Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Personal Growth & Spirituality  › Spirituality › Faith and Politics... I'm frustrated...
New Posts  All Forums:
 

Faith and Politics... I'm frustrated... - Page 2

post #21 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bluegoat View Post
I don't think leftist is really used correctly in this context though. That is why equating views on social issues wil often lead one in the wrong direction. But it is really a problem with the idea of right and left - it is too simple. After all, libertarians tend to favour economic deregulation, and oppose social programs, which in the US is identified with the right.
Yes, that's true, I thought later "leftist" wasn't the best term. Maybe "socially liberal" is more accurate, meaning, most of the Libertarians I know are pro-choice, pro-gay marriage, against religion in the public square, etc. Although, as you pointed out, they're against most forms of social programs.

Usually, the liberal leaning Libertarians I know will just call themselves Libertarian, while the conservative ones will specify conservative Libertarian.
post #22 of 27
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Arduinna View Post
I must be dense, because I have no idea what the OP is trying to imply. But I'd be suspicious of any priest that doesn't stand up for the morality that the Church teaches, if personal beliefs don't affect your decisions and actions in the world it's pretty hollow.
I'll try to explain without going outside of the scope of the forum rules. It isn't the issue of morality at question here. Of course one will be affected by their religious and spiritual convictions on moral issues, and should talk about those convictions. What I am questioning is accusing persons (especially politicians) or other groups of folks of things that aren't moral issues, but portraying them as if they were this were absolute truth and because they did or are ___ they are bad, unAmerican, out to get us, etc... When nothing of the sort can be proven and even if they were ___ or did ___ it would mean none of those things. So, basically fear mongering and a perpetuation of bad political propaganda that has no basis in factual evidence or at the very best construed.
I'm ok with discussing issues that one would vote on using moral arguments, facts, and scripture to show how ones faith convicts them to vote one way or another... even if I were to ultimately disagree, I feel those discussions/sermons are important. I don't put a label on my politics even one as broad as conservative or liberal. I am me and I vote for whoever I feel is mostly in line with what I feel is in the nation's best interest regardless of political party affiliation.
What I am not condoning, or at least am conflicted about is name calling (as in derogatory) or using whole groups of people and turning their identity into the equivalent of something bad. Or, calling someone else and referring to someone as these terms to infer that they are somehow evil or bad, or trying to trick us into some kind of new world order or such as that. At this point, to me that is going too far, especially when it slaps in the face statements from those people themselves, and actions (their "do") which shows us otherwise. Should we not pray for those who we feel are "lost" spiritually... whatever our religious faith? Judging or condemnation without love or those words as a disguise for hate (the way I am feeling at this point) is immoral. And with a confidence in God's love for us be reassured that as we walk the path we are led to walk it will end in the way that God has planned in our best interest if we are remaining faithful. In that hope we can show love and compassion to even those we might perceive as our enemies in hope that they too find spiritual peace and relationship with God/Creator/Universe.
An example would be the Buddha coming first to those asthetic monks with whom he spent time... those who had mocked his change of heart... first with his message of enlightenment. They becoming his first disciples.
Another is Jesus asking the Father to forgive them for they know not what they do. Even when He cleared the temple of the moneychangers if one had come to Him asking for His teaching He would not have witheld it, and spoke civally with those who asked questions of Him.
Peace... begats peace in my opinion. And my heart is heavy with all the name calling and accusations instead of beneficial discussion and openess. But, I suppose that might only be dreaming... in the world of polictics.
post #23 of 27
I think personal morality is one thing.

But I have definitely seen people of faith make an unreasonable attachment between their beliefs and a particular political party or political belief. They are not just Christians who in daily life believe such and such a thing about politics. They cannot separate politics from their faith, and question the faith of others who do not agree with them politically. And I am not pointing the finger at any one group. I see it all across the spectrum.
post #24 of 27
Thanks for clarifying. I'm sure I can't reply to that here and stay within the UA so I won't even try.
post #25 of 27
As a Christian and a non-American, I am constantly amazed and baffled by the extent to which religion and politics are mixed together in the U.S. I think it is a uniquely American phenomenon. There is some religion/politics overlap here, and probably everywhere, but it seems to be such a huge issue in the States, and I am not sure why.

I sometimes put on a Christian radio station from the U.S., just out of curiosity. I seldom hear them talking about anything specifically religious; they only talk about politics: what political party a Christian should vote for, which pending bills a Christian should support, how a Christian should stand on gun control, etc. There is usually not a clear connection between doctrine and political position, at least it is not clear to me. Why does "Christian" imply any particular position on school taxes, military spending, or health care reform? It seems like some alliance made years ago and zealously maintained out of habit.
post #26 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamabadger View Post
As a Christian and a non-American, I am constantly amazed and baffled by the extent to which religion and politics are mixed together in the U.S. I think it is a uniquely American phenomenon. There is some religion/politics overlap here, and probably everywhere, but it seems to be such a huge issue in the States, and I am not sure why.

I sometimes put on a Christian radio station from the U.S., just out of curiosity. I seldom hear them talking about anything specifically religious; they only talk about politics: what political party a Christian should vote for, which pending bills a Christian should support, how a Christian should stand on gun control, etc. There is usually not a clear connection between doctrine and political position, at least it is not clear to me. Why does "Christian" imply any particular position on school taxes, military spending, or health care reform? It seems like some alliance made years ago and zealously maintained out of habit.
I have noticed this too, it is a very American phenomena. Here you would find members of all religions in all the main parties.
post #27 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamabadger View Post
I sometimes put on a Christian radio station from the U.S., just out of curiosity. I seldom hear them talking about anything specifically religious; they only talk about politics: what political party a Christian should vote for, which pending bills a Christian should support, how a Christian should stand on gun control, etc. There is usually not a clear connection between doctrine and political position, at least it is not clear to me. Why does "Christian" imply any particular position on school taxes, military spending, or health care reform? It seems like some alliance made years ago and zealously maintained out of habit.
I can shed some light on this. There is a special use of the word "Christian" within the United States. This special use has the additional connotations of "born again," "saved", and/or "accepted Jesus Christ as your personal savior." None of which are bad... but they are foreign concepts to Catholicism and some other Christian traditions.

Growing up Catholic, I had some people outright try to tell me that Catholics aren't Christian, based on this special use of the word.

The special use also frequently implies following a Calvinist Protestant tradition. Here's a Time article that helped me identify this insight:
http://www.time.com/time/specials/pa...884760,00.html

Also, where the school taxes are concerned... I grew up in Catholic schools. As a child in a religious school, I tended to agree with people who argued that people who sent their children to religious schools should not have to pay for resources they weren't using (i.e. public school).

That was before I learned that many of the private church-based schools came about in the years following Brown vs. Board of Education.

ETA: So, I don't believe in dropping the taxes for private school-goers anymore. Even though it was a hardship for my family. And I am wrestling with myself over where to send my son for his primary education... I've been leaning towards private, perhaps staying with Montessori... but I worry about what he will learn about race if I do that.
New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Spirituality
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Personal Growth & Spirituality  › Spirituality › Faith and Politics... I'm frustrated...