on it... "is the real reason that you don't want me to call because you exaggerated what happened? Can you tell me what really happened?" or whatever...

Good luck mama. I think the situation deserves a bit more probing. Keep us updated.

[tallulahma]

Originally Posted by lonegirl

no. If I haven't personally witnessed anything I would never risk separating a family over what someone elses says has happened.

:

Originally Posted by bluebirdmama1

Thanks all for the responces. I know I didn't wittness anything, but I couldn't get the thought of the little girl being bashed between a door frame. I really wish I could get my mother to call, but when I pressed about her calling, she got all mad and said she shouldn't have ever said anything to me.

I don't like the thought of interfereing with someones life, but I know the family with the mom I am talking about here is pretty much a wreck. They supposidly have pooh and pee all over the house, and no beds to sleep on since the rooms are filled floor to ceiling with trash, seriously, that bad. I trust my mother about that description- she was the one who told me about it. The family even has a goat living in the house and "goes" all over the place.

When I did ask my mother about calling and getting this woman help, she said that she cannot help her behavior since she was raised the way she is treating her children and lifestyle.

I have really got to get my mother to take some action herself. In the morning I will talk to her.

okay- THIS??? supposedly? this kind of stuff sounds like either gossip or a situation that requires someone to step in.

Originally Posted by lilyka

is it possible your mom exaggerated a bit? That would explain why she is upset about you pushing her. Sometimes people do that. If you did not see what happened I certainly would not call. Your mom may have stretched the truth a bit for drama and now does not want to admit to it.

my mother does this. she exaggerates and then refuses to elaborate if you catch on and try to coax more info out of her.

she has told my family back home that we were so poor we couldnt afford beds, formula or diapers (because we chose to cosleep, breastfeed and used cloth diapers), she said that I had become a crazy religious fanatic (because we homeschool and do not celebrate mainstream halloween & christmas due to being PAGAN and not wanting junk gross candy).

they came and visited for a week, and then went home and told everyone we starved them... because we didnt have any doritos, ice cream or coffee cake or soda.

so I would try to meet the woman everyone is talking about and scope out the situation yourself.

believing gossip is dangerous.

[Fuamami]

Well, it kind of sounds like they have a squalor/neglect situation, and if CPS has actually been called before and has been to the home, it may be that there's a case open and they're working with them.

Most CPS workers would pick up on feces in the home and get the family involved with services in some way.

[fyrwmn]

i would contact the pastor of your mother's church and let him know what your mother has told you. i would assume that he must have some knowledge of this family. if in fact things are this bad...mom slamming a child's head repeatedly in a door, etc...then a call needs to be made. i wouldn't recommend that it be by you unless you personally witness this behavior though. i wouldn't just let it go though. children, even a 10yr old, aren't able most of the time to seek out the help they might need in this sort of situation. it is our job as adults, to see that children are safe.

[bebebradford]

So here's an honest question to the posters that are saying to " mind your own business" if it's hearsay. What IF you heard from someone else about serious abuse going on in a family, and later a child died/was injured/etc? I think when it comes to protecting children it's better to be safe than sorry. If I hear of something serious I'm reporting it, even if I didn't see it. Yes, it IS a pain in the butt if it's a false story, but if there is a chance it could save a child from abuse it's worth it. Cps will investigate, and decide what to do. It really baffles me that so many people turn their eyes away from abusive situations like this. Innocent children come first!!!

[corysmilk]

Originally Posted by bebebradford

So here's an honest question to the posters that are saying to " mind your own business" if it's hearsay. What IF you heard from someone else about serious abuse going on in a family, and later a child died/was injured/etc? I think when it comes to protecting children it's better to be safe than sorry. If I hear of something serious I'm reporting it, even if I didn't see it. Yes, it IS a pain in the butt if it's a false story, but if there is a chance it could save a child from abuse it's worth it. Cps will investigate, and decide what to do. It really baffles me that so many people turn their eyes away from abusive situations like this. Innocent children come first!!!

I totally agree

[AndrewsMother]

Originally Posted by bebebradford

So here's an honest question to the posters that are saying to " mind your own business" if it's hearsay. What IF you heard from someone else about serious abuse going on in a family, and later a child died/was injured/etc? I think when it comes to protecting children it's better to be safe than sorry. If I hear of something serious I'm reporting it, even if I didn't see it. Yes, it IS a pain in the butt if it's a false story, but if there is a chance it could save a child from abuse it's worth it. Cps will investigate, and decide what to do. It really baffles me that so many people turn their eyes away from abusive situations like this. Innocent children come first!!!

I agree.

[zinemama]

Originally Posted by bebebradford

So here's an honest question to the posters that are saying to " mind your own business" if it's hearsay. What IF you heard from someone else about serious abuse going on in a family, and later a child died/was injured/etc? I think when it comes to protecting children it's better to be safe than sorry. If I hear of something serious I'm reporting it, even if I didn't see it. Yes, it IS a pain in the butt if it's a false story, but if there is a chance it could save a child from abuse it's worth it. Cps will investigate, and decide what to do. It really baffles me that so many people turn their eyes away from abusive situations like this. Innocent children come first!!!

I might agree with you if this was hearsay from a reliable source, someone I knew was trustworthy. However, the OP has stated that her source in this case "is not always aware of things mentally." And, since that source is her own mother, she has reason to know that this is the case.

That's why I advised her to go to the pastor (a mandated reporter) and lay the story before him or her. The pastor is probably in a position to make a more objective assessment of one of his congregants than a mentally unstable woman who may be making things up for the sake of drama (or some other reason.) I have read many descriptions of people investigated by CPS because of false or malicious reports. Those experiences sounded like a lot more than "pain in the butts." That's why I would be reluctant to make the call based on hearsay from this particular woman, knowing absolutely nothing personally about the family.

[tallulahma]

Originally Posted by bebebradford

So here's an honest question to the posters that are saying to " mind your own business" if it's hearsay. What IF you heard from someone else about serious abuse going on in a family, and later a child died/was injured/etc? I think when it comes to protecting children it's better to be safe than sorry. If I hear of something serious I'm reporting it, even if I didn't see it. Yes, it IS a pain in the butt if it's a false story, but if there is a chance it could save a child from abuse it's worth it. Cps will investigate, and decide what to do. It really baffles me that so many people turn their eyes away from abusive situations like this. Innocent children come first!!!

What i dont understand is that if there is so much concern, why not go and knock on this mama's door?

say, "listen, things are being said... I want you to know, I am here to help. If you need a babysitter, someone to help around the house, etc etc"

or see if people in your church community could get together to help her- if she was willing.


It is very possible that this woman could be depressed, isolated, alone and overwhelmed.

First- if social services has been called and found nothing- then she either cleaned up before they got there or there isnt feces and urine everywhere and a goat living in the house.

Second- if she is abusive to the kids, it is absolutely grounds for calling cps...but what I think I was saying is make sure you really trust your mother. If someone called cps on me because of what MY mother had told them, they would be wasting tax dollars. My children are very well cared for.

see it with your own eyes, try to actually help her, or make sure your mom is not exaggerating.

if she is over her head- she needs help , and there are better ways to help than to just make a phone call so you can feel like you DID something without doing anything. like i said, social services have been there before according to the OP.

its sad to me, that in a community, a church community even- people would rather gossip and call cps than attempt to help.

[meemee]

Originally Posted by bebebradford

Cps will investigate, and decide what to do.

i disagree that in her case CPS is the best way to go. the OP has already said CPS has investigated quite a few times.

i have had CPS called on me. if your child says no i am not scared of my mama, no she takes good care of me, they are not going to further investigate it, esp. if the child does not have bruises.

if she is still continuing then obviously CPS has not helped a great deal.

that is why many of us are saying get the community involved. find out what the mom needs. see what is truly up.

CPS is the absolute last resort. and really CPS is not the answer to everything.

even if one did call CPS, i still think the community needs to be more involved. even if hte mom exaggerates and things are not quite as bad.

[lilyka]

I agree. I would never report someone without knowing for sure what was going on. I know someone who was falsely accused. Even though the charges were dropped things will never go back to normal.

If you are going to report someone on rumors at least have the decency to knock on their door and say "hey this is what people are saying." And offer to help rather than just tattle.

The whole feces and urine and goat thing.....That hardly sounds logical but if they do have a goat living in there perhaps they are house breaking it or something (is that even possible.) When I was house breaking my dog there was often pee spots and occasionally poo I didn't see right away. She is a sneaky little beastie. ON the other hand I have been in a house where the dog was allowed to poop on the floor and we walked into a room with at least 10 piles. sickest thing ever. And there is no way to sufficiently clean that. SO before I reported anything though I would have to see it for myself.

[LROM]

2 ideas that have already been stated that I'd like to repeat:

1. Call CPS, maybe call Prevent Child Abuse org in your state, and maybe also look in your phone book for any other child abuse orgs. Tell them all the general situation and explain that you'd like your mom to report since she saw the head being hit with the door and door frame, but your mom has her own history of abuse and won't do it. Ask for advice. You don't have to give ANY identifying information, but someone in one of these places should be able to give you advice about either how to work with your mom on getting an accurate story to CPS or how you can do it yourself.

2. Talk to the Pastor/head Clergyperson of the church. If you're in VT and it's true that VT law says abuse has to be reported, then talk to the head person about this and your concern.

I do also believe in the approach of going to the house yourself and telling the mom you wanted to reach out and see if there's any way you could be helpful to her family, maybe watch the kids once in awhile, or bring food over. But if it's done to gather info with the main purpose of reporting her, that of course feels unfair, as serious as the situation is.

It is absolutely possible for a mother to absolutely adore and love her children, to try her best to be a good mom and strong disciplinarian, AND to cross the line over into clear child abuse. The fact that a mom loves her kids and is trying her best simply does not explain away or excuse actual child abuse, and if she really is slamming her kids heads in doors or there's feces laying around the house, those are serious and she needs help. Some way or another, she and her kids need help.

I admire and respect you for being this concerned, and hope you're able to set some action into play that gets her attention and help if these allegations are really true.

[Koalamom]

Update!

Thanks everyone for your support. This has been on my mind alot. I looked into things, and aparently after repeted calls, the state as 2 weeks ago, is coming into her home, givig her child raising help/advice, and she is even getting help with cleaning and some counseling. I am not sure of all the specifics, but atleast something is happening.

[LROM]

Very glad you called. Just curious - how did you find out what is going on in her house with the assistance she's getting? And were there any reports on how she seems to be responding, like does she seem to feel like it's helpful or is she really upset or what?

Really I'm mostly just glad you called, but I am curious how it's going and if the Mom is feeling like she understands the concerns, which I know is something you may have no idea about.